The Death of Stalin · 2017 — Chapter 11 of 15 · 3'03" · C1

Molotov Apologizes for Polina, Explained: make something up as you go along

The men planning Stalin's funeral are arguing about bishops when the talk turns to how Polina Molotova was declared a traitor. Someone forces a confession out of the man who once insisted on her guilt: "I beg your forgiveness for my selfish deceitfulness." The answer isn't comfort but a warning — in this room, yesterday's loyalty becomes tomorrow's crime.

What happens

While planning Stalin's funeral, the men bicker about bishops and old grudges. Talk turns to Polina Molotova, condemned as a traitor, and the man who once called her guilty is pushed into apologizing and promising to reassure her. Then the orders change: restart the trains, reopen Moscow, let the people back in.

Goodbyes & funeralsAccusationsConfrontingApologizingRivalsC1fastbritish
IMDb ↗

Listen for

look forward toany oldboyfriends of ChristPast tense

00:00 / 03:03
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

make something up as you go along

invent it on the fly

Someone accuses another of inventing the whole line on the spot, with shit making the insult blunt and vulgar.

Don't make something up as you go along; check the facts.

Also in this scene

  • look forward to

    await with pleasure

  • any old

    any random, dismissive

  • boyfriends of Christ

    sneering label for priests or bishops

  • Past tense

    pun on grammar tense and past era

  • bit on the side

    secret lover, mistress

Everything marked in this scene

34 notes across 56 lines

Phrase · B1
look forward to something

await with pleasure

During funeral planning, someone uses the polite phrase look forward to about a few garbled words, and the tone is sarcastic rather than eager.

I look forward to the five garbled words we afford him before we start the flypast.
Grammar · C1
we afford him

relative clause: The clause modifies words and omits that/which: the few lines they let him say.

I look forward to the five garbled words we afford him before we start the flypast.
Sound
look forward to

Keep to light and put the beat on forward; do not read each word separately.

I look forward to the five garbled words we afford him before we start the flypast.
Phrase · B1
be pals with someone

be friendly or allied with someone

Who else are we pals with now?
Slang · B1
pals

friends or allies — Casual for friends or allies; avoid in formal contexts.

Who else are we pals with now?
Phrase · B1
any old + plural noun

any random, unwanted people Not old Nazis; any old means any random ones.

- You invite any old Nazis? - Excuse me.
Sound
more sweat than

Stress more and sweat, then let than man fade with a self-mocking tone.

I'm more sweat than man.
Phrase · B1
see someone off

say goodbye to someone departing

- Did you see off Vasily? - Yes, we did.
Phrase · B2
land someone something

get someone a job or opportunity Not making the funeral land; landing someone something means getting them a job or opportunity.

And thank you for landing me this funeral.
Slang · C1
boyfriends of Christ

sneering label for priests — A mocking jab at clergy; do not use in formal or interfaith settings.

What, you think I wanted those boyfriends of Christ here?
Phrase · B2
of all people

especially you; you above all Not belonging to everyone; it means especially you, of all people.

Lavrenti, you of all people must know that religion has never been part of...
Sound
you of all people

Link of all into one quick unit, stressing all and people; start you briskly.

Lavrenti, you of all people must know that religion has never been part of...
Phrase · B2
insist on something

keep insisting on guilt

You lecturing me? You standing in the Hall of Columns still insisting on Polina's guilt?
Phrase · B2
call someone a traitor and a parasite

brand someone a traitor and parasite

No, no. You both called the blameless Polina Molotova a traitor and a parasite in her own apartment. I heard you.
Phrase · B2
find someone guilty

declare someone guilty

She was guilty. You found her guilty.
Phrase · B2
the good old days

the supposedly better past Ironic here, not nostalgic: that past was deadly.

In the good old days you pine for,
Grammar · C1
you pine for

relative clause: The clause modifies the good old days and omits which/that: the past you long for.

In the good old days you pine for,
Phrase · C1
have someone shot

would have caused you both to be shot Not you both shooting; it means causing you both to be shot.

that sort of dissonance would have had you both shot. Both of you.
Grammar · C1
would have had you both shot

counterfactual causative: Would have + had + object + past participle: in that past, this would have got you shot.

that sort of dissonance would have had you both shot. Both of you.
Slang · B2
fucking

vulgar intensifier — Vulgar intensifier for anger or emphasis; never formal.

Oh, this is just fucking wordplay.
Phrase · C1
allegiance to something

loyalty to the official line

Allegiance to the party line, hm? That was what Stalin demanded.
Phrase · C1
mark someone out as something

make someone appear to be a traitor Not marking physically; it means identifying or exposing you as a traitor.

And defiance of the party line, that would mark you out as a traitor, wouldn't it?
Grammar · C1
would mark you out as a traitor

conditional result: Fronted topic defiance is picked up by that; would mark states the consequence.

