Garden State · 2004 — 第 2 / 11 章 · 2'59" · B2

医生谈停药与心理治疗:in no position to comment on

诊室里,一个年轻人正说着反复发作的头痛,医生一句 in no position to comment on(没资格评论),跟着又把药说成 as a means to an end(达到目的的手段)。想表达「我不了解你,不便下判断」,这两句比干巴巴的一句不知道更体面,也更能划清界限。

发生了什么

诊室里,一个年轻人告诉医生自己反复头痛,也提到长期服药、最近停药,还怀疑自己也许根本没病。医生没有替他下结论,而是用 in no position to comment on(没资格/不适合评论)说明自己不了解他的经历;又把药的可能作用说成 as a means to an end(作为达到目的的手段),提醒吃药只是权宜之计。还有一句 peek its head out of the water(冒头;浮出水面)很形象:不做心理治疗,脑子里的东西迟早会冒出来。这几句适合在需要谨慎表态、解释权宜之计、描述潜伏问题时用。

生活 · 看病解释建议医患B2快速美音无脏话
IMDb ↗

这场戏看什么

  • 注意医生先开玩笑再追问的反差节奏
  • 留意病人说药史时的迟疑和停顿
  • 看医生如何用隐喻警告不治疗的风险

留意这几个短语

a surge of electricityas far back as I can rememberwrite you a prescriptionit's amazing you can even hear me now

00:00 / 02:59
空格 播放 · ← → 换句 · R 单句循环
此刻
  1. ❝ 独白医生的两条忠告5 句专题跟读 ↗
点一句台词就从那里放

本章短语

in no position to comment on

没资格/不适合评论not qualified to comment on

医生先划清界限:不知道对方完整经历,所以用 in no position to comment on(没资格/不适合评论)表示不能替他决定停不停药。语气专业、克制,既给建议又避免越界。

I'm in no position to comment on your family decision.我没资格评论你家里的决定。

本章还有

  • a surge of electricity

    一股电流般的感觉

  • as far back as I can remember

    从我记事起

  • write you a prescription

    给你开处方

  • it's amazing you can even hear me now

    反讽:你居然还听得见我说话

  • know better

    该明白不该这么做

本章全部批注

42 句台词里标了 31 处

俚语 · A2
Just kidding

开个玩笑——熟人玩笑用,正式场合别用。

Just kidding. How would I know that?
发音
What can we

What can we 连成一口气,can 很轻,别把三个词拆开重读。

What can we do for you today, Andrew?
短语 · B1
get really intense headaches

反复犯剧烈头痛

I've been getting these really intense headaches.
短语 · B1
a split second

一瞬间;极短时间

Um, they last for, like, a split second.
发音
for, like, a

for, like, a 糊成一小团,like 很轻,重音留给 split second。

Um, they last for, like, a split second.
短语 · B2
a surge of + noun

一股电流般的感觉

病人形容头痛只持续一瞬,像闪电,又像 a surge of electricity(一股电流般的感觉)冲过,然后消失。语气在努力找词,带点困惑。

It's like lightening. It's like a surge of electricity, and then it's gone.
短语 · B1
some form of something

某种同类药物 it 指锂盐这类药

Um, I've been on some form of it since I was ten or so.
短语 · B2
as far back as I can remember

从我记事起

病人说,自己可能没病也不知道,因为 as far back as I can remember(从我记事起),他就一直离不开药。语气迟疑,像在拼一段被药物盖住的童年。

Only, I'd never know it, because as far back as I can remember, I've been medicated. I left them in L.A., though.
语法 · B2
as far back as I can remember

时间状语从句:as far back as... 表示时间一直回溯到某点,这里指“从记事起”。

Only, I'd never know it, because as far back as I can remember, I've been medicated. I left them in L.A., though.
短语 · B1
leave someone's body

从体内代谢掉

Well, that stuff will leave your body pretty fast. I could write you a prescription.
短语 · B1
write someone a prescription

给你开处方

医生很实际:药会很快排出体外,需要的话他可以 write you a prescription(给你开处方)。语气像例行问诊,也顺手把选择递给对方。

Well, that stuff will leave your body pretty fast. I could write you a prescription.
短语 · A2
take a vacation

休假;此处指停药一段 这里不是去旅行,是委婉说暂时停药

Actually, I was thinking about taking a vacation.
短语 · B1
stay on something

继续服用那种药 it 指锂盐等药

Yeah, so I think he'd prefer me to stay on it.
短语 · B2
be consumed with + emotion

被压力和焦虑占据 consumed 不是被吃掉,是被占满

You know, our bodies are capable of doing some very funny things when they're consumed with stress and anxiety.
俚语 · B2
ex-best friend

前死党——熟人八卦用,正式写作说 former best friend。

I found my ex-best friend's cufflinks in my wife's purse.
短语 · B2
have someone on + medication

让你一直服用某药 on 后省略了锂盐

Well, with all the lithium he's had you on, it's amazing you can even hear me now.
发音
had you on

had you 的 /d/ 与 /j/ 常连成 /dʒ/,you 弱化为 /jə/;舌尖轻抵上齿龈再滑向 /j/,重音压在 had 和 on。

Well, with all the lithium he's had you on, it's amazing you can even hear me now.
语法 · B2
a psychiatrist that isn't your father

