The Death of Stalin · 2017 — Chapter 7 of 15 · 4'34" · C1

The Committee Meets After Stalin, Explained: test of your discretion

The body isn't cold and the committee is already dividing power. The polite formula is 'in accordance with his will'; the knife is hidden in compliments like "Wouldn't it be kinder if someone else carried the happy burden of Vice-Chairman?" Every vote ends the same way: carried unanimously.

What happens

After Stalin's death, the committee meets and the meeting is called to order. Moves are made to name Malenkov chairman and Beria first vice-chairman; both pass. Khrushchev is handed the funeral. Then a halt to arrests and the release of some detainees under Article 31 is proposed, argued over, and carried as well.

MeetingsArgumentsSuggestingConfrontingRivalsC1slowbritish
IMDb ↗

Listen for

cynical ploytest of your discretionhappy burdenwiping your arse on

00:00 / 04:34
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
  1. ❝ MonologueA Defense of Loyalty8 linesPractice page ↗
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

test of your discretion

a check on your secrecy

A polite tag question disguises a warning: prove you can keep this quiet.

They called it a test of your discretion, but it felt like a threat.

Also in this scene

  • cynical ploy

    a manipulative trick

  • happy burden

    ironic phrase for a desirable burden

  • wiping your arse on

    to treat something with gross contempt

  • blatant attempt

    an obvious, shameless try

  • stick to what we believed in

    keep to one's old beliefs

Everything marked in this scene

28 notes across 74 lines

Phrase · B2
outline the something

summarize the releases here, releases means prisoner releases

So I'll outline the releases under Article 31.
Phrase · C1
a cynical ploy

a manipulative trick

Someone denies that the reforms are a manipulative trick before anyone can accuse them.

Please, understand that this is not some cynical ploy.
Sound
not some cynical

In fast speech, not some runs together; keep the stress on cynical.

Please, understand that this is not some cynical ploy.
Phrase · A2
have a bad back

a painful back

It's a girdle. I have a bad back.
Phrase · C1
a test of someone's discretion

a check on your secrecy

A polite tag question disguises a warning: prove you can keep this quiet.

Let's make this a test of your discretion, shall we?
Sound
test of your

Let test of your flow as one chunk, with the main stress on discretion.

Let's make this a test of your discretion, shall we?
Phrase · B2
in accordance with something

according to his will

So, in accordance with his will, I propose Comrade Malenkov be named Chairman of the Council of Ministers and General Secretary of the Party.
Grammar · C1
be named

subjunctive: After propose, the verb can stay in the base form: be named, not is named. It marks a motion, not a fact.

So, in accordance with his will, I propose Comrade Malenkov be named Chairman of the Council of Ministers and General Secretary of the Party.
Sound
in accordance with

Treat in accordance with as a quick transition; stress accordance and glide over with.

So, in accordance with his will, I propose Comrade Malenkov be named Chairman of the Council of Ministers and General Secretary of the Party.
Phrase · B1
take a vote on something

hold a vote

So, let's take a vote. Those in favour?
Phrase · B2
separate proposals

two distinct motions

Those are two separate proposals.
Grammar · C1
if someone else carried

hypothetical conditional: The past-form carried makes the suggestion hypothetical, softening a power grab into a polite question.

Wouldn't it be kinder if someone else carried the happy burden of Vice-Chairman?
Phrase · B2
be perfectly capable of doing something

well able to multitask

I thank Comrade Khrushchev for his concern, but I'm perfectly capable of doing two things at once.
Phrase · B2
move to a vote on something

proceed to voting

The chair cuts off debate and pushes the room into voting on both proposals.

All right, let's move to a vote on both proposals.
Phrase · B1
take charge of something

be in charge of it

We need someone to take charge of the funeral.
Phrase · C1
be given the honour of doing something

be honoured with the task

I formally propose Comrade Khrushchev be given the honour of organising the funeral.
Phrase · B2
honour someone's legacy

respect his legacy

You said you wanted to honour his legacy.
Sound
wiping your arse

In fast delivery, the g in wiping is barely there; punch arse and link into on.

Whoa, whoa. That's like wiping your arse on Stalin's final list.
Slang · B1
arse

arse/ass — British vulgar; avoid in formal settings.

