Steve Jobs · 2015 — Chapter 6 of 16 · 2'23" · C1

Friend Calls NeXT a Failure, Explained: back to the drawing board

The argument is about price: a $6,500 machine that becomes $12,000 once you add the 'optional' drive and the printer. Underneath it is about who gets to tell Steve Jobs the truth. "I came here to stand next to you while that happens because that's what friends do."

What happens

Minutes before a stage demo, an old friend runs the numbers on the cube-shaped machine: $6,500, plus a $3,000 hard drive nobody can skip, plus a $2,500 printer, $12,000 all in. He calls the cube the single biggest failure in personal computing. Then it's a demo that might crash, a request to start fifteen minutes late, and a fight over that request.

ArgumentsCriticism & layoffsWarningConfrontingFriendsC1fastamerican
IMDb ↗

Listen for

stand by someoneTell Me Something Else I Don't KnowIf It Crashes, It Crashesswallow cyanide

00:00 / 02:23
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
  1. ❝ MonologueWoz's Failure Forecast9 linesPractice page ↗
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

back to the drawing board

start over from scratch

One voice offers a fallback if the launch flops; the other kills the fallback with the same image, twice.

The app flopped, so we're back to the drawing board with a smaller team.

Also in this scene

  • stand by someone

    to support someone in trouble

  • Tell Me Something Else I Don't Know

    That's not news to me.

  • If It Crashes, It Crashes

    accept the worst and move on

  • swallow cyanide

    treat a failure as fatal

  • Can't Lose cards

    a guaranteed-win card

Everything marked in this scene

27 notes across 42 lines

Sound
gonna fail

Keep 'gonna' light and land the stress on 'fail'.

Your computer's gonna fail.
Phrase · B2
price something at $X

set the price of something at X

You've priced NeXT at 6,500.
Phrase · B2
something isn't optional

you have to buy it in the end

And that doesn't include the optional $3,000 hard drive, which people will discover isn't optional.
Grammar · B2
which people will discover isn't optional

non-restrictive relative clause: which points back to the hard drive itself, with 'people will discover' slipped in between: the drive turns out not to be optional.

And that doesn't include the optional $3,000 hard drive, which people will discover isn't optional.
Phrase · B1
too weak to do anything

so weak it's useless

Because the optical disk is too weak to do anything.
Phrase · B1
bring the total to $X

push the total up to X

And the $2,500 laser printer brings the total to $12,000.
Phrase · B2
be housed in something

be built inside something not about a house — the machine sits inside a cube-shaped case

And in the entire world, you are the only person who cares that it's housed in a perfect cube.
Grammar · C1
the only person who cares that it's housed

nested relative clauses: who cares attaches to 'the only person', and the that-clause is the object of 'cares'.

And in the entire world, you are the only person who cares that it's housed in a perfect cube.
Slang · B2
get killed

be destroyed (figuratively) — Fine between friends; too blunt for a formal forecast.

You're gonna get killed.
Phrase · B2
talk to someone like they're other people

treat me like an outsider here 'other people' means outsiders, not just 'others'

We go back, so don't talk to me like I'm other people.
Phrase · B1
be about to be / do something

be just about to happen

I'm standing by you because that perfect cube that does nothing is about to be the single biggest failure in the history of personal computing.
Phrase · C1
the single biggest … in the history of …

the number-one of its kind ever

I'm standing by you because that perfect cube that does nothing is about to be the single biggest failure in the history of personal computing.
Phrase · A2
be out of time

have no time left

- Back onstage? - We're out of time.
Slang · B2
open the house

let the audience in — Theatre-crew jargon; outsiders may not follow it.

They've got to mop the stage and open the house.
Sound
If it crashes

Run 'If it' together and leave almost no gap between the two 'crashes'.

If it crashes, it crashes.
Phrase · B2
be not just talking about something

the real issue is bigger than X

I'm not just talking about the demo, Steve.
Slang · B2
tanks

flops badly — Casual for business or box-office failure; write 'fail' in reports.

If it tanks, we don't swallow cyanide.
Grammar · C1
Invent the Edsel twice, you don't get

imperative conditional: The imperative half works as the condition: 'if you do that twice', then no more chances.

