Chicago · 2002 — 第 8 / 11 章 · 3'11" · B2

證人席上把殺人說成保命:leading the witness

證人席上,律師先讓她親口承認 illicit relations(不正當男女關係),再一步步問到那句 I closed my eyes, and I shot!(我閉上眼睛,開了槍)。法庭上的問話有套路,談判和彙報裡也用得上。

發生了什麼

洛克西·哈特第一次坐上證人席,替自己辯護。律師先讓她承認那份寫著 illicit relations(不正當男女關係)的供詞,再一步步把她帶回一月十四號那晚:她告訴弗雷德自己有了丈夫的孩子,兩人搶一把槍,她閉著眼睛開了槍。這裡的表達全是法庭味:takes the stand(出庭作證)、leading the witness(誘導證人)、in your own words(用你自己的話說)。看一遍就知道,同樣一件事,換個說法就能從「殺人」變成「保命」——寫申訴、吵架、跟老闆解釋,都是這套路數。

法律与调查 · 法庭冲突 · 审讯盘问坦白解释律师与客户B2中速美音无脏话
IMDb ↗

這場戲看什麼

  • 注意比利如何用問句替羅克西鋪故事
  • 留意羅克西示弱和表演的切換
  • 觀察 objection 與 sustained 的攻防節奏

留意這幾個短語

takes the standillicit relationsdrifted intopestering him

00:00 / 03:11
空白鍵 播放 · ← → 換句 · R 單句循環
此刻
點一句台詞就從那裡放

本章短語

leading the witness

誘導證人asking questions that suggest answers

一句“他威脅你了嗎”剛問出口,對方律師立刻喊反對,說這是在 leading the witness(誘導證人)。這句是法庭攻防的固定話,語氣硬、程式性強。

The judge warned the lawyer against leading the witness.法官警告律師不要誘導證人。

本章還有

  • takes the stand

    出庭作證

  • illicit relations

    不正當男女關係

  • drifted into

    不知不覺陷入

  • pestering him

    一直纏著他

  • in your own words

    用你自己的話說

本章全部批註

59 句台詞裡標了 29 處

短語 · B1
the moment someone has been waiting for

期待已久的時刻

This is the moment we've been waiting for.
語法 · B1
we've been waiting for

定語從句:修飾 the moment,介詞 for 留在句尾;意思是“我們一直等的那個時刻”。

This is the moment we've been waiting for.
發音
we've been

we've 很輕,been 快速滑過,重音留給 waiting

This is the moment we've been waiting for.
短語 · B2
take the stand

出庭作證

這句像現場播報或旁白,宣佈洛克西終於 takes the stand——坐上證人席、為自己作證。正式語氣裡帶著懸念,暗示全場等的就是她開口,為下面對答開場。

Roxie Hart finally takes the stand in her own defense.
短語 · B2
in one's own defense

為某人自己辯護

Roxie Hart finally takes the stand in her own defense.
短語 · C1
have illicit relations with someone

不正當男女關係

律師舉著書面陳述,用 illicit relations(不正當男女關係)逼洛克西承認與死者弗雷德有私情。詞很正式,帶著道德審判,比 affair 更冷、更像法庭用語。

Roxie, I have here a statement in which you admit to having illicit relations with the deceased , Fred.
短語 · B2
admit to doing something

承認做過某事

Roxie, I have here a statement in which you admit to having illicit relations with the deceased , Fred.
語法 · B2
a statement in which you admit

介詞加 which:in which 等於 in the statement,把陳述內容接在名詞後;拆成“你在其中承認…”就順了。

Roxie, I have here a statement in which you admit to having illicit relations with the deceased , Fred.
短語 · B1
personal relationship with someone

與某人的私人關係

Your personal relationship with him -- could you tell the jury when that began?
短語 · A2
go with someone

跟某人走或交往

I don't think I would've gone with him if Mr. Hart and me hadn't quarrelled that very morning .
語法 · C1
I don't think I would've gone with him if

否定轉移:don't think 否定的是後面內容,不是“我不思考”;等於 I think I wouldn't have gone if...

