The Crucible · 2014 — 第 14 / 29 章 · 3'45" · B2

Hale Tests Proctor on the Commandments, Explained:bear false witness

Hale is not investigating witchcraft here; he is weighing the Proctors' faith. Elizabeth says openly what she thinks of Parris — "I see no light of God in that man" — and Hale answers by naming the one commandment John cannot recite: adultery. The scene is a quiet interrogation under the guise of a visit.

あらすじ

Reverend Hale visits the Proctor house to test their Christian faith. Elizabeth speaks her mind about Parris, claiming she sees 'no light of God' in him. Hale then asks John to recite the Ten Commandments. John runs through them but forgets adultery, and Elizabeth quietly finishes the list for him. Hale notes a 'softness' in John's record and leaves.

InterrogationsAskingConfrontingB2slowbritishClean
IMDb ↗

注目の表現

lay a hand uponno light of Goda softness in your recordcovet

00:00 / 03:45
Space 再生 · ← → セリフ移動 · R リピート
いま
  1. ❝ 独白Reciting the Commandments11 行練習ページ ↗
セリフをタップするとそこから再生

このシーンの表現

bear false witness

lie about someone

John recites the commandment against bearing false witness, the heart of the trials.

No one should bear false witness against a neighbor.

このシーンの他の表現

  • lay a hand upon

    put a hand on, touch

  • no light of God

    nothing holy in someone

  • a softness in your record

    a weak spot in your record

  • covet

    want what others have

  • a small fault

    a minor fault, in theory

このシーンのメモ一覧

48 行のセリフに 32 件のメモ

表現 · B2lay one's hand upon someone

put a hand on, touch

Elizabeth rebukes Parris for daring to lay his hand upon her child.

I like it not that Mr. Parris should lay his hand upon my baby.
文法 · C1like it not

postponed negation: Putting not after the object, like it not, is old for do not like it.

I like it not that Mr. Parris should lay his hand upon my baby.
表現 · B2not conceal something

not hide something

I see no light of God in that man. I'll not conceal it.
表現 · A2a good sign

a hopeful sign

I hung the door - Oh, did you! That's a good sign, then.
文法 · B2It may be I have been too quick

subject clause: It may be introduces a clause with that dropped, meaning perhaps I rushed.

It may be I have been too quick to bring the but you cannot think we ever desired the
表現 · A2be in someone's mind

be on someone's mind

I think that's in your mind, is it not?
表現 · C1a softness in something

a weak spot in your record

Hale avoids a direct charge and only points to a softness in John's record.

There is a softness in your record, sir, a softness.
表現 · B1be too hard on someone

have been too strict

I think, maybe, we have been too hard with
表現 · C1no mark of blame upon someone

no stain of guilt

There be no mark of blame upon my life, Mr.
文法 · B2There be no mark of blame

archaic there be: There be stands in for there is in this period existential sentence.

There be no mark of blame upon my life, Mr.
発音blame upon

Link the m of blame straight into upon.

There be no mark of blame upon my life, Mr.
表現 · C1a covenanted Christian

a sworn church member

I am a covenanted Christian woman.
スラング · A2Aye

yes, in old speech — Period speech for yes; it sounds theatrical today.

Aye.
文法 · B2Thou shalt not

archaic thou shalt: Thou shalt not is the old form of you shall not, used for solemn commands.

Thou shalt not kill.
スラング · B1Thou

you, old subject form — The old subject form of you, limited to scripture and period texts.

Thou shalt not kill.
表現 · C1covet something

envy what a neighbor owns

Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's goods,
発音shalt not

The t in shalt is often dropped before not.

Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's goods,
表現 · C1make a graven image

a carved idol

nor make unto thee any graven image.
文法 · C1nor make unto thee

nor coordination: Nor continues the negative list, and unto thee means for yourself.

nor make unto thee any graven image.
表現 · C1take the Lord's name in vain

misuse God's name

Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord in
表現 · C1have no other gods before someone

worship nothing above God

thou shalt have no other gods before me.
表現 · B2remember the Sabbath

keep the Sabbath

Thou shalt remember the Sabbath Day and
表現 · B1honor one's father and mother

respect one's parents

Thou shalt honor thy father and mother.
表現 · C1bear false witness

lie about someone

John recites the commandment against bearing false witness, the heart of the trials.

Thou shalt not bear false witness.
発音Adultery

Stress the second syllable: a-DUL-tery.

Adultery, John.
表現 · B1between the two of us

just between us two

between the two of us we do know them all.
表現 · A2a small fault

a minor fault, in theory

After missing one commandment, John plays it down as a small fault, and the understatement is loaded.

I think it be a small fault.
文法 · B2may be accounted

passive voice: The passive may be accounted means cannot be counted as acceptable.

no crack in a fortress may be accounted There be no love for Satan in this house,
表現 · B2suspect someone somewhat

somewhat suspect me

I do think you are suspecting me somewhat?
発音do think

The stressed do adds emphasis: I really do think so.

