Garden State · 2004 — 第 2 / 11 章 · 2'59" · B2

醫生談停藥與心理治療:in no position to comment on

診室裡,一個年輕人正說著反覆發作的頭痛,醫生一句 in no position to comment on(沒資格評論),跟著又把藥說成 as a means to an end(達到目的的手段)。想表達「我不瞭解你,不便下判斷」,這兩句比干巴巴的一句不知道更體面,也更能劃清界限。

發生了什麼

診室裡,一個年輕人告訴醫生自己反覆頭痛,也提到長期服藥、最近停藥,還懷疑自己也許根本沒病。醫生沒有替他下結論,而是用 in no position to comment on(沒資格/不適合評論)說明自己不瞭解他的經歷;又把藥的可能作用說成 as a means to an end(作為達到目的的手段),提醒吃藥只是權宜之計。還有一句 peek its head out of the water(冒頭;浮出水面)很形象:不做心理治療,腦子裡的東西遲早會冒出來。這幾句適合在需要謹慎表態、解釋權宜之計、描述潛伏問題時用。

生活 · 看病解释建议医患B2快速美音无脏话
IMDb ↗

這場戲看什麼

  • 注意醫生先開玩笑再追問的反差節奏
  • 留意病人說藥史時的遲疑和停頓
  • 看醫生如何用隱喻警告不治療的風險

留意這幾個短語

a surge of electricityas far back as I can rememberwrite you a prescriptionit's amazing you can even hear me now

00:00 / 02:59
空白鍵 播放 · ← → 換句 · R 單句循環
此刻
  1. ❝ 獨白醫生的兩條忠告5 句專題跟讀 ↗
點一句台詞就從那裡放

本章短語

in no position to comment on

沒資格/不適合評論not qualified to comment on

醫生先劃清界限:不知道對方完整經歷,所以用 in no position to comment on(沒資格/不適合評論)表示不能替他決定停不停藥。語氣專業、剋制,既給建議又避免越界。

I'm in no position to comment on your family decision.我沒資格評論你家裡的決定。

本章還有

  • a surge of electricity

    一股電流般的感覺

  • as far back as I can remember

    從我記事起

  • write you a prescription

    給你開處方

  • it's amazing you can even hear me now

    反諷:你居然還聽得見我說話

  • know better

    該明白不該這麼做

本章全部批註

42 句台詞裡標了 31 處

俚語 · A2
Just kidding

開個玩笑——熟人玩笑用,正式場合別用。

Just kidding. How would I know that?
發音
What can we

What can we 連成一口氣,can 很輕,別把三個詞拆開重讀。

What can we do for you today, Andrew?
短語 · B1
get really intense headaches

反覆犯劇烈頭痛

I've been getting these really intense headaches.
短語 · B1
a split second

一瞬間;極短時間

Um, they last for, like, a split second.
發音
for, like, a

for, like, a 糊成一小團,like 很輕,重音留給 split second。

Um, they last for, like, a split second.
短語 · B2
a surge of + noun

一股電流般的感覺

病人形容頭痛只持續一瞬,像閃電,又像 a surge of electricity(一股電流般的感覺)衝過,然後消失。語氣在努力找詞,帶點困惑。

It's like lightening. It's like a surge of electricity, and then it's gone.
短語 · B1
some form of something

某種同類藥物 it 指鋰鹽這類藥

Um, I've been on some form of it since I was ten or so.
短語 · B2
as far back as I can remember

從我記事起

病人說,自己可能沒病也不知道,因為 as far back as I can remember(從我記事起),他就一直離不開藥。語氣遲疑,像在拼一段被藥物蓋住的童年。

Only, I'd never know it, because as far back as I can remember, I've been medicated. I left them in L.A., though.
語法 · B2
as far back as I can remember

時間狀語從句:as far back as... 表示時間一直回溯到某點,這裡指“從記事起”。

Only, I'd never know it, because as far back as I can remember, I've been medicated. I left them in L.A., though.
短語 · B1
leave someone's body

從體內代謝掉

Well, that stuff will leave your body pretty fast. I could write you a prescription.
短語 · B1
write someone a prescription

給你開處方

醫生很實際:藥會很快排出體外,需要的話他可以 write you a prescription(給你開處方)。語氣像例行問診,也順手把選擇遞給對方。

Well, that stuff will leave your body pretty fast. I could write you a prescription.
短語 · A2
take a vacation

休假;此處指停藥一段 這裡不是去旅行,是委婉說暫時停藥

Actually, I was thinking about taking a vacation.
短語 · B1
stay on something

繼續服用那種藥 it 指鋰鹽等藥

Yeah, so I think he'd prefer me to stay on it.
短語 · B2
be consumed with + emotion

被壓力和焦慮佔據 consumed 不是被吃掉,是被佔滿

You know, our bodies are capable of doing some very funny things when they're consumed with stress and anxiety.
俚語 · B2
ex-best friend

前死黨——熟人八卦用,正式寫作說 former best friend。

I found my ex-best friend's cufflinks in my wife's purse.
短語 · B2
have someone on + medication

讓你一直服用某藥 on 後省略了鋰鹽

Well, with all the lithium he's had you on, it's amazing you can even hear me now.
發音
had you on

had you 的 /d/ 與 /j/ 常連成 /dʒ/,you 弱化為 /jə/;舌尖輕抵上齒齦再滑向 /j/,重音壓在 had 和 on。

Well, with all the lithium he's had you on, it's amazing you can even hear me now.
語法 · B2
a psychiatrist that isn't your father

