Sense and Sensibility · 1995 — Chapter 8 of 27 · 3'04" · B2

Marianne Falls in the Rain, Explained: at death's door

A parcel from Edward arrives with a curiously cold letter, and Marianne keeps asking why he has not come. After a talk with her mother about Edward, Elinor takes Marianne walking; they are caught in the rain, and Marianne falls and hurts her ankle. "You must run and fetch help," she tells Elinor.

What happens

Edward sends Marianne the atlas she wanted, but the letter with it is oddly distant and he does not come. Elinor admits to her mother that she is not sure of Edward's feelings. She takes Marianne out walking to cheer her, and when rain starts and Marianne slips and injures her ankle, Elinor runs for help.

Parents & kidsSiblingsComplainingConfessingSiblingsB2mediumbritishClean
IMDb ↗

Listen for

at death's doordevoted servanta bad influenceby no means

00:00 / 03:04
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
  1. ❝ MonologueA Letter of Apology6 linesPractice page ↗
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

at death's door

extremely ill, close to death

When the colonel is called infirm, Elinor retorts that she must then be at death's door.

The old dog was at death's door last winter.

Also in this scene

  • devoted servant

    a loyal servant

  • a bad influence

    someone who leads others astray

  • by no means

    not at all

  • one's head

    one's reason

  • fetch help

    go and get assistance

Everything marked in this scene

21 notes across 46 lines

Phrase · A2
a parcel has arrived

a parcel came

A parcel's arrived for you.
Sound
parcel's arrived

The final s of parcel's slides straight into arrived.

A parcel's arrived for you.
Phrase · B1
when is someone safe

when is anyone safe

It is ridiculous. When is a man safe?
Phrase · B2
age and infirmity

old age and frailty

- Age and infirmity do not protect him. - Infirmity?
Phrase · B2
be at death's door

extremely ill, close to death

When the colonel is called infirm, Elinor retorts that she must then be at death's door.

If Brandon is infirm, then I am at death's door.
Sound
miracle you're

You're often weakens to yer inside a sentence.

It is a miracle you're still alive.
Phrase · B1
that was his phrase

that was his wording

"A slight ache," I believe was his phrase.
Phrase · B1
bring something oneself

deliver it in person

But Edward said he would bring it himself.
Phrase · B2
the rightful owner

the true owner

it gives me great pleasure to restore this atlas to its rightful owner.
Phrase · B1
far more than something

much more than

This is likely to hurt me far more than it hurts you.
Phrase · B2
for the present

for now

For the present, my memories of your kindness must sustain me.
Phrase · B2
your devoted servant

a loyal servant

Edward closes his letter with the formal line 'I remain your devoted servant', which feels more distant than warm.

I remain your devoted servant.
Phrase · B1
a bad influence on someone

someone who leads others astray

Elinor blames Mrs. Jennings for encouraging Marianne's reckless streak, calling her a bad influence.

I fear Mrs. Jennings is a bad influence.
Phrase · B2
by no means

not at all

When her mother insists Edward loves her, Marianne answers that she is by no means sure of it.

I am by no means assured of his regard for me.
Grammar · C1
Were he to feel

inverted conditional: Dropping if and fronting were makes the condition sound more hypothetical and formal.

Were he to feel such a preference, I think we should be foolish to assume...
Grammar · B2
his marrying a woman

possessive with gerund: The possessive his marks who would do the marrying inside the gerund phrase.

that there would not be many obstacles to his marrying a woman of no rank...
Phrase · B2
use one's head

think rationally

In such a situation, it is perhaps better to use one's head.
Phrase · B2
superior to something

better than

Is there any felicity in the world superior to this?
Grammar · B2
supposed to run

be supposed to: It marks what is expected or permitted, here with a rueful sense of breaking the rule.

- Let us chase it. - I'm not supposed to run.
Sound
must run and

Drop the t in must and run run and together.

I do not think I can walk. You must run and fetch help.
Phrase · A2
as fast as one can

at top speed

I will run as fast as I can.

