The Rainmaker · 1997 — Chapter 21 of 23 · 2'29" · C1

Citing Club Ruby to Admit Stolen Files, Explained: played no part in

A case is handed up mid-hearing and the argument turns on paperwork: "stolen documents are, in fact, admissible if the lawyers played no part in the theft." The judge says the case overrules the objection, then apologizes to the lawyer he just ruled against.

What happens

Mid-hearing, someone hands up a new case and asks to approach. The ruling: stolen documents can be admitted as evidence as long as the lawyers did not take part in the theft. The judge says the case overrules the objection and notes the objection anyway. Then the questioning turns to a claims manual and its section "U."

CourtroomConfrontingExplainingRivalsC1mediumamericanClean
IMDb ↗

Listen for

controlled in this factual situationadmissibleplayed no part inhead notes

00:00 / 02:29
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

played no part in

was not involved in

The admissibility turns on whether the lawyers took part in the theft; the phrase draws a clean line of non-involvement.

She played no part in the leak, but she still got blamed.

Also in this scene

  • controlled in this factual situation

    governed by precedent on these facts

  • admissible

    allowed as evidence in court

  • head notes

    summary notes at the top of a case report

  • overrule your objection

    reject your objection

  • mysterious section U

    the mysterious Section U

Everything marked in this scene

30 notes across 40 lines

Sound
your honor

Keep 'your' light and let the stress fall on 'honor'.

I thought this matter was already settled, your honor.
Phrase · C1
controlled in a factual situation / controlled by precedent

governed by precedent on these facts

A lawyer offers a fresh precedent, arguing that it governs this exact factual situation and should defeat the objection.

Your honor, I just this morning found a case that is controlled in this factual situation.
Grammar · B2
a case that is controlled in this factual situation

relative clause: The relative clause defines which kind of case controls this factual situation.

Your honor, I just this morning found a case that is controlled in this factual situation.
Phrase · B1
take a look at something

please look at this ruling

If you'll just take a look at this ruling.
Phrase · B2
play no part in something

were not involved in the theft Here 'part' means involvement, not a role.

And it shows very clearly that stolen documents are, in fact, admissible if the lawyers played no part in the theft.
Grammar · B2
admissible if the lawyers played no part in the theft

conditional clause: The if-clause makes admissibility depend on the lawyers' lack of involvement.

And it shows very clearly that stolen documents are, in fact, admissible if the lawyers played no part in the theft.
Sound
in fact

Stress 'fact'; glide over 'are' before it.

And it shows very clearly that stolen documents are, in fact, admissible if the lawyers played no part in the theft.
Slang · C1
admissible

allowed as evidence — Legal jargon for evidence; outside court, say acceptable or allowed.

And it shows very clearly that stolen documents are, in fact, admissible if the lawyers played no part in the theft.
Phrase · C1
according to something

based on these head notes Here 'head notes' are case summary notes, not personal notes.

Well, according to these head notes, this case will overrule your objection.
Phrase · B2
overrule an objection

reject your objection

The lawyer predicts the case will overrule the objection; the judge then notes the objection but allows the evidence.

Well, according to these head notes, this case will overrule your objection.
Phrase · B2
note an objection

record my formal objection

But note my strong objection.
Phrase · B1
excuse the interruption

sorry for interrupting

Excuse the interruption, Mr. Keeley.
Phrase · B1
be about to do something

were just going to discuss

We were about to talk about the Great Benefit claims manual.
Phrase · B1
explain something to someone

explain it to the jury

Why don't we explain it to the jury?
Sound
look at it

Let 'look at it' run together; keep the t light and it unstressed.

Take a look at it.
Phrase · B2
within [time] of receipt of something

within three days of receiving the claim

"Claim handlers are directed to deny all claims "within 3 days of receipt of claim.
Grammar · C1
are directed to deny all claims

passive infinitive: The passive plus infinitive removes the actor and presents the denial as an order.

"Claim handlers are directed to deny all claims "within 3 days of receipt of claim.
Sound
within 3 days

Stress '3 days' and keep 'within' quick.

"Claim handlers are directed to deny all claims "within 3 days of receipt of claim.
Phrase · C1
frivolous and fraudulent claims

baseless and fraudulent claims

Well, sometimes we get some frivolous and fraudulent claims in our business, and sometimes we have to use this kind of language to focus in on the legitimate and more needy claims.
Phrase · C1
focus in on something

focus on legitimate and needier claims

Well, sometimes we get some frivolous and fraudulent claims in our business, and sometimes we have to use this kind of language to focus in on the legitimate and more needy claims.
Phrase · B2
expect someone to believe something

expect the court to believe

Mr. Keeley, do you honestly expect this court to believe that explanation?
Grammar · B2
expect this court to believe that explanation

complex object: The pattern expect someone to do something frames the question as disbelief.