定语从句:that isn't your father 修饰 psychiatrist,限定“不是父亲”的医生。

Look, Andrew, first of all, I think you do need to find a psychiatrist that isn't your father.
短语 · B2
should have been + past participle

多年前就该被纠正

That's something that should have been remedied years ago. He knows better!
短语 · B2
know better

该明白不该这么做

医生听到病人的心理医生就是父亲,直接说这事早该纠正,又用 know better(该明白不该这么做)说父亲本该懂边界。语气不客气,带责备。

That's something that should have been remedied years ago. He knows better!
短语 · C1
be in no position to do something

没资格/不适合评论

医生先划清界限:不知道对方完整经历,所以用 in no position to comment on(没资格/不适合评论)表示不能替他决定停不停药。语气专业、克制,既给建议又避免越界。

And secondly... I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not, 'cause I don't know your story.
短语 · B2
know someone's story

了解对方经历 story 不是故事,是病史和经历

And secondly... I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not, 'cause I don't know your story.
语法 · C1
whether you should stay on the meds or not

whether 从句:whether...or not 作 comment on 的宾语,表示“是否”;去掉后意思不完整。

And secondly... I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not, 'cause I don't know your story.
俚语 · B1
meds

药——日常口语,正式写作说 medication。

And secondly... I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not, 'cause I don't know your story.
短语 · B1
since someone is paying for it

既然你付了钱

But my opinion , since you're paying for it, is that yeah, those drugs may help you as a means to an end.
短语 · C1
as a means to an end

作为达到目的的手段

医生先说自己没资格判断,又补一句:既然对方付钱,那药或许能帮到某个目标,把药说成 as a means to an end(作为达到目的的手段)。语气冷静、务实,不是鼓励长期依赖。

But my opinion , since you're paying for it, is that yeah, those drugs may help you as a means to an end.
短语 · B1
sooner or later

迟早

But sooner or later, if you're not in therapy, whatever's going on in your mind will find a way to peek its head out of the water.
短语 · B1
find a way to do something

找到办法做某事

But sooner or later, if you're not in therapy, whatever's going on in your mind will find a way to peek its head out of the water.
语法 · C1
whatever's going on in your mind

主语从句:whatever 引导的从句整体作 will find 的主语,指“你脑子里不管有什么事”。

But sooner or later, if you're not in therapy, whatever's going on in your mind will find a way to peek its head out of the water.
发音
sooner or later

sooner or later 整块快带,重音落在 soon 和 late,or 几乎滑过。

But sooner or later, if you're not in therapy, whatever's going on in your mind will find a way to peek its head out of the water.
短语 · A2
take something off

脱掉某物

I'll need you to take your shoes off. I have to scratch your feet.

看懂「医生谈停药与心理治疗」

发音重点

  • What can we — What can we 连成一口气,can 很轻,别把三个词拆开重读。
  • for, like, a — for, like, a 糊成一小团,like 很轻,重音留给 split second。
  • had you on — had you 的 /d/ 与 /j/ 常连成 /dʒ/,you 弱化为 /jə/;舌尖轻抵上齿龈再滑向 /j/,重音压在 had 和 on。
  • sooner or later — sooner or later 整块快带,重音落在 soon 和 late,or 几乎滑过。
It's recently occurred to me I might not even have a problem.

我最近意识到,我也许根本就没病。 把多年用药后的自我怀疑压成一句,语气轻却可怖。

This is the first time I haven't had medicine in my body for a long time.

这是很久以来,我第一次体内没有药。 用 first time 加完成时,把“停药”说成一种陌生的自由。

And secondly... I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not, 'cause I don't know your story.

第二,我没资格评论你该不该继续吃药,因为我不了解你的经历。 把专业边界说得既坦白又不冷漠,whether 从句拉出犹豫感。

But sooner or later, if you're not in therapy, whatever's going on in your mind will find a way to peek its head out of the water.

但迟早,如果你不做心理治疗,你脑子里的事总会找到办法冒出头来。 把心理问题写成水里探头的东西,警告不吓人却难忘。

Yeah, you're all right. You're alive.

是的,你没事。你还活着。 两句短话都不把话说满,只递一个最硬的事实:你还活着,冷里带一点暖。

关于这一章的问题

in no position to comment on 是什么意思?

意思是「没资格/不适合评论」。医生说这话,是因为不了解对方的情况,所以不判断对方该不该继续吃药。

「作为达到目的的手段」英语怎么说?

as a means to an end。台词里说那些药可能帮得上忙,算是达成目的的一种手段;医生随后强调,不做心理治疗,问题迟早会冒出来。

peek its head out of the water 在台词里指什么?

字面是「冒头、浮出水面」,台词里指脑子里那些东西迟早会找机会显现出来。医生用这个说法说明,不做心理治疗,问题不会自己消失。

know better 是「更懂」吗?

不是。台词里的 knows better 是「该明白不该这么做」,说的是父亲本该知道不能这样安排,这事多年前就该纠正。

write you a prescription 是什么意思?

意思是「给你开处方」。医生说那种药从身体里排掉很快,接着提出可以开处方,但话题随后转向了停药。

情归新泽西 · 共 11 章

全部章节 →
看到第 2 / 11 章 · 后面还有约 29 分钟