Aladdin · 2019 — Chapter 3 of 24 · 3'34" · B1

Aladdin Shares His Rooftop Home, Explained: Come and go as we please

Two strangers on a rooftop aren't just flirting. "Come and go as we please" is Aladdin's pride in a life nobody owns, and she quietly answers with a life she can't leave. Under the talk of bracelets and silk is a shared ache: both lost their parents, both feel trapped by where they were born.

What happens

Aladdin brings a girl up to the rooftop he calls home and, from her bracelet and imported silk, works out that she serves the princess in the palace. They talk: about coming and going as they please, about the song their mothers taught them, and about feeling trapped by the life they were born into. Then she has to return to the palace.

First datesSmall talkConfessingSmall talkStrangersB1slowamericanClean
IMDb ↗

Listen for

Come and go as we pleasequite thenothing to do withborn into

00:00 / 03:34
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
  1. ❝ MonologueHe reads class off a bracelet5 linesPractice page ↗
  2. ❝ MonologueShe says trapped out loud4 linesPractice page ↗
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

Come and go as we please

In this job you can come and go as you please.

Also in this scene

  • quite the

  • nothing to do with

  • born into

Everything marked in this scene

20 notes across 70 lines

Phrase · C1
come and go as one pleasesJust me and Abu. Come and go as we please.
Sound
Come and go

liaison

Just me and Abu. Come and go as we please.
Phrase · B2
quite the somethingYou are quite the magician.
Phrase · B1
get out of thereThank you. And thank you for getting me out of there.
Sound
out of there

liaison

Thank you. And thank you for getting me out of there.
Phrase · A2
from the palaceFrom the palace.
Grammar · B2
could afford a bracelet

could

Well, only someone from the palace could afford a bracelet like that.
Grammar · C1
which means you are

non-restrictive which

At least, not most servants, which means you are a handmaid to the princess.
Phrase · B2
get out moreI should get out more.
Phrase · B2
in yearsThe people haven't seen her in years.
Phrase · B2
lock someone awaySo she's kept locked away.
Phrase · B2
have nothing to do with somethingBut the people of Agrabah had nothing to do with that.
Phrase · B1
on one's ownBeen on my own ever since.
Sound
on my own

liaison

Been on my own ever since.
Phrase · B2
get byWe get by.
Grammar · B1
things will be different

that-omission

Every day I just think things will be different...
Phrase · B1
seem to do somethingbut it never seems to change.
Phrase · B2
be born into somethingLike you can't escape what you were born into?
Grammar · B2
what you were born into

what-clause

Like you can't escape what you were born into?
Phrase · A2
get back to somewhereI have to get back to the palace.

Aladdin Shares His Rooftop Home, explained

What's really going on

On the surface this is a charming rooftop meet-cute: a street thief guessing a girl's rank from her jewelry, the two of them bonding over a song. But the scene keeps turning toward what each of them can't escape. "Come and go as we please" sounds like freedom until she answers with "They won't let her," describing a princess locked away since the queen was killed. The line about the people having "nothing to do with that" is a first real glimpse of the injustice under the palace walls. When she admits she feels trapped and he asks, "Like you can't escape what you were born into?" the gap between them shrinks: the thief and the handmaid share the same sentence, just different cages. The ease of the rooftop - tea, songs, a view of the city - is exactly what the rest of the story is fighting to keep.

Theme

IdentityBoth admit they feel trapped by the lives they were born into, and the rooftop becomes the one place they can say it out loud.
ClassA street thief reads a girl's rank off her bracelet and silk, making the wall between palace and street the scene's quiet subject.

Listen for

  • Come and go — liaison
  • out of there — liaison
  • on my own — liaison
Just me and Abu. Come and go as we please.

He's showing off the one luxury a street kid has: a home with no rules, where nobody tells him when to stay or go.

You are quite the magician.

A playful compliment dressed as a fact: the guess about her being from the palace was clever, and she says so with a smile.

But the people of Agrabah had nothing to do with that.

He refuses to let the city be blamed for the queen's death, separating ordinary people from the crime that frightened the palace.

Like you can't escape what you were born into?

He names the fear exactly: that your birth decides your whole life, whether you're a thief or a handmaid.

It's all I remember of her.

The song is the only thing left of his mother. Saying it plainly, without self-pity, is what makes the moment land.

Questions about this scene

How does Aladdin figure out that she's from the palace?

He spots her bracelet, which only palace money could buy, and the imported silk lining of her clothes - details most servants wouldn't have.

Why does she say she feels trapped?

She's a handmaid kept inside the palace walls; since the queen was killed, the sultan has kept the princess and everyone around her shut away, so she can't leave.

Do Aladdin and the girl already know each other?

No. They've just met after he helps her escape a chase, and the rooftop is where they start trading stories instead of insults.

Is the rooftop scene romantic?

It leans that way. The two share songs and loss, and by the end neither wants her to go back, though she says she has to return to the palace.

Aladdin · 24 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 3 of 24 · about 87 min to go