The Rainmaker · 1997 — Chapter 11 of 23 · 2'23" · B2

New Judge Grills Defense Lawyer, Explained: place an undue burden on

What looks like a scheduling fight is a test of nerve. A defense lawyer has objected to fast-tracking this case, arguing it would "place an undue burden on both parties." The judge is not impressed: name one case, he says, where you ever agreed to a fast track.

What happens

A hearing in court: a newly appointed judge takes over the case and asks a defense lawyer why he objected to fast-tracking it. The judge asks him to name a case he ever agreed to have fast-tracked. The lawyer stalls, promising to call back. The judge goes on to set the dying boy's deposition for next Thursday at 2 p.m. and denies the motion to dismiss.

CourtroomConfrontingExplainingRivalsB2mediumamericanClean
IMDb ↗

Listen for

fast-trackingplace an undue burden onget back to you on thatpushing me around pretty good

00:00 / 02:23
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

place an undue burden on

put excessive strain on

The defense lawyer says fast-tracking would overload both sides, hoping to slow the case down; the judge dismisses it at once.

Critics say the rule would place an undue burden on small clinics.

Also in this scene

  • fast-tracking

    accelerated court process

  • get back to you on that

    reply to you about that later

  • pushing me around pretty good

    wearing someone out; bossing someone around

  • Sorry if it inconveniences the defense

    fake apology while refusing to change

  • anxious to hear about

    eager to hear about

Everything marked in this scene

29 notes across 45 lines

Phrase · B1
object to something

oppose or protest something

You've objected to the fast-tracking of this case.
Phrase · B2
fast-tracking of something

accelerated handling of something here it means speeding up a court case

You've objected to the fast-tracking of this case.
Grammar · B1
You've objected to

present perfect: Present perfect frames the objection as already on the record, not just a past event.

You've objected to the fast-tracking of this case.
Phrase · B2
rule upon something

make a ruling on something

This issue's already been ruled upon by Judge Hale.
Phrase · C1
place an undue burden on someone

put excessive strain on

The defense lawyer says fast-tracking would overload both sides, hoping to slow the case down; the judge dismisses it at once.

Uh, the preparations required for fast-tracking the case place an undue burden on both parties, I believe.
Phrase · B1
both parties

both sides

Uh, the preparations required for fast-tracking the case place an undue burden on both parties, I believe.
Grammar · B2
preparations required for fast-tracking the case

reduced relative clause: Required for fast-tracking modifies preparations; it is not the main verb.

Uh, the preparations required for fast-tracking the case place an undue burden on both parties, I believe.
Sound
burden on

Let burden on link smoothly, with the weight on burden.

Uh, the preparations required for fast-tracking the case place an undue burden on both parties, I believe.
Phrase · B1
ask someone something

ask someone something

Let me ask you something, Mr. Drummond.
Phrase · B1
agree to something

consent to something

As a defense lawyer, have you ever agreed to the fast-tracking of a lawsuit?
Sound
have you ever

In fast speech, have you ever can blur; keep ever and agreed prominent.

As a defense lawyer, have you ever agreed to the fast-tracking of a lawsuit?
Phrase · B1
get back to someone on something

reply to you about that later

When asked for a specific case name, the speaker stalls and promises to reply later; the judge immediately sets a deadline.

Well, your honor, I have to get back to you on that.
Sound
I'm gonna

I'm gonna compresses in speech; stress the time 3:00.

I don't believe I'm gonna be in before 3:00.
Slang · A2
gonna

going to — Very common in speech, but avoid it in writing or formal remarks.

I don't believe I'm gonna be in before 3:00.
Phrase · A2
when someone gets in

when you arrive or get in

Oh. Well, call me when you get in.
Phrase · B2
anxious to hear about something

eager to hear about

Before the session breaks up, the judge politely but firmly reminds the lawyer to deliver the case name he promised to find.

I'm very anxious to hear about this case you agreed to fast-track.
Phrase · A2
be about to do something

be ready to do something very soon

This boy is about to die, gentlemen.
Phrase · B2
record someone's testimony

make a record of someone's testimony

You do agree that we need to record his testimony.
Grammar · B2
do agree that we need to record his testimony

emphatic do: Emphatic do makes the agreement stronger, and the that-clause states what is agreed.

