not publicly
- How about in private? - No.Steve Jobs · 2015 — Chapter 15 of 16 · 4'42" · C1
Woz isn't asking for a favor; he wants a public nod to the Apple II team on launch day. "These people live and die by your praise," one line says — and the answer is a flat refusal, with the old machine dismissed as finished. It's an argument about credit, and about who gets to write Apple's history.
Backstage before a product launch, Woz catches Jobs and asks him to acknowledge the Apple II team on stage — the engineers he says are the ones getting laid off. Jobs refuses, twice: the company doesn't make that machine anymore, and the launch isn't a luncheon. What starts as a request turns into a fight over the Apple II's place in Apple's history.
Listen for
scared the shit out ofinsolventblow me offEverybody loves Ringo
Phrase of the scene
depend completely on something
Someone puts the team's fate in the other person's hands: their jobs and dignity depend on this public praise.
Small creators live and die by the algorithm.
terrified someone
unable to pay debts
dismiss or brush someone off
a fake consolation that dismisses the complaint
rephrase
33 notes across 79 lines
not publicly
- How about in private? - No.In fast speech, 'what do you' blurs together; stress 'mean'.
- She said she'd rather not. - What do you mean?would prefer not to
She's sitting with her friends, and she said she'd rather not come back.terrified someone — Vulgar; use only with close friends, never at work.
But tell her I just scared the shit out of Andy, and this time, nobody's paying her fucking...fucking (intensifier) — Strong vulgar intensifier; avoid in formal settings.
But tell her I just scared the shit out of Andy, and this time, nobody's paying her fucking...come across as wise
But do your thing where you sound old and wise because of the broad, tragic European canvas of your life.close to a state of X
You were less than 90 days from being insolvent.Let 'less than' glide; keep 'than' weak.
You were less than 90 days from being insolvent.be made leaner
The whole place has to be streamlined.begin by dealing with
- Start with two of the accountants. - I started with the...dismiss me — Informal; fine in close conflict, risky with a boss.
You will not blow me off right now, Steve.mediocre performers — Corporate jargon; insulting if said publicly about colleagues.
They're "B" players, and "B" players discourage the "A" players.more qualified to judge
They're not "B" players, and I'm a better judge of that.an essential part of
I'm talking about the Apple II, which is not just a crucial part of this company's history, it is a crucial part of the history of personal computing.non-restrictive relative clause: The which-clause adds extra comment on the Apple II, not a defining limit.
I'm talking about the Apple II, which is not just a crucial part of this company's history, it is a crucial part of the history of personal computing.lay people off a euphemism for laying people off
The least you can do, if you're going to downsize these people...unemployed means being unemployed
They're gonna live in the biggest houses of anyone on the unemployment line.publicly recognize
Is to acknowledge them. Acknowledge them and the Apple II during this launch.created by
This whole place was built by the Apple II. You were built by the Apple II.actually
As a matter of fact, I was destroyed by the Apple II and its open system so that hackers and hobbyists could build ham radios or something.invented or devised
You guys came up with the Newton. You want people to know that?product launch event
This is a product launch, not a luncheon.weary of being
I don't like talking like this, but I am tired of being Ringo when I know I was John.Blur 'tired of being'; stress 'tired' and 'Ringo'.
I don't like talking like this, but I am tired of being Ringo when I know I was John.by random luck
You think John became John by winning a raffle, Woz?counterfactual conditional: A counterfactual: without me, you would be a very easy A student.
If it weren't for me, you'd be the easiest "A" at Homestead High School.depend entirely on your approval not literal life and death; total dependence on approval
These people live and die by your praise, so here's your chance.Link 'that' into 'something'; punch 'good'.
Acknowledge that something good happened that you weren't in the room for.negation + comparative: The negation fronts don't think, while the who-clause carries a comparison of contributions.
I don't think there's a man who's done more to advance the democratization that comes with personal computing than I have, but you've never had any respect for me.entertain the idea
I'd at least consider the possibility that it's because you've never had any for me.appositive clause: The that-clause explains what the possibility is: you never had respect for me.
I'd at least consider the possibility that it's because you've never had any for me.In fast speech the t in 'what' may disappear; stress 'hell'.
What the hell is going on here?what on earth — Informal; shows shock or anger, not for formal use.