Mr. Keeley, do you honestly expect this court to believe that explanation?
Phrase · B2
in-house processing guidelines

internal processing rules

The witness calls the damning order internal processing guidelines; the lawyer repeats the phrase back with disbelief.

Well, this chapter merely denotes in-house processing guidelines.
Slang · B2
in-house

inside a company — Business jargon for internal rules; use 'internal' with outsiders.

Well, this chapter merely denotes in-house processing guidelines.
Phrase · B2
do a lot more than something

does much more than that

Section "U" does a lot more than that.
Slang · B2
son

a condescending address — Older speaker putting a younger man down; avoid at work.

I don't think it does that, son.
Phrase · C1
route / shuffle / reroute something

passed around and redirected to delay

The lawyer asks whether Section U routes, shuffles, and reroutes claims to avoid payment; the verb chain makes the process sound deliberately evasive.

Mr. Keeley, doesn't it explain precisely how claims should be routed and shuffled and rerouted, anything to avoid payment?
Phrase · B2
anything to avoid something

anything to avoid paying

Mr. Keeley, doesn't it explain precisely how claims should be routed and shuffled and rerouted, anything to avoid payment?
Grammar · C1
how claims should be routed and shuffled and rerouted

embedded clause: The how-clause spells out the alleged procedure in passive, evasive terms.

Mr. Keeley, doesn't it explain precisely how claims should be routed and shuffled and rerouted, anything to avoid payment?
Sound
routed and shuffled

Stress 'rout-' and 'shuff-'; keep 'and' very light.

Mr. Keeley, doesn't it explain precisely how claims should be routed and shuffled and rerouted, anything to avoid payment?

Citing Club Ruby to Admit Stolen Files, explained

What's really going on

The fight isn't really about the documents — it's about who gets to set the rules mid-hearing. A precedent is produced like a trump card: "stolen documents are, in fact, admissible if the lawyers played no part in the theft." The objection survives on paper only — "Objection noted" — and "Sorry, Leo" draws back "Oh, I'm sure you are, your honor." Then the questions turn to the claims manual and its section "U," with the demand "Why don't we explain it to the jury?" The manual's own words are read out: "Claim handlers are directed to deny all claims" within three days, no exceptions; the explanation that this is merely "in-house processing guidelines" gets a flat "No, Mr. Keeley. No, it does not."

Theme

JusticeA technical precedent decides what the jury may see, and the objection is overruled but formally preserved.
DeceptionDenial instructions are recast as routine 'in-house processing guidelines' — the label itself is the defense.

Listen for

  • your honor — Keep 'your' light and let the stress fall on 'honor'.
  • in fact — Stress 'fact'; glide over 'are' before it.
  • look at it — Let 'look at it' run together; keep the t light and it unstressed.
  • within 3 days — Stress '3 days' and keep 'within' quick.
And it shows very clearly that stolen documents are, in fact, admissible if the lawyers played no part in the theft.

The precedent is read out to win the point: the documents can go to the jury, because the lawyers weren't in on the theft.

"Claim handlers are directed to deny all claims "within 3 days of receipt of claim.

A manual instruction read aloud in court: staff are told to turn down every claim within three days.

Mr. Keeley, doesn't it explain precisely how claims should be routed and shuffled and rerouted, anything to avoid payment?

The question reframes the section: it looks less like guidance than a system for moving claims around until they die.

I don't think it does that, son.

The offered explanation is rejected outright, and 'son' turns the correction into a put-down.

Questions about this scene

Why is Club Ruby vs. Carmine De Soto brought up in the middle of the hearing?

It is offered as controlling authority in this factual situation: the case holds that stolen documents are admissible if the lawyers played no part in the theft, and the judge says it overrules the objection.

What does Section "U" of the claims manual say?

It directs claim handlers to deny all claims within three days of receipt, with no exceptions. The paragraph is read aloud in court from the manual.

What does Keeley call Section "U"?

He calls it in-house processing guidelines and says such language helps focus on the legitimate and more needy claims. That explanation is rejected in court: "No, Mr. Keeley. No, it does not."

What happens to the objection once the judge rules against it?

It is entered on the record — "Objection noted" — after the losing side asks for a strong objection to be noted, so the complaint is preserved rather than dropped.

Does Keeley admit the manual is built to delay payment?

No. Asked whether the section explains how claims get routed and shuffled and rerouted, anything to avoid payment, the answer is a flat "I admit nothing."

The Rainmaker · 23 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 21 of 23 · about 6 min to go