You do agree that we need to record his testimony.
Phrase · B2
push someone around

wearing someone out; bossing someone around

The lawyer blames a crowded trial calendar for running him ragged, using it as a reason to avoid the proposed date.

It's just my trial calendar is pushing me around pretty good.
Phrase · A2
be out of town

away from town

I believe I'm out of town.
Sound
enough of you

Link enough of smoothly, then let you guys land quickly.

Sorry if it inconveniences the defense, but God knows there's enough of you guys to handle it.
Slang · A2
you guys

you all — Friendly plural address; too casual for many formal situations.

Sorry if it inconveniences the defense, but God knows there's enough of you guys to handle it.
Phrase · C1
motion to dismiss

request to dismiss a case

After the deposition date is set, someone raises the unresolved dismissal request; the judge denies it almost instantly.

Oh, uh, your honor, the motion to dismiss is still pending.
Phrase · B2
still pending

not yet decided

Oh, uh, your honor, the motion to dismiss is still pending.
Grammar · B2
motion to dismiss

infinitive modifier: To dismiss describes what kind of motion it is, not why someone moves.

Oh, uh, your honor, the motion to dismiss is still pending.
Phrase · B1
call someone with something

phone someone about something

don't forget to call me with the name of that case you agreed to fast-track.
Grammar · B2
you agreed to fast-track

relative clause: The clause modifies case with an omitted that: the case you agreed to fast-track.

don't forget to call me with the name of that case you agreed to fast-track.
Phrase · B1
look around

search for it; look for records

At the very end, the lawyer answers the judge's reminder with a vague promise to search, leaving the pressure unresolved.

I'll look around.

New Judge Grills Defense Lawyer, explained

What's really going on

The docket is not the point. One line asks whether the objection to fast-tracking has ever cut the other way: "As a defense lawyer, have you ever agreed to the fast-tracking of a lawsuit?" It is a trap. Answer yes and a case name is owed; answer no and the objection stands exposed as routine. What comes back — "I have to get back to you on that" — is a stall, and it does not end the matter. The same hearing notes "This boy is about to die," sets the deposition for the following Thursday anyway, and denies the pending motion to dismiss. The objection is never debated; it is overruled by the calendar.

Theme

JusticeA judge sets the pace by the boy's condition — "This boy is about to die" — not by the defense's convenience.
PowerThe lawyer stalls, the judge rules: one hearing decides the schedule, the deposition and the motion to dismiss.

Listen for

  • burden on — Let burden on link smoothly, with the weight on burden.
  • have you ever — In fast speech, have you ever can blur; keep ever and agreed prominent.
  • I'm gonna — I'm gonna compresses in speech; stress the time 3:00.
  • enough of you — Link enough of smoothly, then let you guys land quickly.
You've objected to the fast-tracking of this case.

The judge restates the lawyer's position before taking it apart: the objection is on the record, and now it has to hold up.

As a defense lawyer, have you ever agreed to the fast-tracking of a lawsuit?

A trap question. If the answer is yes, a case name is owed; if it is no, the objection looks like routine delay.

This boy is about to die, gentlemen.

The reason the schedule is being forced: the boy may not live long enough to give his testimony.

Sorry if it inconveniences the defense, but God knows there's enough of you guys to handle it.

A fake apology: the speaker regrets the schedule, then notes the defense has plenty of people to handle it.

don't forget to call me with the name of that case you agreed to fast-track.

The matter is not dropped. A real case name has to be produced, or the claim of having agreed before collapses.

Questions about this scene

Why does the judge ask for the name of a case?

To test whether the objection to fast-tracking is principle or habit. If the lawyer has ever agreed to fast-tracking, he should be able to name the case. All he offers is "I have to get back to you on that."

Why is the deposition set for next Thursday afternoon?

Because the boy is dying: "This boy is about to die, gentlemen." His testimony has to be recorded while he can still give it, so the judge sets 2 p.m. even after the defense says it will be out of town.

Does the judge grant the motion to dismiss?

No. The motion is still pending when the hearing turns to it, and the ruling is flat: "That motion is denied."

What does "fast-tracking" mean here?

Moving the case through the court faster than usual. The defense has objected to it, citing the preparation it requires and the "undue burden" it puts on both parties.

The Rainmaker · 23 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 11 of 23 · about 36 min to go