定語從句:that isn't your father 修飾 psychiatrist,限定“不是父親”的醫生。

Look, Andrew, first of all, I think you do need to find a psychiatrist that isn't your father.
短語 · B2
should have been + past participle

多年前就該被糾正

That's something that should have been remedied years ago. He knows better!
短語 · B2
know better

該明白不該這麼做

醫生聽到病人的心理醫生就是父親,直接說這事早該糾正,又用 know better(該明白不該這麼做)說父親本該懂邊界。語氣不客氣,帶責備。

That's something that should have been remedied years ago. He knows better!
短語 · C1
be in no position to do something

沒資格/不適合評論

醫生先劃清界限:不知道對方完整經歷,所以用 in no position to comment on(沒資格/不適合評論)表示不能替他決定停不停藥。語氣專業、剋制,既給建議又避免越界。

And secondly... I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not, 'cause I don't know your story.
短語 · B2
know someone's story

瞭解對方經歷 story 不是故事,是病史和經歷

And secondly... I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not, 'cause I don't know your story.
語法 · C1
whether you should stay on the meds or not

whether 從句:whether...or not 作 comment on 的賓語,表示“是否”;去掉後意思不完整。

And secondly... I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not, 'cause I don't know your story.
俚語 · B1
meds

藥——日常口語,正式寫作說 medication。

And secondly... I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not, 'cause I don't know your story.
短語 · B1
since someone is paying for it

既然你付了錢

But my opinion , since you're paying for it, is that yeah, those drugs may help you as a means to an end.
短語 · C1
as a means to an end

作為達到目的的手段

醫生先說自己沒資格判斷,又補一句:既然對方付錢,那藥或許能幫到某個目標,把藥說成 as a means to an end(作為達到目的的手段)。語氣冷靜、務實,不是鼓勵長期依賴。

But my opinion , since you're paying for it, is that yeah, those drugs may help you as a means to an end.
短語 · B1
sooner or later

遲早

But sooner or later, if you're not in therapy, whatever's going on in your mind will find a way to peek its head out of the water.
短語 · B1
find a way to do something

找到辦法做某事

But sooner or later, if you're not in therapy, whatever's going on in your mind will find a way to peek its head out of the water.
語法 · C1
whatever's going on in your mind

主語從句:whatever 引導的從句整體作 will find 的主語,指“你腦子裡不管有什麼事”。

But sooner or later, if you're not in therapy, whatever's going on in your mind will find a way to peek its head out of the water.
發音
sooner or later

sooner or later 整塊快帶,重音落在 soon 和 late,or 幾乎滑過。

But sooner or later, if you're not in therapy, whatever's going on in your mind will find a way to peek its head out of the water.
短語 · A2
take something off

脫掉某物

I'll need you to take your shoes off. I have to scratch your feet.

看懂「醫生談停藥與心理治療」

發音重點

  • What can we — What can we 連成一口氣,can 很輕,別把三個詞拆開重讀。
  • for, like, a — for, like, a 糊成一小團,like 很輕,重音留給 split second。
  • had you on — had you 的 /d/ 與 /j/ 常連成 /dʒ/,you 弱化為 /jə/;舌尖輕抵上齒齦再滑向 /j/,重音壓在 had 和 on。
  • sooner or later — sooner or later 整塊快帶,重音落在 soon 和 late,or 幾乎滑過。
It's recently occurred to me I might not even have a problem.

我最近意識到,我也許根本就沒病。 把多年用藥後的自我懷疑壓成一句,語氣輕卻可怖。

This is the first time I haven't had medicine in my body for a long time.

這是很久以來,我第一次體內沒有藥。 用 first time 加完成時,把“停藥”說成一種陌生的自由。

And secondly... I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not, 'cause I don't know your story.

第二,我沒資格評論你該不該繼續吃藥,因為我不瞭解你的經歷。 把專業邊界說得既坦白又不冷漠,whether 從句拉出猶豫感。

But sooner or later, if you're not in therapy, whatever's going on in your mind will find a way to peek its head out of the water.

但遲早,如果你不做心理治療,你腦子裡的事總會找到辦法冒出頭來。 把心理問題寫成水裡探頭的東西,警告不嚇人卻難忘。

Yeah, you're all right. You're alive.

是的,你沒事。你還活著。 兩句短話都不把話說滿,只遞一個最硬的事實:你還活著,冷裡帶一點暖。

關於這一章的問題

in no position to comment on 是什麼意思?

意思是「沒資格/不適合評論」。醫生說這話,是因為不瞭解對方的情況,所以不判斷對方該不該繼續吃藥。

「作為達到目的的手段」英語怎麼說?

as a means to an end。臺詞裡說那些藥可能幫得上忙,算是達成目的的一種手段;醫生隨後強調,不做心理治療,問題遲早會冒出來。

peek its head out of the water 在臺詞裡指什麼?

字面是「冒頭、浮出水面」,臺詞裡指腦子裡那些東西遲早會找機會顯現出來。醫生用這個說法說明,不做心理治療,問題不會自己消失。

know better 是「更懂」嗎?

不是。臺詞裡的 knows better 是「該明白不該這麼做」,說的是父親本該知道不能這樣安排,這事多年前就該糾正。

write you a prescription 是什麼意思?

意思是「給你開處方」。醫生說那種藥從身體裡排掉很快,接著提出可以開處方,但話題隨後轉向了停藥。

情歸紐澤西 · 共 11 章

全部章節 →
看到第 2 / 11 章 · 後面還有約 29 分鐘