Steve Jobs · 2015 — Chapter 8 of 16 · 3'13" · B2

NeXT Has No Operating System, Explained: off the record

Backstage minutes before a launch, a reporter keeps asking when he can get a NeXT machine, and the answer keeps sliding. The surface is scheduling; underneath it is the gap between a product that demos and a product that works: "I guess, in layman's terms, you'd have to say we don't have an OS."

What happens

Minutes before a launch, someone is fielding questions about the new NeXT machine and trying to keep the answers unquotable. A reporter wants a line he can print and a ship date; he gets "on background" and "off the record" instead. And the answer to what's left to finish is that the machine can only demonstrate itself — there is no operating system yet.

MeetingsNegotiationExplainingConfessingB2fastamericanClean
IMDb ↗

Listen for

on backgroundtake out a full-page adWhy botheroff the record

00:00 / 03:13
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
  1. ❝ MonologueCar Without an Engine4 linesPractice page ↗
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

off the record

not for publication

Someone tries to set a privacy boundary mid-interview, but the other side keeps pressing for the technical truth.

Everything he said was off the record, so we can't quote him.

Also in this scene

  • on background

    not for attribution

  • take out a full-page ad

    place a full-page newspaper ad

  • Why bother

    What's the point of doing it?

  • in layman's terms

    in plain, non-expert language

  • find out the hard way

    learn through painful experience

Everything marked in this scene

29 notes across 64 lines

Phrase · B1
in front of + audience/crowd

before a huge audience

- ...playing in front of thousands of people. - Steve!
Phrase · B1
a quick reaction to something

a brief response to something

- Can I get a quick reaction to the press this morning? - What about it?
Phrase · C1
tell someone on background

brief someone off the record

- The size of it, the volume. - I'll tell you on background...
Slang · C1
on background

not for attribution — Media jargon for usable but unattributed information.

- The size of it, the volume. - I'll tell you on background...
Grammar · B1
that I've never seen anything like it

object clause: The that-clause tells the listener what the background information actually is.

- I was hoping for a quote from Steve. - I'll tell you on background that I've never seen anything like it in the tech industry.
Sound
anything like it

Link anything like it smoothly; stress never and like.

- I was hoping for a quote from Steve. - I'll tell you on background that I've never seen anything like it in the tech industry.
Phrase · B2
take out an ad

place a full-page newspaper ad

Someone recalls trying to buy a full-page ad and being told it would be pointless because the launch is already huge news.

I called the Wall Street Journal to take out a full-page ad for today, and do you know what their sales guy said?
Phrase · B1
Why bother (doing something)?

What's the point of doing it?

The question is not a real request for reasons; it dismisses an action as pointless before the simile lands.

"Why bother? It'd be like notifying Macy's that tomorrow is Christmas."
Phrase · B2
notify someone that + clause

tell someone the obvious

"Why bother? It'd be like notifying Macy's that tomorrow is Christmas."
Phrase · B2
announce the ship date

give a release date

- When can he? - We'll announce the ship date in the next eight to 10 weeks.
Phrase · B1
be talking about something

not referring to the release date

Alsop's not talking about the ship date.
Phrase · B2
get something into someone's hands

put something in someone's hands

We have a lot of respect for Stewart Alsop, and we want to get a machine into his hands so he can tell his subscribers about it.
Phrase · B1
tell someone about something

tell one's readers about it

We have a lot of respect for Stewart Alsop, and we want to get a machine into his hands so he can tell his subscribers about it.
Slang · B2
Off the record

not for publication — Use in interviews or private talks; do not promise it casually.

Off the record.
Phrase · B2
off the record

not for publication

Someone tries to set a privacy boundary mid-interview, but the other side keeps pressing for the technical truth.

We're off the record, and Joel's always been good at understanding nuance.
Phrase · B2
in layman's terms

in plain, non-expert language

After a technical question, the speaker switches into plain language before admitting there is no operating system.

I guess, in layman's terms, you'd have to say we don't have an OS.
Sound
in layman's terms

Stress layman's and terms; hurry through the words around them.

I guess, in layman's terms, you'd have to say we don't have an OS.
Grammar · B2
what runs the computer

predicative clause: The what-clause defines the subject: the OS is the thing that runs the computer.

- What do you mean? - Well, the OS is what runs the computer.
Sound
How's it gonna

Compress How's it gonna and listen for the verb run.

How has it been running? How's it gonna run this morning?
Phrase · B1
write a demo program

write a demo program

It's like this. Avie Tevanian is our chief software designer, and he wrote a demo program.
Phrase · B2
make something go for a bit

keep it running briefly

So we put a golf cart battery in there to make it go for a bit.
Grammar · B2
All this computer knows how to do right now

relative clause: A relative clause with that omitted modifies All; the whole All-phrase is the subject, so the point lands after is.