Marianne Falls in the Rain, explained

What's really going on

The scene moves in one long emotional arc from a small disappointment to a literal fall. The parcel from Edward should be a gift, but the letter that comes with it is cold and formal, and Marianne cannot stop asking why he has not come himself. Then the film shifts to Elinor, who tells her mother plainly, 'I am by no means assured of his regard for me.' It is the most she will admit, and it defines her: she feels deeply but keeps it in. Marianne insists on the romantic reading — 'Is there any felicity in the world superior to this?' — and the rain begins almost as an answer. Her fall in the wet field is both accident and image: the sister who trusts feeling is the one who goes down, and the sister who thinks must run for help.

Theme

RomanceThe parcel and the unanswered questions about Edward define the sisters' different ways of loving and hoping.
ClassElinor's doubts about Edward include the plain fact that she cannot afford to buy sugar.

What you'll learn

  • A letter can be more distant than silence.
  • Marianne denies a bond she clearly feels.
  • The storm she chases is really her own recklessness.
  • Formal courtesy in a love letter reads as a warning.

Listen for

  • parcel's arrived — The final s of parcel's slides straight into arrived.
  • miracle you're — You're often weakens to yer inside a sentence.
  • must run and — Drop the t in must and run run and together.
It is ridiculous. When is a man safe?

A joke about Colonel Brandon being hunted as a husband: even age and poor health are no protection.

If Brandon is infirm, then I am at death's door.

A dry self-mocking line: if the robust Brandon counts as frail, the speaker must be nearly dead.

This is likely to hurt me far more than it hurts you.

Edward's claim in the letter that giving up the atlas costs him more pain than it costs Marianne.

You always say that, and then it always does.

Marianne's teasing about the weather, said to the sister who insists it will not rain.

Is there any felicity in the world superior to this?

Marianne's romantic delight in the countryside, spoken just before the rain and her fall.

Questions about this scene

Why is Marianne upset about Edward's parcel?

Edward sends back the atlas with a letter instead of coming himself, and the letter is cold and formal. Marianne keeps asking why he has not come.

What does Elinor admit to her mother?

That she is by no means assured of Edward's regard for her, and that in such cases it may be better to use one's head.

Why does Marianne fall?

Elinor takes her out walking to lift her spirits, they are caught in the rain, and Marianne slips in the wet field and injures her ankle.

What does "at death's door" mean?

It means very close to death. Elinor jokes that if the soldier Brandon is considered infirm, then she herself must be at death's door.

How does the scene end?

Marianne says she cannot walk and tells Elinor to run and fetch help; Elinor answers that she will run as fast as she can.

Sense and Sensibility · 27 chapters

All chapters →
Up next · Chapter 9set your cap atWilloughby Rescues Marianne
Chapter 1discharge my promiseJohn Dashwood's Deathbed PromiseChapter 2not to be borneThe Dashwoods Lose NorlandChapter 3by any chanceEdward Ferrars Visits NorlandChapter 4do me the honourEdward and Elinor Talk of Their FuturesChapter 5formed an attachmentMarianne and Elinor Debate LoveChapter 6eligible bachelorMrs. Jennings Teases Marianne at DinnerChapter 7on what groundsMrs. Jennings Tells Brandon's StoryWatching · Chapter 8at death's doorMarianne Falls in the RainChapter 9set your cap atWilloughby Rescues MarianneChapter 10crawling withWilloughby Visits Barton CottageChapter 11set something at naughtBrandon Invites Them to DelafordChapter 12swallow one's bonnetColonel Brandon Leaves the PicnicChapter 13force a confidenceWilloughby's Abrupt FarewellChapter 14the whip handLucy Tells Elinor Her SecretChapter 15brook no refusalLucy Reveals Her Secret EngagementChapter 16once and for allBrandon Asks About WilloughbyChapter 17set her heart at restMrs. Jennings Presents Robert FerrarsChapter 18confide inWilloughby Snubs Marianne at the BallChapter 19engaged elsewhereWilloughby's Letter to MarianneChapter 20imagine the worstBrandon Confesses His Past to ElinorChapter 21take a fancy toBrandon Tells Elinor the TruthChapter 22take my leaveEdward Calls on the Dashwood SistersChapter 23break one's wordElinor's Secret Finally Comes OutChapter 24only too delightedBrandon Offers Edward a LivingChapter 25stroke of luckMarianne Walks Out Before the StormChapter 26does it follow thatMarianne Revisits Where She FellChapter 27not a wordA Visitor Arrives at Barton Cottage
Chapter 8 of 27 · about 64 min to go