Won't You Be My Neighbor? · 2018 — 第 15 / 15 章 · 2'12" · C1

被指毁掉一代人:anything sensational

访谈里,一句 narcissistic society(自恋成风的社会)把「每个孩子都重要」和这种风气连在一起,紧接着一句 destroyed a generation(毁掉一代人)把批评推到最重。想学怎么转述尖锐的批评,这两句就够用,写评论、吵架都用得上。

发生了什么

访谈里,一句 Do you believe his philosophy destroyed a generation?(你觉得他的理念毁掉了一代人吗?)把争论推到最尖锐的地方。接着一句 evil, evil man(这位大恶人)把指控说得夸张。批评的说法是,孩子不用努力就能得到「特别」。但话题随后转到 inherent value(内在价值):如果不信每个人都有价值,那用 might as well(倒不如)就可以说,这也违背了信仰的根本。最后一场毕业演讲把话说透:你永远不必做 anything sensational(任何惊人之举)才配被爱。这些说法适合写评论、辩论或安慰朋友时用。

冲突 · 指控质问表达 · 演讲动员质问解释C1中速美音无脏话
IMDb ↗

这场戏看什么

  • 留意质问与道谢之间语气怎样翻转
  • 看 special 从口号变成“天生有价值”
  • 注意抽象词如何被具体往事接住

留意这几个短语

evil, evil mannarcissistic societydestroyed a generationmight as well

00:00 / 02:12
空格 播放 · ← → 换句 · R 单句循环
此刻
  1. ❝ 独白被误读的特别7 句专题跟读 ↗
  2. ❝ 独白不必做惊人之事5 句专题跟读 ↗
点一句台词就从那里放

本章短语

anything sensational

任何惊人之举any grand, attention-grabbing act

谈到“特别”到底什么意思时,这句 anything sensational 把落点放在爱不需要惊人成就;语气温和,却很确定,不容反驳。

You don't need to do anything sensational to make your family proud.你不需要做什么惊人之举,才能让家人骄傲。

本章还有

  • evil, evil man

    反讽:这位大恶人

  • narcissistic society

    自恋成风的社会

  • destroyed a generation

    毁掉一代人

  • might as well

    倒不如;还不如

  • Bless your heart

    真是难为你/祝福你

本章全部批注

29 句台词里标了 28 处

短语 · B1
so much to think about / so much to do

要操心的事很多

There's so much to think about, isn't there?
发音
isn't there

isn't there 快带过,重音留给 much 和 think

There's so much to think about, isn't there?
短语 · A2
ask someone something

问你一件事

Let me ask you something about what we've -been discussing for the last three hours. -Woman: Yeah.
短语 · B1
have been discussing something

一直在讨论

Let me ask you something about what we've -been discussing for the last three hours. -Woman: Yeah.
短语 · B2
give birth to something

催生;导致 字面是生育,这里指催生一种社会现象。

-Yeah. -Mr. Rogers and the narcissistic society that he gave birth to because he told every kid that they were important.
语法 · B2
that he gave birth to

定语从句:that 作 to 的宾语,修饰 society,说明“他催生的社会”。

-Yeah. -Mr. Rogers and the narcissistic society that he gave birth to because he told every kid that they were important.
短语 · B2
destroy a generation

毁掉一代人

有人用 destroyed a generation 追问:对方是否相信他的理念毁了一代人;问题把抽象争论压成严重罪名。

Do you believe his philosophy destroyed a generation?
短语 · B1
go like this

话是这么说的

The criticism goes like this: "You told everyone they're special.
短语 · B1
do anything to earn something

费劲争取

"They don't have to do anything to earn that special.
短语 · B1
what's wrong with something

问题出在

"That's what's wrong with our country.
俚语 · A2
gonna

将要——口语缩略,朋友聊天常用,正式写作别用

He didn't say, "if you want to be special, you're gonna have to work hard."
短语 · A2
grow up

长大成人

And now all these kids are growing up, and they're realizing, "hey, wait a minute.
短语 · C1
talking about something

谈的是特权心态 entitlement 这里不是“权利”,而是觉得自己该受特殊待遇。

I'm sure by then Fred had heard the criticisms, but he's not talking about entitlement.
语法 · B2
had heard

过去完成时:had heard 表示在“by then”之前已听过批评,比后面的 he's not talking 更早。

I'm sure by then Fred had heard the criticisms, but he's not talking about entitlement.
短语 · C1
inherent value

内在价值

And if you don't believe that everyone has inherent value,
语法 · B2
if you don't believe that everyone has inherent value