All this computer knows how to do right now is demonstrate itself.
Grammar · B2
an e-mail sent on a NeXT computer

participle modifier: The past participle phrase modifies e-mail: an email that was sent on a NeXT computer.

And I assume an e-mail sent on a NeXT computer can only be received by a NeXT computer?
Slang · B2
Abso-fruitly

playful absolutely — Only with people who share the joke.

Abso-fruitly.
Phrase · B2
find out the hard way

learn through painful experience

Someone passes along a warning so another person does not have to learn the hard way how strict the demo standards are.

I-I didn't want him to find out the hard way your position on glitches in a demo, but it sounds like you've mellowed.
Phrase · B2
someone's position on something

one's stance on something

I-I didn't want him to find out the hard way your position on glitches in a demo, but it sounds like you've mellowed.
Sound
didn't want him

Slide through the consonants in didn't want him, slow then fast.

I-I didn't want him to find out the hard way your position on glitches in a demo, but it sounds like you've mellowed.
Grammar · C1
wouldn't have ever dreamed that was a problem

modal perfect: The modal perfect looks back at a past possibility the speaker never imagined.

Hmm. I wouldn't have ever dreamed that was a problem.
Slang · B2
Fantastic burn

a great insult — Playful praise for a sharp joke among friends.

Fantastic burn.

NeXT Has No Operating System, explained

What's really going on

Everyone in the room is managing what can be printed. The reporter's job is to turn a conversation into a quote; the other side's job is to keep the conversation from becoming one, which is why the same answer arrives wrapped in "on background" and then "off the record." The real pressure shows when the packaging is refused: "Alsop's not talking about the ship date. He wants to know when he can get one to play with." What's being negotiated isn't a date but whether the product exists. The metaphor does the confessing — "It's like we built a great car, but we haven't built the engine" — and the golf-cart battery admits that the demo, not the machine, is the deliverable. "All this computer knows how to do right now is demonstrate itself." The follow-up, "Is this a strategy or a problem?", is the question the scene never quite answers.

Theme

SecretsThe scene is about controlling information: what can be quoted, what stays background, and what finally slips out.
AmbitionA launch is minutes away, and the machine behind it still can't run without a demo.

Listen for

  • anything like it — Link anything like it smoothly; stress never and like.
  • in layman's terms — Stress layman's and terms; hurry through the words around them.
  • How's it gonna — Compress How's it gonna and listen for the verb run.
  • didn't want him — Slide through the consonants in didn't want him, slow then fast.
- I was hoping for a quote from Steve. - I'll tell you on background that I've never seen anything like it in the tech industry.

The answer can be used but not attributed: it is given as background, not as a quotable line, and it still works as a boast about the launch.

"Why bother? It'd be like notifying Macy's that tomorrow is Christmas."

A newspaper's sales rep is saying a full-page ad would be pointless, because everyone already knows — like telling Macy's that Christmas is coming.

It's like we built a great car, but we haven't built the engine.

The machine looks finished on the outside but is missing its core, so it can only run briefly and by makeshift means.

All this computer knows how to do right now is demonstrate itself.

The demo is all the hardware can actually do; there is nothing underneath it yet.

But isn't it the coolest black cube you've ever seen?

The confession gets a joke instead of an apology: the casing is the only real thing, and it is offered as the selling point.

I don't understand it either, and my name's on the patents.

Even the person holding the patents admits the system is beyond him, which leaves the gap between the box and the machine.

Questions about this scene

Why does the reporter keep pressing about Stewart Alsop?

Someone reads the newsletter headline "Dear NeXT, when can I get my machine?" and then corrects the answer given: "Alsop's not talking about the ship date. He wants to know when he can get one to play with." The announced ship date doesn't answer that.

What does "on background" mean here?

It means the line can be used but not attributed: "I'll tell you on background that I've never seen anything like it in the tech industry." It is less restrictive than "off the record," which comes later and leaves the words unprintable altogether.

Why is the machine compared to a car with no engine?

It explains what is missing: a demo program exists and "we put a golf cart battery in there to make it go for a bit," so "All this computer knows how to do right now is demonstrate itself." The box is real; the system that would run it isn't there yet.

Why does someone say a NeXT email can only reach another NeXT?

The question is whether a message sent on a NeXT machine can be received anywhere else, and the reply confirms the closed setup: "Closed, end-to-end."

Why is someone explaining Avie Tevanian's message to the others?

"I didn't want him to find out the hard way your position on glitches in a demo." The warning is being passed on so it lands gently, and the reply, "I've been growing, Andy. I've been learning to love myself," treats the warning as a joke rather than an answer.

Steve Jobs · 16 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 8 of 16 · about 29 min to go