I do think you are suspecting me somewhat?
表現 · C1add what one may

add whatever one can

My duty is to add what I may to the godlywisdom of the court.
表現 · B1wish someone good health and good fortune

health and good luck

I pray you both good health and good fortune.

「Hale Tests Proctor on the Commandments」を読み解く

What's really going on

The visit looks like a religious examination and works like a trap. Hale asks the Proctors to recite the Ten Commandments, and when John recites them, one is missing: adultery. Elizabeth supplies it — "Adultery, John" — which tells Hale exactly where the fault lies. Hale has already pointed at it with a gentler phrase: "There is a softness in your record, sir." What makes the scene uneasy is that Hale is not hostile. He says he does not judge Goody Proctor and only wants to add to the court's godly wisdom. Yet the commandment John forgets is the one he has broken with Abigail, and everyone in the room can hear it. The trial has not begun, but the Proctors' marriage is already on the record.

Theme

FaithHale tests the household's Christianity by the Commandments, and John's missing answer exposes a spiritual fault.
SecretsJohn's forgotten commandment is adultery, and Hale's 'softness in your record' shows the private sin is no longer hidden.

このチャプターで学べること

  • To bear false witness is to testify falsely.
  • Thou shalt not is the old form of a solemn command.
  • A softness in a record is a weakness a questioner can press.
  • Adultery is stressed on its second syllable.

発音のポイント

  • blame upon — Link the m of blame straight into upon.
  • shalt not — The t in shalt is often dropped before not.
  • Adultery — Stress the second syllable: a-DUL-tery.
  • do think — The stressed do adds emphasis: I really do think so.
I like it not that Mr. Parris should lay his hand upon my baby.

Elizabeth's opening complaint: she resents that Parris blessed or touched her child, blaming him for bringing trouble into the house.

I see no light of God in that man. I'll not conceal it.

Her blunt judgment of Parris: she sees nothing holy in him and refuses to hide her opinion.

There is a softness in your record, sir, a softness.

Hale's coded accusation: something in John's past is weak or compromised, and he repeats the word to make sure it lands.

Theology, sir, is a fortress;

Hale's defense of his discipline: doctrine is a fortress, and any crack in it — any broken commandment — matters.

I pray you both good health and good fortune.

His polite farewell, which lands as a warning rather than a blessing, since he has just found fault with John.

このシーンについての質問

Why does Hale ask John to recite the Ten Commandments?

He is testing John's Christian faith. A covenanted Christian should know the commandments, so failing to name one is a meaningful slip.

Which commandment does John forget?

Adultery. John recites the others but skips it, and Elizabeth supplies it for him, revealing the fault in his record.

What does Hale mean by 'a softness in your record'?

He means there is a flaw or weak spot in John's moral record. It is a polite way of hinting that Hale suspects something without accusing him outright.

Does Hale believe the Proctors are guilty?

He is not sure. He says he does not judge Elizabeth and only wants to add to the court's wisdom, but he clearly keeps his suspicions about John.

What does Elizabeth think of Parris?

She distrusts him. She says she sees 'no light of God' in him and resents him laying a hand on her baby.

The Crucible · 全 29 章

すべて見る →
次のチャプター · 第 15 章wash your hands ofCheever Arrests Elizabeth Proctor
第 1 章at stakeParris Demands the Truth From Abigail第 2 章conjure upAnn Putnam Cries Witchcraft第 3 章breathe a wordAbigail Threatens the Girls第 4 章put it out of mindProctor Rejects Abigail第 5 章wheels within wheelsProctor Clashes With Parris第 6 章weighted with authorityHale Arrives With His Books第 7 章keep your wits about youHale Brings the Devil's Books第 8 章conjureHale Interrogates Abigail and Tituba第 9 章turn your back onTituba Confesses and Names Names第 10 章nightfallElizabeth Urges Proctor to Testify第 11 章hard as rockMary Warren Defies John Proctor第 12 章come to thisElizabeth Fears Abigail Wants Her Place第 13 章God forbidHale Visits the Proctors at Night再生中 · 第 14 章bear false witnessHale Tests Proctor on the Commandments第 15 章wash your hands ofCheever Arrests Elizabeth Proctor第 16 章make your peace withProctor Forces Mary to Testify第 17 章take it upon yourselfGiles Corey Storms the Court第 18 章have no love forProctor Refuses to Drop the Charge第 19 章put-uponFrancis Nurse Presents the Petition第 20 章have no bearing onProctor Accuses Abigail in Court第 21 章search your heartProctor Confesses Adultery in Court第 22 章given to understandElizabeth Lies to Protect Proctor第 23 章deadly sinThe Girls Turn on Mary Warren第 24 章his majestyTituba and Sarah Go to Barbados第 25 章reckon withParris Reports Abigail Has Vanished第 26 章cast doubt uponHale Begs Danforth to Postpone第 27 章cleave toHale Urges Elizabeth to Save Proctor第 28 章one foot in HeavenElizabeth Visits John in Prison第 29 章have no tongue for itProctor Refuses to Name Others
第 14 / 29 章 · 残り約 65 分