And defiance of the party line, that would mark you out as a traitor, wouldn't it?
Phrase · B2
beg someone's forgiveness

ask for forgiveness

I beg your forgiveness for my selfish deceitfulness, and I will go and reassure Polina.
Sound
shit up as

Glide through shit up as without a pause, keeping the beat on making.

You're just making this shit up as you go along.
Slang · B2
shit

vulgar for nonsense — Vulgar dismissal of nonsense; avoid at work or with elders.

You're just making this shit up as you go along.
Slang · C1
bit-on-the-side

secret lover — British slang for a secret lover; insulting, not for polite use.

This from the man who invited his bit-on-the-side whore pianist to play at the funeral, even though she swore to kill Stalin, who's now dead.
Slang · C1
whore

vulgar insult for a woman — A severe insult; avoid entirely in formal or civil speech.

This from the man who invited his bit-on-the-side whore pianist to play at the funeral, even though she swore to kill Stalin, who's now dead.
Slang · C1
barrelling fuck

vulgar intensifier of confusion — Vulgar and forceful; best avoided in real polite speech.

Whoa. What the barrelling fuck are you talking about?
Phrase · B2
let someone back into a place

allow people to return to a place

Open the city's borders and let the people back into Moscow.
Phrase · B1
deserve to do something

ought to be allowed to see

They deserve to see the old man.
Phrase · B1
cope with something

deal with something difficult

Let's see how Beria's goons cope with that.
Sound
cope with that

Let with almost disappear; stress cope and that.

Let's see how Beria's goons cope with that.
Slang · B2
goons

thugs, enforcers — Sneering term for enforcers; avoid in neutral reporting.

Let's see how Beria's goons cope with that.

Molotov Apologizes for Polina, explained

What's really going on

Nobody here is really arguing about bishops. The fight is about who survives the funeral, and the weapon is language. "Nobody doubted. Past tense, you see" turns grammar into a knife: yesterday's certainty is today's evidence, and the man who once repeated the verdict now has to eat it. His apology — "I beg your forgiveness for my selfish deceitfulness" — is not contrition but arithmetic: he gives up the words and keeps the seat. Hence the charge that lands later: "You're bending and cracking the truth like a human body." Everyone in the room knows the same facts. The only question left is who gets to keep calling them true.

Theme

PowerA funeral guest list is really a map of who holds power now that Stalin is gone.
LiesGuilt is decided by whoever is still alive to say the line, not by what happened.

Listen for

  • look forward to — Keep to light and put the beat on forward; do not read each word separately.
  • more sweat than — Stress more and sweat, then let than man fade with a self-mocking tone.
  • you of all people — Link of all into one quick unit, stressing all and people; start you briskly.
  • shit up as — Glide through shit up as without a pause, keeping the beat on making.
I'm more sweat than man.

Comic exaggeration of exhaustion: he has climbed so many stairs there is nothing left of him but sweat.

I beg your forgiveness for my selfish deceitfulness, and I will go and reassure Polina.

A formal, total capitulation: he calls himself selfish and deceitful and offers to go comfort Polina — the cheapest way to stay in the room.

You're just making this shit up as you go along.

The charge is not that he lies, but that he invents the rule minute by minute, so the standard always lands where it suits him.

You're bending and cracking the truth like a human body.

The truth is being tortured here: bent, cracked and finally broken until it confesses whatever the interrogator needs.

It's lucky we both now live in the new Soviet Union or you and your wife and your family would be a pile of dust on the floor of a crematorium toilet.

Congratulations that doubles as a threat: the same state that frees people can erase a family, so the new leniency is old terror under a friendlier name.

Questions about this scene

Why does the man who called Polina guilty suddenly apologize?

Because the ground has shifted. He is asked whether allegiance to the party line was what Stalin demanded, and agrees; asked whether defying it marked you a traitor, he can only call himself selfish and deceitful. The apology is the price of staying in the room.

Why does someone answer the claim that nobody doubted with "Past tense"?

It is wordplay. Someone repeats that nobody doubted the verdict, and the reply points out that doubted is past tense: that certainty belonged to an earlier era and is finished. One verb tense becomes a verdict on the whole system.

Is the pianist's note real, or is it being used as a weapon?

Nothing in the scene confirms the note itself — we only see a copy that someone says he found by Stalin's body. Its use is clear anyway: it ties the pianist to a death threat and to a man's wife and family, who would be "a pile of dust on the floor of a crematorium toilet" under the old rules.

Why does the scene end with orders to restart the trains and reopen Moscow?

Control of the story has changed hands. Restarting the trains and letting people back into Moscow is staged as a mercy — "They deserve to see the old man" — but the closing line about Beria's goons coping with it makes clear it is also a move against a rival's police.

The Death of Stalin · 15 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 11 of 15 · about 11 min to go