“Will you not shake hands with me?”
Why it's great
One negative question exposes the whole wound: he will not even touch her.
Register
Neutral
Use it yourself
Will you not even say hello to me?
00:00 / 03:28
00:00 / 03:28
Willoughby Snubs Marianne at the Ball, Explained
Sense and Sensibility · 1995
Chapter 18 of 27 · 3'28"
At the London ball, Marianne rushes to Willoughby and asks why he has not come to see her, but he is cold and formal, answering only that he must rejoin his party. "Will you not shake hands with me?" she asks. Elinor takes her away, and the sisters quarrel about trust on the way home.
Key moments
Start here, then watch the full scene- 0:30–1:16
Willoughby Snubs Marianne
45s - 3:05–3:27
The Sisters Quarrel About Trust
22s
Willoughby Snubs Marianne at the Ball, explained
What happens
At a London ball, Marianne finally meets Willoughby, but he greets her coldly and refuses her plea to explain himself, saying he must return to his party. Elinor leads her away. On the way home the sisters argue: Elinor complains that Marianne has no confidence in her, and Marianne answers that Elinor confides in no one.
What's really going on
The scene is the moment Marianne's romantic world breaks. She has been waiting for Willoughby, and when she reaches him he treats her like a stranger, his politeness doing the work of cruelty. Her question, 'Will you not shake hands with me?' is the whole wound in one line — she is asking whether he will acknowledge her at all. The sisters' argument afterwards is the film's central debate arriving in the open: Elinor accuses Marianne of never confiding in her, and Marianne answers that Elinor communicates nothing. Both are right, and the exchange shows how differently they manage feeling — one by hiding, one by showing — and how little either can do about Willoughby himself.
Key lines & what they mean
- “Will you not shake hands with me?”
- Marianne's plea for the most basic acknowledgement, after Willoughby greets her like a stranger.
- “Were you not in London? Have you not received my letters?”
- Her questions insisting that something has gone wrong, since she expected letters and visits that never came.
- “For heaven's sake, Willoughby. Tell me what is wrong.”
- Her urgent demand for an explanation, spoken in front of others because he will not speak to her privately.
- “This reproach from you? You who confide in no one?”
- Marianne turning Elinor's accusation back on her: the sister who says she is shut out is herself closed.
- “I, because I conceal nothing, and you, because you communicate nothing.”
- The argument in one sentence: two sisters who handle their feelings in opposite ways, each accusing the other.
- “If I might be so bold, it would be our pleasure to escort your charge home.”
- A polished offer to escort Marianne home, delivered with the courtesy that makes the gossip harmless on the surface.
Theme
- Heartbreak — Marianne is publicly snubbed by the man she loves, and the coldness of his greeting breaks her composure.
- Trust — The sisters argue over who confides in whom, exposing their opposite ways of handling private feeling.
What this chapter teaches
Teaching points
Review right after watchingMy level3/8
A1–C2 is the CEFR scale. Cards above the level you pick fade, and playback will not auto-pause on them.
Language points
Click a card to jump to its moment in the videoGolden lines
A great line in its own right — why and how to use it“Were you not in London? Have you not received my letters?”
Why it's great
Two negative questions in a row corner him with facts he cannot deny.
Register
Neutral
Use it yourself
Have you not received my emails all week?
“For heaven's sake, Willoughby. Tell me what is wrong.”
Why it's great
It pleads and demands at once, which is exactly how desperation sounds.
Register
Informal
Use it yourself
For heaven's sake, tell me what the letter said.
“This reproach from you? You who confide in no one?”
Why it's great
She turns his own reserve against him, so the rebuke cannot be answered.
Register
Neutral
Use it yourself
This reproach from you? You're never on time either.
“I, because I conceal nothing, and you, because you communicate nothing.”
Why it's great
The balanced clauses define both sisters in a single breath, fair and cutting.
Register
Formal
Use it yourself
I, because I ask first, and you, because you never ask at all.
“If I might be so bold, it would be our pleasure to escort your charge home.”
Why it's great
Its extreme courtesy hides a calculated move, which is what makes it memorable.
Register
Formal
Use it yourself
If I might be so bold, it would be our pleasure to drive you home.
Up next · 19engaged elsewhereThe scene: Willoughby's Letter to MarianneTakeaways
What you walk away with- A refused handshake says more here than any speech.
- Politeness can be the coldest thing in the room.
- The sisters' quarrel is really about who hides what.
- Confiding is the trust the whole family lacks.
People also search
Questions, then the linesWhy does Willoughby snub Marianne?
He behaves as though they barely know each other, refusing to explain and saying only that he must rejoin his party. The reason is kept back for later in the film.
Why is Marianne so upset?
She has waited for Willoughby and written to him, and now he greets her coldly in public and will not shake her hand, so her hopes collapse in front of everyone.
Why do the sisters argue on the way home?
Elinor says Marianne has no confidence in her, and Marianne replies that Elinor is the one who confides in no one. Each is accusing the other of hiding her feelings.
What does "confide in" mean?
It means to share your private thoughts with someone. Marianne uses it to say that Elinor never tells anyone what she feels.
Why does Lucy say the Dashwoods are wearing country fashions?
It is a small social sneer: in London, country dress marks them as provincial, and Lucy enjoys pointing it out.