Invent the Edsel twice, you don't get any more drawing boards.
Phrase · B2
something reveals itself to someone

become clear on its own

The plan will reveal itself to you when you're ready to see it.
Slang · C1
drop acid

take LSD — Dated slang; a joke only, never in polite company.

Will I have to drop acid?
Slang · B1
Couldn't hurt

no harm in trying — A light way to say 'go ahead'; too casual for serious requests.

Couldn't hurt.
Phrase · B1
let someone down

fail someone who trusted you

Have I ever let you down?
Phrase · B2
put someone in a position where …

force you into a spot where …

I just don't wanna put you in a position where you're lying to people.
Grammar · B2
a position where you're lying to people

relative adverb where: where refers back to 'position', not a place: the kind of situation in which you would be lying.

I just don't wanna put you in a position where you're lying to people.
Phrase · B2
give somebody a fighting chance

a real chance if you fight for it

Start 15 minutes late so Avie can recompile and give us a fighting chance.
Sound
We're not

We're is barely there; the beat falls on 'not' and 'late'.

- We're not starting late, ever! - Fine!
Sound
come down on

Link the three words in one breath and let 'late' rise a little.

But where do you come down on starting late?

Friend Calls NeXT a Failure, explained

What's really going on

On the surface it's arithmetic: $6,500, an 'optional' $3,000 hard drive, a $2,500 printer, a $12,000 total — and one line that lands harder than any price, "And in the entire world, you are the only person who cares that it's housed in a perfect cube." Underneath is a fight about who is allowed to say the worst thing out loud, and what friendship buys you: "I came here to stand next to you while that happens because that's what friends do." The pushback is that the guy on stage is a character someone invented. The answer to all of it is a shrug — "Tell me something else I don't know" — then a joke about the demo crashing, and a promise of a plan that "will reveal itself to you when you're ready to see it."

Theme

PrideThe perfect cube is the pride point: one person's care for the case outlasts every argument that the price and the drive make it unsellable.
FriendshipSomeone comes backstage to say the worst thing out loud, and calls that friendship.

Listen for

  • gonna fail — Keep 'gonna' light and land the stress on 'fail'.
  • If it crashes — Run 'If it' together and leave almost no gap between the two 'crashes'.
  • We're not — We're is barely there; the beat falls on 'not' and 'late'.
  • come down on — Link the three words in one breath and let 'late' rise a little.
And in the entire world, you are the only person who cares that it's housed in a perfect cube.

The cube may be beautifully made, but no buyer cares about its case; only its maker is impressed by it.

I'm standing by you because that perfect cube that does nothing is about to be the single biggest failure in the history of personal computing.

Loyalty is framed as a front-row seat to a disaster: support and a death sentence delivered in the same breath.

Tell me something else I don't know.

A flat brush-off: everything just said is treated as old news, so say something new.

Invent the Edsel twice, you don't get any more drawing boards.

One famous flop might be survivable; repeat it and there is no chance to start over again.

The plan will reveal itself to you when you're ready to see it.

A promise instead of details: the plan will show itself when you are ready to see it — no steps, no numbers given.

Questions about this scene

Why does the friend run through the price list?

He starts from the board that asked for a $2,000–$3,000 workstation, then stacks up the $6,500 price, the 'optional' $3,000 hard drive ('which people will discover isn't optional'), the $2,500 printer and the $12,000 total. The point is that nobody can buy it.

Why does he come backstage to say all this?

He gives his reason in the line itself: 'I came here to stand next to you while that happens because that's what friends do.' 'That' is the failure he has just predicted — he wants to be there when it lands, and calls it friendship.

What does 'Tell me something else I don't know' mean here?

It is a brush-off: the warning is treated as old news. Instead of answering the pricing and design points, the reply dismisses the whole list.

Why does the offer to start over get refused?

The offer is 'We go back to the drawing board' — start over — and the answer is 'No more drawing boards,' backed by the Edsel: make the same famous flop twice and there is no restart.

Why does someone ask for a fifteen-minute delay?

'Start 15 minutes late so Avie can recompile and give us a fighting chance.' The delay is for a recompile before a demo that may crash, and it turns into the last fight of the scene: 'We're not starting late, ever!'

Steve Jobs · 16 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 6 of 16 · about 35 min to go