Whoa, whoa. That's like wiping your arse on Stalin's final list.
Phrase · C1
make someone look + adjective

make us look idiotic

Releasing people we arrested three days ago will make us look cretinous.
Grammar · C1
Releasing people we arrested three days ago

gerund subject: A long gerund phrase is the subject; the main verb arrives late at will make. It keeps the accusation formal and heavy.

Releasing people we arrested three days ago will make us look cretinous.
Slang · B1
kidding

joking or deceiving — Informal rhetorical question; don't use with strangers in formal contexts.

Who are you kidding, Lavrenti, yourself?
Phrase · B1
know what one is doing

know exactly what one does

We all knew what we were doing when we signed those lists.
Phrase · C1
buy someone's support

purchase public support not literal purchase; to win support

This is a blatant attempt by Comrade Beria to buy the support of the public.
Phrase · B2
an iron will

a strong will

However, he also had an iron will, undeviating, strong.
Phrase · B2
stick to what one believes in

keep to one's old beliefs

A rhetorical question appeals to principle, asking everyone to keep to what they believed in.

Should we not do the same and stick to what we believed in?
Phrase · C1
forge one's own beliefs

create one's own beliefs

It is stronger still to forge our own beliefs with the beliefs of the collective leadership.
Grammar · C1
It is stronger still to forge

extraposition: It is a placeholder for the infinitive clause. The structure lets the speaker stress stronger still before revealing the real action.

It is stronger still to forge our own beliefs with the beliefs of the collective leadership.

The Committee Meets After Stalin, explained

What's really going on

Nothing in this room is about policy; it is about who ends up holding what. The language is deliberately bloodless — a promotion arrives “in accordance with his will”, and blocking a rival's promotion is dressed up as kindness: “Wouldn't it be kinder if someone else carried the happy burden of Vice-Chairman?” The reply is that the target is “perfectly capable of doing two things at once”, a reminder that he already runs both Interior and Security. Later, when a halt to arrests is proposed, the objection isn't moral but reputational — releasing people arrested three days ago would “make us look cretinous” — and the answer is that “we all knew what we were doing when we signed those lists.”

Theme

PowerChairmanships, a funeral and a prisoner release are all traded as chips in the same meeting.
SatireReform is proposed and denounced in the same breath, and every vote still comes back 'unanimously'.

Listen for

  • not some cynical — In fast speech, not some runs together; keep the stress on cynical.
  • test of your — Let test of your flow as one chunk, with the main stress on discretion.
  • in accordance with — Treat in accordance with as a quick transition; stress accordance and glide over with.
  • wiping your arse — In fast delivery, the g in wiping is barely there; punch arse and link into on.
Please, understand that this is not some cynical ploy.

A pre-emptive denial: the reforms aren't a cold calculation for advantage — which is exactly what the room suspects they are.

Let's make this a test of your discretion, shall we?

A polite way of saying keep quiet about what you just saw and heard. Calling it a 'test' turns silence into a matter of loyalty.

Wouldn't it be kinder if someone else carried the happy burden of Vice-Chairman?

'Happy burden' is sarcasm: the post is power, not a burden. He is proposing to take the job away while sounding gracious.

Whoa, whoa. That's like wiping your arse on Stalin's final list.

The objection is about insult, not policy: reversing Stalin's last orders so soon would publicly trash his authority.

We have loosened the Union's great corset.

A callback to the girdle mentioned earlier: the releases are sold as relief from something tight and confining.

Questions about this scene

What does Beria propose about the arrests and the detainees?

He proposes “a halt to deportations, the release of some existing detainees under Article 31 and the suspension of all arrests that were officially sanctioned three days ago.” Others object that releasing people arrested three days earlier would “make us look cretinous” and call it “a blatant attempt by Comrade Beria to buy the support of the public.”

Is the vote on Malenkov and Beria one proposal or two?

Two. "Those are two separate proposals," someone objects, and the reply is that they should "vote one at a time" — though the room then moves to a vote on both anyway, recorded as "Carried... unanimously."

Why is Khrushchev unhappy about organising the funeral?

The answer to the proposal is "What? Come on, I don't have any time to do that" and "What do I know about funerals?" The vote passes regardless, followed by "Nicky Khrushchev, funeral director. It suits you."

Why does Beria say he can do two things at once?

"I'm perfectly capable of doing two things at once" is the reply to a suggestion that someone else carry the vice-chairmanship. The earlier complaint was that he is "busy combining his role as Minister for both Interior and Security" — so the line doubles as a warning.

The Death of Stalin · 15 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 7 of 15 · about 24 min to go