The Death of Stalin · 2017 — Chapter 13 of 15 · 2'35" · B2

Beria Threatens the Room With Files, Explained: carry the can

The 1,500 dead are the opening bid in a blame auction: one side says the trains ran again, the other says the guns fired. "Are you blaming the dead for their own death?" Nobody wants to carry the can — so someone reaches for his files.

What happens

A meeting-room argument after 1,500 people are killed. Someone asks who will carry the can, and fingers point at whoever restarted the trains and at the officers who fired. When the shouting turns to a signature on a file, dates and names get read out loud.

AccusationsMeetingsConfrontingThreateningRivalsB2fastbritish
IMDb ↗

Listen for

carry the canthere's no point topossess a working brainshit sack

00:00 / 02:35
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
  1. ❝ MonologueDaggers and Documents5 linesPractice page ↗
  2. ❝ MonologueReading out the list8 linesPractice page ↗
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

carry the can

take the blame for others

With a massacre to explain, someone bluntly asks who will carry the can — and the question lands on everyone at the table.

Someone has to carry the can for the missing files.

Also in this scene

  • there's no point to

    no argument behind it, and no use

  • possess a working brain

    sarcastic: are you still thinking?

  • shit sack

    a worthless piece of shit

  • have a pop at somebody

    criticize or attack someone

  • prop up

    hold up; keep something standing

Everything marked in this scene

32 notes across 56 lines

Phrase · A2
do somebody a favour

do a small favour for me

If you could do me a favour and just nod as I'm speaking.
Grammar · B1
If you could do me a favour

polite conditional: Not a real condition — 'if you could' softens a request into a favour being asked.

If you could do me a favour and just nod as I'm speaking.
Sound
and just nod

'And' shrinks to a light n; keep 'just nod' as one quick beat.

If you could do me a favour and just nod as I'm speaking.
Phrase · B2
look to somebody for something

expect reassurance from me

People are looking to me for reassurance and I have no idea what is going on.
Phrase · A2
have no idea what / why ...

have no clue at all

People are looking to me for reassurance and I have no idea what is going on.
Sound
looking to me

Run 'looking to me' together, with 'to' barely there.

People are looking to me for reassurance and I have no idea what is going on.
Phrase · B1
bring something under control

get the situation under control

We will bring the situation under control. Order will be restored.
Slang · B2
pissed their pants

got so scared they lost it — Mocking, informal; too crude for work or formal talk.

And your men pissed their pants and killed 1500 people.
Phrase · B1
be supposed to do something

were not meant to be there

Those people weren't supposed to be there.
Slang · B2
shit sack

worthless piece of shit — A filthy insult; never use it in public or professional settings.

This shit sack is going to be blamed.
Phrase · C1
carry the can for something

take the blame for others

With a massacre to explain, someone bluntly asks who will carry the can — and the question lands on everyone at the table.

Who's gonna carry the can for this farrago of shit?
Sound
gonna carry

Glide through 'gonna' and land the stress on 'carry the can'.

Who's gonna carry the can for this farrago of shit?
Slang · C1
farrago of shit

a total mess of nonsense — British and crude; describes an absurd mess, not for polite company.

Who's gonna carry the can for this farrago of shit?
Phrase · B1
have a point

be right about something

- Yes, he has a point. - No, he doesn't.
Phrase · B2
officers on the ground

the people actually at the scene here it means officers at the scene, not literally on the floor

Right? Hothead officers on the ground.
Phrase · B2
be made the villain for something

be cast as the one to blame

You dumb animal. I am the security forces and I'm not gonna be made the villain for this catastrophe.
Slang · B2
dumb animal

stupid brute — A direct insult to someone's intelligence; only in a fight.

You dumb animal. I am the security forces and I'm not gonna be made the villain for this catastrophe.
Phrase · C1
close ranks against somebody

unite and defend each other

Look, even if you do get blamed, we close ranks.
Grammar · B2
even if you do get blamed

concessive with do: 'Even if you do get blamed' concedes the worst case and stresses it with 'do'.

Look, even if you do get blamed, we close ranks.
Phrase · C1
have a pop at somebody

criticize or attack someone

When one man is singled out for blame, another promises the group will stand in front of him.

If anyone has a pop at you, they have to come through us first.
Phrase · B2
be somebody's own doing

be your own fault

- A lot of this is your own doing. - You spineless rat.
Slang · B2
spineless rat

a cowardly, sneaky person — Accuses someone of cowardice and treachery; far too harsh for work.

