The Death of Stalin · 2017 — Chapter 15 of 15 · 4'06" · C1

Beria Arrested in the Kremlin, Explained: at the expense of

Grief is adjourned in one sentence — 'write the next chapter of our great history' — and a new agenda item turns a committee meeting into an arrest. 'He'll get a trial' is offered as reassurance; minutes later the argument is whether Beria dies or waits to take revenge.

What happens

The Central Committee meets in the Kremlin, mourning barely begun, when a new item is tabled: the conduct of Comrade Beria. He is accused of hoarding power; a button is pressed, nothing happens; the army arrives, Beria is disarmed and dragged to a lavatory, where the others debate a trial.

MeetingsAccusationsConfrontingThreateningRivalsC1mediumbritish
IMDb ↗

Listen for

set aside our griefat the expense ofAny Other BusinessHe'll get a trial

00:00 / 04:06
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
  1. ❝ MonologueThe case against him5 linesPractice page ↗
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

at the expense of

by harming or sacrificing something

Someone formally accuses Beria of concentrating power in his ministry at the Party's expense.

He built his career at the expense of his family.

Also in this scene

  • set aside our grief

    put mourning aside for now

  • Any Other Business

    the miscellaneous final agenda item

  • He'll get a trial

    he will be given a trial

  • little coil of shit

    a vulgar, dehumanizing insult

  • in complete limbo

    stuck in total uncertainty

Everything marked in this scene

34 notes across 78 lines

Phrase · B2
set aside + 情绪/分歧

put mourning aside for now

At the start of the meeting, someone asks the comrades to stop mourning and move on.

Comrades, time to set aside our grief and begin to write the next chapter of our great history.
Phrase · B2
write the next chapter of something

begin a new phase Here it means a new phase of political history.

Comrades, time to set aside our grief and begin to write the next chapter of our great history.
Sound
set aside our

In fast speech, set aside our can blur into one chunk; keep the stress on grief.

Comrades, time to set aside our grief and begin to write the next chapter of our great history.
Phrase · B2
take stock of something

assess the situation

Someone seconds the new agenda and says it is time to take stock, shifting away from procedure.

Seconded. Time to take stock.
Phrase · C1
Any Other Business (AOB)

the miscellaneous final agenda item

Someone uses the routine agenda label to push a serious proposal into the miscellaneous pile.

If you have a serious proposal, comrade, I suggest "Any Other Business".
Phrase · B2
at the expense of something

by harming or sacrificing something

Someone formally accuses Beria of concentrating power in his ministry at the Party's expense.

I accuse Comrade Beria of centralising power within his Ministry at the expense of the Party and Central Committee...
Grammar · B2
of centralising power

gerund after preposition: The gerund after of names the exact action being accused.

I accuse Comrade Beria of centralising power within his Ministry at the expense of the Party and Central Committee...
Phrase · C1
a breach of protocol

a violation of formal rules

I deplore this wanton breach of protocol. Georgy.
Phrase · C1
an ad hoc motion

an improvised formal proposal

Breach, my arse! This is an ad hoc motion.
Slang · B2
my arse

bullshit; no way — British vulgar dismissal; avoid in formal settings.

Breach, my arse! This is an ad hoc motion.
Phrase · A2
Hands up!

put your hands up

Hands up or I'll shoot you in the face.
Slang · A2
shit

oh crap — Casual exclamation of alarm; informal only.

Oh, shit.
Phrase · B2
want something done properly

want something done right

Want a job done properly, you call the army.
Sound
Want a job

Want a job can rush together; land the beat on job.

Want a job done properly, you call the army.
Phrase · B1
take something off someone

remove his belt

Take his belt off.
Phrase · C1
give someone a good kicking

beat someone badly

- You're a disgrace. - Give his head a good kicking.
Phrase · B2
all in good time

not yet, but eventually

- Make you feel better. - All in good time.
Grammar · B1
have been picturing

present perfect continuous: It shows a repeated action continuing from the past up to now.

I have been picturing this moment every day for the last three decades.
Phrase · B1
feel at home

feel comfortable Here it is ironic: the lavatory is called his home.

Well, you should feel at home, then, you little coil of shit.
Slang · C1
coil of shit

a piece of shit — Extreme insult; only in open hostility.

Well, you should feel at home, then, you little coil of shit.
Slang · B2
Fuck me

bloody hell; wow — Vulgar surprise; not for polite company.

Fuck me.
Slang · B2
crapper

toilet — Vulgar British slang for toilet; informal only.