条件状语从句:if 从句先给前提;主句再用 might as well 推出“那倒不如说…”。

And if you don't believe that everyone has inherent value,
短语 · B2
might as well do something

倒不如;还不如

有人把“人人有内在价值”和基督教“蒙爱的儿女”并置,说若不信前者,那也等于背离后者;句子里用 might as well 把这层推论说出来。

you might as well go against the fundamental notion of christianity that you are the beloved son or daughter of god.
短语 · B2
go against something

违背

you might as well go against the fundamental notion of christianity that you are the beloved son or daughter of god.
发音
might as well

might as well 挤成一口气,as 轻,重音在 might 和 well

you might as well go against the fundamental notion of christianity that you are the beloved son or daughter of god.
短语 · B1
be allowed to do something

不获准做某事

I wasn't allowed to go to preschool 'cause I had a disability, and my mom made me watch your show every day.
俚语 · A2
'cause

因为——口语省音说法,闲聊可以,正式场合换 because

I wasn't allowed to go to preschool 'cause I had a disability, and my mom made me watch your show every day.
短语 · C1
give a commencement speech

毕业典礼演讲

At the very end of Fred's very last commencement speech, he said what he meant when he'd say, "you're special."
短语 · C1
do anything sensational

任何惊人之举

谈到“特别”到底什么意思时,这句 anything sensational 把落点放在爱不需要惊人成就;语气温和,却很确定,不容反驳。

And what that ultimately means, of course, is that you don't ever have to do anything sensational for people to love you.
语法 · C1
what that ultimately means

主语从句:what that ultimately means 是整个句子的主语,后面 is that... 才给解释。

And what that ultimately means, of course, is that you don't ever have to do anything sensational for people to love you.
发音
have to

have to 快说时挤成一拍,两个词别分太开

And what that ultimately means, of course, is that you don't ever have to do anything sensational for people to love you.
短语 · C1
a matter of doing something

关键在于相信

It is really a matter of believing that you're endowed by your creator with good.
短语 · B1
ways of saying something

表达方式

话锋从宏大论证转到日常表达时,这句 ways of saying 把“我爱你”拆成许多可说可做的方式,语气放松下来。

You know, there are many different ways of saying, "i love you."
短语 · B1
show one's love

表达爱意

In fact, I like to think about times when I've seen people showing their love.

看懂「被指毁掉一代人」

发音重点

  • isn't there — isn't there 快带过,重音留给 much 和 think
  • might as well — might as well 挤成一口气,as 轻,重音在 might 和 well
  • have to — have to 快说时挤成一拍,两个词别分太开
Do you believe his philosophy destroyed a generation?

你相信他的理念毁掉了一代人吗? 把一个宽泛指控压成是非问句,逼对方当场表态,锋利又克制。

I'm sure by then Fred had heard the criticisms, but he's not talking about entitlement.

我确信到那时弗雷德已经听过那些批评,但他谈的不是特权心态。 先承认批评存在,再用 but 把焦点拨回误解,转折干净。

And what that ultimately means, of course, is that you don't ever have to do anything sensational for people to love you.

而那最终意味着,当然,你根本不必做什么惊人之事,才能让人爱你。 把“特别”从成就焦虑里解救出来;长句层层推进,落点温柔而坚定。

You know, there are many different ways of saying, "i love you."

你知道,说“我爱你”有很多种不同的方式。 把宏大主题收回日常:爱不只是一句台词,也是一串具体做法。

关于这一章的问题

anything sensational 是什么意思?

意思是「任何惊人之举」。台词说,你永远不必做 anything sensational 才配得到爱,强调的是不用靠惊天动地的表现来换爱。

「倒不如」英语怎么说?

用 might as well。台词说,如果不相信每个人都有与生俱来的价值,you might as well go against...,意思就是「那也等于违背了……」,带一种「既然如此」的推论。

evil, evil man 是在夸人吗?

不是夸人。台词把 evil 连说两遍,用夸张的「这位大恶人」来讽刺上一句「毁掉一代人」的指控;台词没有标明说话人,不能断定是谁说的。

「毁掉一代人」英语怎么说?

说 destroyed a generation。台词问 Do you believe his philosophy destroyed a generation?,就是问:你觉得他的理念毁掉了一代人吗?

narcissistic society 是什么意思?

意思是「自恋成风的社会」。台词把它和「告诉每个孩子他们很重要」放在一起,是在转述一种批评,不是在夸这个社会。

与我为邻 · 共 15 章

全部章节 →
这部 15 章都在这里了