Atlas Shrugged: Part I · 2011 — 第 5 / 16 章 · 2'56" · B2

Owen Kellogg Resigns from Taggart, Explained:name your price

Owen Kellogg comes to hand in his resignation, effective immediately, and refuses every offer Dagny makes — a promotion, double the pay, and finally "Name your price." His answer, "Nothing, nothing on Earth," makes the exit final, and he leaves her with a question: "Who is John Galt?"

あらすじ

At her office, Dagny Taggart first argues with James about the Mexican line she has stripped of anything valuable. Then Owen Kellogg arrives to resign on the spot. Dagny offers him a promotion, double the salary of any other railroad, and any terms he wants, but he turns it all down and leaves her with the question, "Who is John Galt?"

Talking to the bossNegotiationSaying noPersuadingBoss & employeeB2mediumamericanClean
IMDb ↗

注目の表現

in the gameyou'd be surprisedpolitical favorsnationalize

00:00 / 02:56
Space 再生 · ← → セリフ移動 · R リピート
いま
  1. ❝ 独白James defends the pullout4 行練習ページ ↗
セリフをタップするとそこから再生

このシーンの表現

name your price

say what you want

To keep Owen, Dagny keeps raising the offer and finally tells him to name his price.

Name your price and I'll pay it.

このシーンの他の表現

  • in the game

    still competing

  • you'd be surprised

    it is more than you think

  • political favors

    help traded by influence

  • nationalize

    put under state control

  • resignation

    formal quitting

このシーンのメモ一覧

53 行のセリフに 27 件のメモ

表現 · B1look forward to something

anticipate with pleasure

Thank you, Mr. McNamara. I look forward to working with you as well.
表現 · B2take over something

take charge of

I found an excellent contractor to takeover the rebuilding of the Rio Norte Line.
表現 · B1get something done

be completed

You'd be surprised how quickly things get done when you do some actual work...
文法 · B2how quickly things get done

embedded question: The how-clause is the object of be surprised and names the surprising fact.

You'd be surprised how quickly things get done when you do some actual work...
発音get done

The t in get often drops, almost like ge-done.

You'd be surprised how quickly things get done when you do some actual work...
表現 · B1rely on something

depend on

...and don't rely on political favors.
表現 · A2passenger train

a train for people

Is this accurate? Just one passenger train per day on the Mexican line?
表現 · B1every other + 时间

on alternate nights

And one freight every other night? Yes.
表現 · B2develop an area

build up a region

How are the Mexicans gonna develop the area...
スラング · A2gonna

going to — Everyday speech; avoid it in formal writing.

How are the Mexicans gonna develop the area...
表現 · A2once a day

daily

...with a single passenger train once a day?
スラング · B2looters

people who steal in chaos — A disapproving word for those who steal during disorder.

There's nothing for looters once the Mexicans nationalize.
表現 · B2get back in the game

compete again

That Mexican line was helping those destitute people get back in the game.
表現 · B1take something away from someone

deprive someone of everything

You can't just take everything away from people who need our help.
文法 · B1people who need our help

relative clause: The who-clause specifies exactly which people are being talked about.

You can't just take everything away from people who need our help.
スラング · A2Okay

all right — Casual agreement; in writing prefer all right.

Move. Okay
表現 · C1effective immediately

starting right now

I've have come to give you my resignation. Effective immediately.
発音Effective immediately

Effective links straight into immediately, almost as one phrase.

I've have come to give you my resignation. Effective immediately.
表現 · B1no longer do something

not any more

But you no longer wish to work for Taggart Transcontinental?
表現 · B2offer someone a promotion

give a higher post

I actually called you in here today to offer you a promotion.
文法 · B1offer you a promotion

double object: Offer takes two objects: the person who receives and the thing being given.

I actually called you in here today to offer you a promotion.
表現 · B2double what someone offers

offer twice as much

I'll double what any other railroad is offering.
表現 · B2keep one's word

honor a promise

Owen explains that he is not upset with anyone; he simply wants to keep his word.