Georgy's eyes really do follow you round the crapper. It's weird.
Phrase · B2
look someone in the eye

face someone directly

Georgy! Can't even look me in the eye.
Phrase · B1
get over something

recover from something

Georgy, you'll get over it. I did. Took me about five minutes.
Sound
get over it

Link over into it so the phrase comes out as one unit.

Georgy, you'll get over it. I did. Took me about five minutes.
Phrase · C1
in complete limbo

stuck in total uncertainty

After the arrest, the army has not arrived, and someone asks how long they must wait.

H-How long before the army's here? We're in complete limbo now.
Grammar · B2
wait for the NKVD to leave

infinitive after wait for: The structure means waiting for someone to do something before moving on.

Not long. We have to wait for the NKVD to leave the Kremlin.
Phrase · C1
spend a penny/kopeck

go to the toilet kopeck is a Soviet coin; the phrase means going to the toilet.

In that case, if nobody objects, I'm going to spend a kopeck.
Phrase · B2
hold your fire

stop shooting

Right, hold your fire.
Phrase · B2
a fair trial

a just legal hearing

No. He deserves a fair trial. He's one of us.
Phrase · B2
the only choice we have is between A or B

our sole option

The only choice we have is between his death or his revenge.
Grammar · B1
The only choice we have

relative clause: The omitted relative pronoun makes we have modify choice directly.

The only choice we have is between his death or his revenge.
Sound
his death or his

Keep or his light and let death and revenge carry the stress.

The only choice we have is between his death or his revenge.
Slang · B2
fucking

vulgar intensifier — Vulgar intensifier used in rage; avoid formally.

And you will fucking sign this.

Beria Arrested in the Kremlin, explained

What's really going on

What looks like a procedural squabble is the whole power struggle in miniature. The motion is 'ad hoc', the correct channel is 'Any Other Business', and the argument is about whether the proper forms were followed — not about whether Beria did anything. That is the point: the forms are the only weapon in the room, and the moment the army walks in they stop mattering. 'Want a job done properly, you call the army' lands as a joke about competence and as a plain statement about who is now in charge. The plea for a trial is made twice and brushed aside both times; the last thing heard in the room is an order to sign.

Theme

PowerA committee argues over procedure while armed men decide the outcome; whoever holds the room holds the country.
RevengeThe plea for a trial is answered with 'his death or his revenge' — a thirty-year score settled in a lavatory.

Listen for

  • set aside our — In fast speech, set aside our can blur into one chunk; keep the stress on grief.
  • Want a job — Want a job can rush together; land the beat on job.
  • get over it — Link over into it so the phrase comes out as one unit.
  • his death or his — Keep or his light and let death and revenge carry the stress.
Comrades, time to set aside our grief and begin to write the next chapter of our great history.

Grief is declared finished in one sentence so the scramble for power can start; the funeral is over before it begins.

Want a job done properly, you call the army.

A boast about getting things done: the committee's forms have just failed, so bring in men with guns — and it quietly announces who really decides now.

It's hard to run away with your pants falling down.

The belt is taken for a practical reason and played as a joke: humiliation used as a restraint.

I have been picturing this moment every day for the last three decades.

A score being settled after thirty years; the arrest is personal long before it is political.

The only choice we have is between his death or his revenge.

The argument for finishing him off without a trial: if he lives, he comes back. Framed as having no alternative.

Questions about this scene

Why do they arrest Beria right there in the meeting?

Because a new item is tabled at the very start — 'Item one, the conduct of Comrade Beria' — and the objection that 'there's no tabled motion' is simply overruled. The button under the desk is pressed, the army walks in, and the arrest goes ahead.

Why is his belt taken off?

So he can't run: 'It's hard to run away with your pants falling down.' The humiliation is played for a laugh, but it does the practical work of a restraint.

Why does someone keep insisting on a trial?

'He deserves a trial,' and later 'He deserves a fair trial. He's one of us.' The answer, 'He'll get a trial. Take it easy,' is a way of quieting the room, and by the end the plea is met with 'It's too late.'

What does 'Any Other Business' mean here?

It's the last item on a meeting agenda, where leftover matters get dumped. Suggesting it is a way of shelving a proposal — saying that if Beria's conduct has to be raised at all, it belongs at the end, not first.

What is the button under the desk supposed to do?

Summon the guards. The order is given twice and the reply is 'What button?' — the machinery of the room fails exactly when it is needed, and it takes an army from outside to finish the job.

The Death of Stalin · 15 chapters

All chapters →
That's all 15 chapters of this film