...away from her now.The Great Gatsby · 2013 — Chapter 12 of 18 · 5'22" · B1
Gatsby Refuses to Let the Past Go, Explained: repeat the past
Gatsby insists Daisy can still be his, and that they can go back to how things were five years ago. One line cuts at the fantasy: "You can't repeat the past." His reply is flat refusal to accept it — "Why, of course you can" — and the film then shows where that belief was born.
What happens
After the party, Gatsby tells Nick that Daisy was unhappy and now wants to run away, and he reveals his plan: Daisy will tell Tom she never loved him, and they will return to Louisville to be married. Nick objects that the past cannot be repeated, but Gatsby refuses to believe it and describes how they fell in love five years earlier.
Listen for
couldn't care lessrepeat the pastlet myself gostart over
00:00 / 05:22Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
Tap a line to replay it
Phrase of the scene
repeat the past
重演过去；让过去再来一次
尼克对盖茨比说过去无法重演，盖茨比立刻反问为什么不能。
History often repeats the past when nobody learns from it.
Also in this scene
- couldn't care less
一点也不在乎
- let myself go
放任自己；不再克制
- start over
to begin again from the start
Everything marked in this scene
35 notes across 94 lines
It's so hard to make her understand.liaison
It's so hard to make her understand.I couldn't care less about the parties.negative emphasis
I couldn't care less about the parties....she has to tell Tom that she never loved him.Her parents are lovely people, old sport. We'll be...to begin again from the start
See, Daisy and I are gonna start over just as if it were five years ago.subjunctive
See, Daisy and I are gonna start over just as if it were five years ago.I wouldn't ask too much of her.You can't repeat the past.modal negative
You can't repeat the past.liaison
You can't repeat the past.I'm gonna fix things......just the way they were before.Everything's been so confused since then. I......as if he wanted to recover something.If I could just get back to the start......of himself that he had put into loving Daisy.One night in Louisville, five years ago......Gatsby found himself at Daisy's house by colossal accident.I'd never been in such a beautiful house.I'd never been in such a beautiful house.weak form
I'd never been in such a beautiful house.May I save the next dance?...a penniless young man......grand vision of himself....if I climbed alone....forever wed to her....the mind of God.And then I just let myself go.She blossomed for him like a flower...I knew it was a great mistake for a man like me to fall in love.I just need to give her more time, old sport.You're wrong about the past, old sport.Gatsby Refuses to Let the Past Go, explained
What's really going on
Gatsby's whole plan depends on a sentence he wants Daisy to say — "she never loved him" — as if erasing Tom from the past would restore the five years he lost. Nick's warning, "You can't repeat the past," is answered with "Why, of course you can," because Gatsby is not talking about memory but about control. The flashback that follows shows the source: a young man who believed he could only climb if he climbed alone, and who fixed his dream onto one girl. What the scene shows is that his dream was built before she was.
Theme
DreamsGatsby believes the past can be recovered and rebuilt, treating his old love as a goal still within reach.
MemoryNick narrates a man who keeps talking about the past as if trying to recover something he lost.
What you'll learn
- Use you can't repeat the past as a warning
- Hear couldn't care less as total indifference
- Use start over and as if for a reset
- Catch old sport as Gatsby's pet name
- Hear of course you can as stubborn hope
Listen for
- make her understand — liaison
- repeat the past — liaison
- never been in — weak form
I knew it was a great mistake for a man like me to fall in love.Gatsby looks back and admits love was a risk he should not have taken, given where he came from.
My life has got to be like this.A declaration that his life must keep climbing, with no room for standing still or for the past to catch him.
You're wrong about the past, old sport.Gatsby's parting shot to Nick, insisting that the past is not fixed and can still be changed.
It's got to keep going up.The rule Gatsby lives by: everything must rise, a self-made man's refusal to let his life level off.
Questions about this scene
Why does Gatsby want Daisy to tell Tom she never loved him?
He wants the past rewritten so that only he was ever in her heart. If she says she never loved Tom, then the five years apart become a mistake he can undo.
What does Nick mean by "You can't repeat the past"?
Nick is warning Gatsby that time cannot be reversed. He thinks Gatsby is chasing a memory that no longer exists, no matter how much money or effort he spends.
Why does the film flash back to Louisville?
The flashback shows where Gatsby's belief comes from. It reveals him as a penniless young man who fell for Daisy and built his entire ambition around her.
What does "old sport" tell us about Gatsby here?
It is his signature old-fashioned address, used warmly and often. In these scenes it also keeps a distance, letting him stay calm and in control while insisting the past can be fixed.
The Great Gatsby · 18 chapters
All chapters →
Up next · Chapter 13Have it your own wayGatsby Meets Tom at Lunch
Chapter 1reserve all judgmentsNick Begins His Story
Chapter 2have the decencyNick Dines with the Buchanans
Chapter 3sit on the sidelineTom's Secret Apartment Party
Chapter 4old sportNick Searches for Gatsby
Chapter 5a pack of liesGatsby Tells Nick His Life Story
Chapter 6keeps his mouth shutGatsby's Lunch with a Gambler
Chapter 7pomp and circumstanceJordan Tells Gatsby's Backstory
Chapter 8acting like a little boyGatsby's Awkward Reunion with Daisy
Chapter 9If it wasn't forGatsby Shows Daisy His Mansion
Chapter 10to your likingTom and Daisy Join Gatsby's Party
Chapter 11make a point ofDaisy Wants to Run Away
Watching · Chapter 12repeat the pastGatsby Refuses to Let the Past Go
Chapter 13Have it your own wayGatsby Meets Tom at Lunch
Chapter 14Nobody From NowhereTom Calls Gatsby Nobody From Nowhere
Chapter 15in our bloodTom Exposes Gatsby at the Hotel
Chapter 16pull yourself togetherThe Yellow Car After the Crash
Chapter 17keep your voice downGatsby Waits Outside Daisy's House
Chapter 18made something of myselfGatsby Keeps Vigil Until DawnChapter 12 of 18 · about 24 min to go