想起、想到
When I think of Donny Ray Black...The Rainmaker · 1997 — 第 23 / 23 章 · 2'44" · C1
陪審團面前,辯護律師先說自己 I am disgusted with myself(我就厭惡我自己),覺得沒臉做結案陳詞,接著讓唐尼的證詞替他說完。證詞裡一句 Great Benefit insurance denied our claim(大益保險拒賠了),把「拒絕理賠」說成一家人湊不出治療費的原因,聊保險理賠時正好用得上。
庭審最後一步:辯護律師站到陪審團面前,先說「我就厭惡我自己」(I am disgusted with myself),並說整個法律界都沒能救下當事人,自己沒臉做結案陳詞,於是讓唐尼的證詞替他說完。證詞裡講,白血病發現得並不晚,唯一能救命的是骨髓移植,可家裡付不起錢,而大益保險一句 denied our claim(拒絕了我們的理賠)斷了他的路。他還提醒陪審團:這家公司花錢請律師、僱說客,就想讓人相信懲罰性賠償(punitive damages)該廢除。想感嘆對方做到什麼地步,可以用 the lengths to which(竟做到的程度);把決定權交給別人時,可以說 do what you think is right(做你認為對的事)。
這場戲看什麼
留意這幾個短語
gasping for his last breathdisgusted with myselfmake my own summationthe only thing that could save my life
本章短語
拒絕理賠refuse to pay an insurance claim
證詞裡一句 Great Benefit insurance denied our claim,不是否認事實;這是保險語境裡的 deny a claim:拒賠。
Some insurers deny a claim without giving a reason.有些保險公司拒賠卻不給理由。
喘著最後一口氣
恨自己、厭惡自己
做自己的結案陳詞
唯一可能救命的辦法
竟做到的程度
28 句台詞裡標了 28 處
想起、想到
When I think of Donny Ray Black...恨自己、厭惡自己
開場有人用 I am disgusted with myself 自責,把自己和整個法律界一起罵進去,語氣不是撒嬌,而是沉重自省。
I am disgusted with myself...整個法律界
And with the entire legal profession that could not save him.對自己有足夠信心
I don't even feel good enough about myself as a lawyer to make my own summation.結案陳詞——法庭/法律語境用,日常聊天別用
I don't even feel good enough about myself as a lawyer to make my own summation.時間很充裕
The leukemia was detected in plenty of time.骨髓移植
I was in the hospital being treated when the doctors realized that the only thing that could save my life would be a bone-marrow transplant.定語從句:that could save my life 修飾 the only thing,說明唯一能救命的東西。
I was in the hospital being treated when the doctors realized that the only thing that could save my life would be a bone-marrow transplant.付不起、負擔不起
So, I got released from the hospital, 'cause my family couldn't afford to pay the bill for what they had recommended.拒絕理賠
證詞裡一句 Great Benefit insurance denied our claim,不是否認事實;這是保險語境裡的 deny a claim:拒賠。
Great Benefit insurance denied our claim.九成存活機會
If I had had a bone-marrow transplant, I would have had a 90% chance of living.虛擬條件句:had had 是過去完成,would have had 表示過去沒發生的結果;整句在說沒實現的救命機會。
If I had had a bone-marrow transplant, I would have had a 90% chance of living.兩個 had 快說時幾乎併成一拍,a 輕輕滑出,別逐字斷讀。
If I had had a bone-marrow transplant, I would have had a 90% chance of living.從某人手裡拿錢
at the lengths to which a wealthy insurance company, like the defendant, will go to take money from a low-income family and then keep it by denying a legitimate claim.拒絕正當理賠
at the lengths to which a wealthy insurance company, like the defendant, will go to take money from a low-income family and then keep it by denying a legitimate claim.介詞定語從句:to which 從 go to lengths 提前,修飾 lengths;等於 lengths that a company will go to。
at the lengths to which a wealthy insurance company, like the defendant, will go to take money from a low-income family and then keep it by denying a legitimate claim.from a 常弱成很快的一小團,low-income family 才是重音。
at the lengths to which a wealthy insurance company, like the defendant, will go to take money from a low-income family and then keep it by denying a legitimate claim.在某事上花大錢
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.說服我們需要
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.懲罰性賠償
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.難怪、並不意外
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.徹底終止某事