...because I promised you once that I would and I wanna keep my word.
文法 · B2I promised you once that I would

object clause with ellipsis: The object clause drops keep my word at the end, leaving would to carry the promise.

...because I promised you once that I would and I wanna keep my word.
発音wanna keep

Wanna weakens and slides into keep with no pause.

...because I promised you once that I would and I wanna keep my word.
スラング · A2wanna

want to — Very casual; use want to in formal settings.

...because I promised you once that I would and I wanna keep my word.
表現 · C1write one's own ticket

set your own terms

Write your own ticket, Owen.

「Owen Kellogg Resigns from Taggart」を読み解く

What's really going on

The scene is built on a refusal, and the refusal keeps getting larger. Owen Kellogg will not name a reason, will not be bought, and will not even say where he is going; his only explanation is that he promised to tell her, "because I promised you once that I would and I wanna keep my word." Dagny, who has just been lectured by James about taking everything from people who need help, does the same thing here with money and titles — every offer is an attempt to keep a valuable man in place. What defeats her is not a counter-offer but an absence of any want she can satisfy: "Nothing, nothing on Earth." The final line turns the private resignation into something larger, the film's recurring question about John Galt. The point is not that Owen is stubborn; it is that the people Dagny most needs are quietly leaving, and no price is holding them.

Theme

MoneyDagny throws promotions and double pay at Owen, and all of it fails, showing what money cannot buy.
PhilosophyOwen leaves for a reason he won't explain and answers only with the question, "Who is John Galt?"

このチャプターで学べること

  • Owen leaves to keep a promise, not out of anger.
  • Dagny offers a promotion, then any price at all.
  • The Mexican line was a moral question to her.
  • The scene ends on a question everyone repeats.

発音のポイント

  • get done — The t in get often drops, almost like ge-done.
  • Effective immediately — Effective links straight into immediately, almost as one phrase.
  • wanna keep — Wanna weakens and slides into keep with no pause.
You'd be surprised how quickly things get done when you do some actual work...

Dagny's jab at James: real work and no political favors get results faster than he assumes.

You should know I moved everything of value out of Mexico a month ago.

Dagny had already pulled her assets before nationalization, so the coming takeover will leave looters nothing.

You can't just take everything away from people who need our help.

James's objection: he sees the empty Mexican line as abandoning the poor, while Dagny sees no reason to keep investing.

I've have come to give you my resignation. Effective immediately.

Owen's blunt opening: he is quitting at once, with no notice and no sign that anything at work caused it.

...because I promised you once that I would and I wanna keep my word.

His one stated reason for telling her in person: an old promise, which makes the departure feel chosen rather than forced.

So there's nothing I can offer you?

Dagny's question before the final refusal — she has exhausted money, title, and terms, and knows it.

このシーンについての質問

Why does Owen Kellogg resign?

He refuses to give a reason, saying only that it is personal and that no person or event at work caused it. The film leaves it unexplained, which is the point: the best people are leaving for reasons they won't name.

Why won't Owen take Dagny's offers?

Promotions and double pay mean nothing to him. He says he will not work for any railroad, and when Dagny asks what she can offer, he answers, "Nothing, nothing on Earth."

Why does Owen answer with "Who is John Galt?"?

It is the film's recurring question, spoken when no one can explain why things go wrong. By ending the meeting with it, Owen suggests his departure is part of something larger he will not name.

Why does Dagny want Owen to stay so badly?

He is the man she trusted to rebuild the Rio Norte Line, and she calls him in specifically to promote him. Losing him means losing someone she considers essential to the railroad.

What does "name your price" mean?

It means to ask for whatever terms you want. Dagny says it to Owen as a last resort, offering him any salary or conditions if he will stay.

Atlas Shrugged: Part I · 全 16 章

すべて見る →
第 5 / 16 章 · 残り約 30 分