- A lot of this is your own doing. - You spineless rat.
Phrase · B2
prop somebody up

hold somebody upright

You're just a cadaver we propped up in a corset.
Grammar · B2
a cadaver we propped up

contact relative clause: The clause 'we propped up' modifies 'cadaver' with the relative pronoun left out.

You're just a cadaver we propped up in a corset.
Grammar · B2
It's time all of you realised

It's time + past: After 'It's time', the past tense means 'you should already have done this'.

It's time all of you realised who kept the daggers out of your backs.
Slang · B2
fucking respect

show some damn respect — A vulgar intensifier used when someone loses their temper.

Show some fucking respect. I... I've got... I've got...
Phrase · B2
have documents on somebody

hold incriminating files about you not paperwork but evidence that can destroy them

I've got documents. I have documents on all of you.
Phrase · A2
be written down

recorded in writing

I know the truth. It's all written down.
Sound
all written down

The t inside 'written' nearly disappears; the pause before 'long list' does the drama.

It's all written down on a very... on a very fucking long list!
Phrase · B2
nominate somebody as a scapegoat

pick people to take the blame

I will nominate some scapegoats.
Phrase · A2
a couple of + 复数名词

a few of the officers

We can arraign a couple of the officers who fired.
Grammar · B1
the officers who fired

relative clause: The clause 'who fired' narrows 'the officers' to the ones who actually shot.

We can arraign a couple of the officers who fired.

Beria Threatens the Room With Files, explained

What's really going on

Nobody in this room is arguing about the dead. The argument is about who gets written into the record as the man who signed off on them. The tidy answer on the table — blame the officers on the ground — is refused outright: "I am the security forces and I'm not gonna be made the villain for this catastrophe." What follows is the language of loyalty: close ranks, and anyone who has a pop at you comes through us first. Then the documents come out, and the meeting stops being about 1,500 deaths. Dates, a number of dead, a signature — the rest of the scene is about which of these men can still be unmade by paperwork.

Theme

PowerThe room isn't deciding what happened; it's deciding whose version of it survives, using dates and signatures.
BetrayalBlame is a commodity: officers on the ground are offered up so the men at the top stay covered.

Listen for

  • and just nod — 'And' shrinks to a light n; keep 'just nod' as one quick beat.
  • looking to me — Run 'looking to me' together, with 'to' barely there.
  • gonna carry — Glide through 'gonna' and land the stress on 'carry the can'.
  • all written down — The t inside 'written' nearly disappears; the pause before 'long list' does the drama.
Are you blaming the dead for their own death?

Turning the excuse back on whoever offered it: saying the crowd shouldn't have been there is not a reason they deserved to be shot.

Yeah, well, you signed off the life of your own brother!

A reminder that the paperwork being waved around is not abstract: one signature here sent a member of someone's own family to his death.

You're just a cadaver we propped up in a corset.

The insult that ends the argument: the man being held upright is a corpse in a corset, kept standing by the same people now being threatened.

It's time all of you realised who kept the daggers out of your backs.

A claim of protection used as leverage: whoever holds the files says he is the reason none of them were stabbed in the back.

Only comrades and friends could shout at each other like this.

The shouting is declared normal, even affectionate, minutes after documents were used as threats — the fight gets filed as friendship.

Questions about this scene

Why does the argument keep coming back to the trains?

Because the deaths need a cause that isn't the shooting. One line puts it plainly: the trains were put back on, and the people getting off them were shot. Whichever decision gets named first is the one left holding it.

What does "carry the can" mean in this scene?

To take the blame. The question opens the bidding — who is going to carry the can — and the first answer offered names the man who put the trains back on.

What happens when the documents come out?

Someone starts reading: a date, a trial, forty-two dead, 173 exiled, then "your signature." The reaction is immediate — "Beria, that's enough!" — and the accusations turn to who signed what.

Why won't the officers simply be blamed?

Because one line answers that with "I am the security forces and I'm not gonna be made the villain for this catastrophe." The officers being offered up are that man's own, so the blame would land on him.

Why does the meeting end by naming officers to arraign?

Because a scapegoat is still needed. The closing exchange offers to nominate some scapegoats and to arraign a couple of the officers who fired, then moves the whole thing to a committee.

The Death of Stalin · 15 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 13 of 15 · about 6 min to go