What the hell is going on here?On the surface it's a scheduling problem: a few minutes on stage, a nod to the people who built the company. Underneath it's about authorship. "I don't like talking like this, but I am tired of being Ringo when I know I was John," one line runs — and the reply is a compliment that works as a dismissal: "Everybody loves Ringo." The blame flows both ways. The Apple II is written off as something finished — "For a time" — and its open system is blamed in one line for destroying the speaker himself. A beautiful board that, by one account, was nearly given out for free. The closing move asks for nothing for himself, which is what makes it land: "These people live and die by your praise, so here's your chance." Acknowledge them, and admit something good happened in a room you weren't in.
I don't like talking like this, but I am tired of being Ringo when I know I was John.He frames the feud as a Beatles problem: he sees himself as the one who wrote the songs, and resents being treated as the easy-going sidekick.
He was John because he was John.Talent isn't a prize handed out or a spot someone can steal; the work itself is the proof.
These people live and die by your praise, so here's your chance.The team's sense of worth depends on a word from him, and this launch gives him one clean moment to give it.
Acknowledge that something good happened that you weren't in the room for.Admit that a success wasn't his own doing — that others built something good without him there.
He was John 'cause he wrote "Ticket to Ride." And I wrote the Apple II.He answers the Beatles analogy with his own claim to authorship: the Apple II is the song he wrote.
They're "B" players, and "B" players discourage the "A" players.A corporate reason for the layoffs: in his view this team's presence drags down the people he wants to keep.
The refusal is argued two ways in the scene: there are no "top guys" on that team, they're "B" players who discourage the "A" players, and this is "a product launch, not a luncheon" — a new product, not a reunion with the old one.
Not a favor for himself. He wants the names said out loud at the launch — "acknowledge them and the Apple II during this launch" — because, as one line puts it, "these people live and die by your praise."
One line gives the reason plainly: the company doesn't make that machine anymore — "I started with the Apple II team because we don't make that anymore." Another line calls them "B" players who discourage the "A" players, and the reply rejects that outright.
One line complains about being treated as the sidekick — "tired of being Ringo when I know I was John" — and the answer is "Everybody loves Ringo." The analogy is how both men argue about who authored the work: "He was John 'cause he wrote 'Ticket to Ride.' And I wrote the Apple II."
Up next · Chapter 16a bicycle for the mindSculley Visits Jobs Backstage
Chapter 1more than likelyThe Voice Demo Crashes Before Launch
Chapter 2where do you get offSteve Denies Lisa Is His Daughter
Chapter 3make a dent in the universeBackstage Before the Launch
Chapter 4out of the loopAdoption Question Before the Keynote
Chapter 5have a chip on your shoulderJobs Refuses to See the VIP Guests
Chapter 6back to the drawing boardFriend Calls NeXT a Failure
Chapter 7know peopleChrisann Confronts Jobs About Money
Chapter 8off the recordNeXT Has No Operating System
Chapter 9drag your feetBuilding the Steve Jobs Revenge Machine
Chapter 10How's that for somethingSteve Rehearses the Macworld Keynote
Chapter 11cross meJobs Backstage Before the Keynote
Chapter 12take some of the sting offJobs Won't Pay Lisa's Tuition
Chapter 13you don't get toAndy Paid Lisa's Tuition
Chapter 14lock it inJobs Picks the 39th Shark
Watching · Chapter 15live and die byWoz Confronts Jobs Backstage
Chapter 16a bicycle for the mindSculley Visits Jobs BackstageThe expressions marked in the script, each on its own page with the lines where it is said.
“John was upset that you went off into a room to record this by yourself. Me and Ringo was it went off into a room and John went, "Oh, I guess that's the way it's got to be." But didn't we used to all just record together and now Paul's going off on his own and playing all the parts?”
“No. No. But it's John. I honestly thought you going to be a lot more together than this. You know that being such a well organized man. When I hear you on the radio, just the pumbling you give those poor politicians. Honestly, it's like lamb to slaughter.”
“Maybe at the end of the day I will agree with Joey Reid. But I just I'm just so sick of this you know, glazing of John Ow. I'm like, I get it. He's he's very handsome. He's a good speaker.”
“When I met John, he was kind of a little awkward, a little clumsy, a little not, you know, so slick.”

Please. You have to tell me why it's so important for it to say hello.

It was a bad idea to have Markkula open with quarterly reports.

It's having no control.

Your computer's gonna fail.

I threw the bowl on the floor.

It's like this. Avie Tevanian is our chief software designer, and he wrote a demo program.