I don't think I would've gone with him if Mr. Hart and me hadn't quarrelled that very morning .
發音
would've gone

would've 的 v 幾乎吞掉,直接滑到 gone

I don't think I would've gone with him if Mr. Hart and me hadn't quarrelled that very morning .
短語 · B2
couldn't stop doing something

忍不住一直煩某人

I suppose I just couldn't stop pestering him .
語法 · B1
couldn't stop pestering him

動名詞賓語:stop doing 是停止做某事;這裡 couldn't stop pestering 指忍不住一直煩他,不是停下來去煩。

I suppose I just couldn't stop pestering him .
短語 · B1
work long hours

長時間工作

I didn't like him working those long hours at the garage.
短語 · B2
drift into something

不知不覺陷入

律師用 drifted into(不知不覺陷入)把洛克西的婚外情說成不是主動選擇,而是因為在家不快樂慢慢滑進去,幫她卸掉責任,聽起來像被環境推著走。

So you drifted into this illicit relationship because you were unhappy at home.
短語 · B2
plead not guilty

不認罪

I'm not guilty. I'm not guilty.
發音
not guilty

重音壓在 not 上,guilty 降調收短

I'm not guilty. I'm not guilty.
短語 · B2
in one's own words

用你自己的話說

律師請洛克西用 in your own words(用你自己的話說)向陪審團講一月十四號那晚。前面的問話一路把答案遞到嘴邊,這句「你自己的話」聽著就更像真的。

Could you tell the jury, in your own words, the happenings of that night?
俚語 · A2
gonna

將要,口語縮略——日常口語常用,正式寫作和法庭陳述裡別用

That me and Amos were gonna have a baby.
短語 · B2
be all over between someone

我們之間徹底結束 不是“到處都在我們之間”,而是關係徹底結束。

And that it was all over between us.
俚語 · B1
Your Honor

法官大人——只在法庭稱呼法官,日常不用

Objection , Your Honor. Counsel is leading the witness!
俚語 · B2
Sustained

反對成立——法庭用語,法官支援律師反對時說

Sustained .
短語 · B2
another man's child

別的男人的孩子

''I'll kill you before I'll see you have another man's child !'' Could you tell the audience -- the jury -- what happened next?
短語 · B1
reach for something

伸手去拿槍

We both reached for the gun , but I got it first.
發音
got it first

got it 兩個 t 輕彈連住,first 重讀收尾

We both reached for the gun , but I got it first.
發音
closed my eyes

closed my 連成一團,eyes 稍拖長再衝 shot

I closed my eyes, and I shot!
短語 · B2
in defense of something

為保命或正當防衛

一句 in defense of your life(為保衛你的生命),把開槍說成自衛,逼出自衛邏輯。短句像替她把結論釘給陪審團。

In defense of your life!
短語 · B1
an unborn child

未出生的孩子

To save my husband's innocent, unborn child !

看懂「證人席上把殺人說成保命」

發音重點

  • we've been — we've 很輕,been 快速滑過,重音留給 waiting
  • would've gone — would've 的 v 幾乎吞掉,直接滑到 gone
  • not guilty — 重音壓在 not 上,guilty 降調收短
  • got it first — got it 兩個 t 輕彈連住,first 重讀收尾
This is the moment we've been waiting for.

這就是我們一直等待的時刻。 短句壓住全場,宣告好戲開場,適合跟讀。

I wanted a real home and a child .

我想要一個真正的家,還有一個孩子。 願望簡單直白,把謀殺案拉回家庭動機。

I killed him . I did , but I'm not a criminal .

我殺了他。我承認,但我不是罪犯。 先認最重的事實,再用 but 翻轉身份,節奏極強。

So it was his life or yours?

所以是他死還是你死? 二選一逼出自衛邏輯,短句像法庭上的釘子。

I closed my eyes, and I shot!

我閉上眼睛,然後開了槍! 兩個動作幾乎同時,畫面感強,情緒在 shot 上爆開。

To save my husband's innocent, unborn child !

為了救我沒出生的、無辜的孩子! 把自衛升級成母性保護,情感牌打到最高。

關於這一章的問題

illicit relations 是什麼意思?

指不正當的男女關係,多用於婚外情這種見不得光的關係。臺詞裡說她承認 having illicit relations with the deceased,就是承認和死者弗雷德有這層關係。

「不知不覺陷入」英語怎麼說?

drifted into。臺詞裡 So you drifted into this illicit relationship,意思是「你就這麼不知不覺陷進了這段關係」。drift 是隨波逐流,強調不是有意為之。

「誘導證人」英語怎麼說?

leading the witness。庭審裡一方問 Did he threaten you 這種把答案塞進問題裡,另一方喊 Counsel is leading the witness(辯護律師在誘導證人),法官回一句 Sustained(反對有效)。

in your own words 是什麼意思?

「用你自己的話說」。臺詞裡讓證人說 Could you tell the jury, in your own words, the happenings of that night,就是別照稿念,用自己的話講一遍。日常讓人複述、面試自我介紹都能用。

「正當防衛」英語怎麼說?

in defense of your life。臺詞裡問 So it was his life or yours?,緊接著一句 In defense of your life!,就是把開槍說成保命。字面是「為保衛你的生命」,法庭上就是正當防衛的說法。

芝加哥 · 共 11 章

全部章節 →
看到第 8 / 11 章 · 後面還有約 9 分鐘