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.賓語從句:convince us 後省略 that,接 we need...;意思是說服我們相信我們需要...
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.put an end to 快說時連成一串,t 輕帶過,重心放在 end 和後面詞。
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.侵權法改革——法律政治討論常用,圈外人可能聽不懂
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.在內心深處
Do what you think is right in your hearts.他們的下一個受害者
You could be their next victim.could 和 be 都弱,their 也輕;重音留給 next victim。
You could be their next victim.I don't even feel good enough about myself as a lawyer to make my own summation.我甚至覺得自己作為律師不夠格,來做我自己的結案陳詞。 用自我貶低開場,反而讓後面的指控更有重量;enough to 結構把職業羞恥和案件責任扣在一起。
If I had had a bone-marrow transplant, I would have had a 90% chance of living.如果我當時做了骨髓移植,我本來有九成機會活下來。 虛擬語氣把“本可活命”釘在拒賠上;數字 90% 讓抽象過錯變成具體生命機率。
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.難怪他們花大錢僱律師、遊說者和公關機器,讓我們相信需要侵權法改革,需要終止懲罰性賠償。 用“難怪”把對方的宣傳預算反轉為罪證;連續三個 their 把企業機器鋪開,最後落到 punitive damages。
Do what you think is right in your hearts.憑你們心中的良知,做你們認為對的事。 簡短、直接,把法律判斷交回陪審團的道德直覺;hearts 讓冷法庭出現溫度。
You could be their next victim.你們可能就是他們的下一個受害者。 六個詞完成警告,把陪審團從旁觀者變成潛在目標;could 比 will 更冷、更耐想。
就是「拒絕理賠」。投保人提出索賠,保險公司不給錢。臺詞裡 Great Benefit insurance denied our claim,說的就是大益保險拒賠,一家人因此湊不出治療費。
the lengths to which。臺詞用它感嘆一家財大氣粗的保險公司,為了從低收入家庭手裡拿錢、再靠拒賠把錢扣下,居然能做到這個地步。
把決定權交給別人、不想替他做主的時候用。臺詞裡它出現在結案陳詞靠後的部分,等於告訴陪審團:按你們的良心判。
disgusted with myself。臺詞裡先出現 I am disgusted with myself,後面又說自己這個律師當得不夠格、沒臉做結案陳詞,自責很重。
punitive damages 是懲罰性賠償,在賠償實際損失之外再罰被告一筆錢。臺詞裡提到保險公司花大錢請律師、僱說客、做公關,就是想讓大家支援廢掉它。
第 1 章cover your draw律所面試談預支薪水
第 2 章every man for himself帶新人熟悉辦公室接拒賠案
第 3 章deny a claim上門請一家人籤委託合同
第 4 章cut someone out of something勸老太太做遺產規劃
第 5 章not charge a dime病房裡拉車禍客戶
第 6 章day in court搭話認識,聊當律師
第 7 章passed the bar通過律考,發獎金又聊上庭
第 8 章on a shoestring勸搭檔撤出去單幹
第 9 章on my behalf沒執照硬闖法庭
第 10 章throw money at法官內庭遭伏擊
第 11 章place an undue burden on新法官追問速審舊案
第 12 章take depositions登門告知取證行程
第 13 章jury tampering竊聽曝光後定下陪審團對策
第 14 章tamper with指控陪審團被動手腳
第 15 章deny a claim母親出庭念拒賠信
第 16 章less than truthful當庭盤問喪子母親
第 17 章a little late for an apology證人席上念出拒賠信
第 18 章paper pusher聽經辦人講拒賠套路
第 19 章playing the odds當庭指認逼她寫信的人
第 20 章preyed on me爭論一份備忘錄能否採納
第 21 章played no part in援引判例推翻異議
第 22 章give or take a few當庭逼問保險證人
正在看 · 第 23 章deny a claim結案陳詞搬出唐尼證詞
Well, I want it all to go to the reverend Kenneth Chandler.

Remember, don't talk to anybody except your doctor.

We can rent a small office, $500 a month.

I'm a very expensive lawyer from a very expensive firm, and, uh...

I'm looking at a team of lawyers who are pulling down a $1,000 an hour, and I hate them.

Great Benefit. July 7, 1996.
劇本裡標出來的說法,每個都有自己的頁面,收著電影裡說它的原句。
“- Wow, you've given me a lot to think about, lawyer man. You're right, I need to be better. I'm going to be better.”
“For me, becoming a lawyer wasn't just ambition. It was identity, a proof that I was capable and I fought for it through the exhaustion, through the self-doubt, through the closed doors, through moments where I questioned whether I was enough, particularly if I was smart enough.”
“But my dear audience, I have learned from my life and me being a stammerer, who can't even speak my name properly. You can believe me, the world doesn't need me perfect lawyers, perfect doctors.”
“Like I I didn't even see myself as Jasmine. Like I'm an attorney. Like I am a lawyer. Like that's what I'm going to do. And you know, I I think, you know, looking back on it, I didn't take the time to like get to know myself.”