V for Vendetta · 2006 — 第 9 / 25 章 · 2'24" · B2

V Shows Evey Monte Cristo, Explained:get me every time

On the surface it's movie night: V shares his favorite film, and Evey asks if it has a happy ending. Underneath, the Count of Monte Cristo is a mirror. "It is not my sword, Mondego, but your past that disarmed you." Evey's verdict on the hero is really a warning about V himself.

あらすじ

V invites Evey to watch The Count of Monte Cristo, his favorite film, and she asks whether it has a happy ending. They talk about the story, and Evey says she feels sorry for Mercedes because Edmond Dantes cared more about revenge than about her. Meanwhile Finch's team traces Prothero's death, and a news report announces that the Voice of London is dead.

InvestigationSmall talkExplainingSmall talkFriendsB2slowbritishClean
IMDb ↗

注目の表現

get me every timecelluloidhappy endinglike a ghost

00:00 / 02:24
Space 再生 · ← → セリフ移動 · R リピート
いま
セリフをタップするとそこから再生

このシーンの表現

get me every time

always moves me

At the moment Mondego is broken by his past, V admits the film moves him every single time.

That final scene gets me every time, no matter how often I watch it.

このシーンの他の表現

  • celluloid

    film, the movies

  • happy ending

    a story ending well

  • like a ghost

    vanishing without a trace

  • coincidence

    a chance happening

  • believe in

    trust the existence or value of something

このシーンのメモ一覧

39 行のセリフに 25 件のメモ

表現 · A2wake someone

disturb someone's sleep

Oh, God. I hope I didn't wake you.
表現 · B1for real

genuinely, seriously

No, I just thought you were fighting. I mean, for real.
表現 · A1one's favorite film

the film someone likes best

My favorite film: The Count of Monte Cristo, with Robert Donat as Edmond Dantes.
表現 · C1disarm someone

take away someone's means to resist

It is not my sword, Mondego, but your past that disarmed you.
文法 · C1not my sword, Mondego, but your past that

emphatic not-but: The not-but frame shifts the weight onto your past, so B is presented as the real cause.

It is not my sword, Mondego, but your past that disarmed you.
発音but your past

Link but your into one sound, and run past that together.

It is not my sword, Mondego, but your past that disarmed you.
表現 · B2just wrapped

just finished wrap here means finish a job, not cover with paper

Forensics just wrapped.
スラング · B2Forensics

the forensics team — Standard in police and news talk; rare in daily chat.

Forensics just wrapped.
スラング · B1wrapped

finished a job — Common on film sets and in police talk for finishing up.

Forensics just wrapped.
発音like a ghost

Run like, a and ghost together as one string of sound.

No prints, no hair, no fibers. The guy is like a ghost.
スラング · B1prints

fingerprints — Police shorthand; the full word is fingerprints.

No prints, no hair, no fibers. The guy is like a ghost.
表現 · A2find something on someone

discover something about a person

You won't believe what they found on Prothero.
表現 · B1start one's own something

set up one's own

-Drugs? -Could've started his own hospital.
表現 · B1one of the most / richest ...

among the most

Did you know Lewis Prothero was one of the richest men in the country...
表現 · B2a major stockholder in something

a big owner of shares

Major stockholder in Viadoxic Pharmaceutical.
表現 · A2less than a week

under seven days

Viadoxic and St. Mary's in less than a week. Coincidence?
文法 · B2as long as I've been

comparison clause: As long as compares the two spans, meaning the speaker has done it just as long.

When you're at this as long as I've been, you stop believing in coincidence.
発音at this as

At, this and as blur into a single run of sound.

When you're at this as long as I've been, you stop believing in coincidence.
表現 · A2come up

come upstairs

May we come up?
表現 · A2feel sorry for someone

pity someone

-But it made me feel sorry for Mercedes. -Why?
表現 · B1care more about A than B

value A over B

Because he cared more about revenge than he did about her.
表現 · B1pass away

die, stated gently

...passed away late last night from apparent heart failure.
文法 · B1a story she knows is false

relative clause: The relative clause, with that left out, narrows which story is meant.

She blinks a lot when she does a story she knows is false.
表現 · B2come as no surprise

be entirely expected

It came as no surprise to those who knew him...
表現 · B1work long hours

work late for long stretches

...where he often worked long hours after everyone else had gone home.

「V Shows Evey Monte Cristo」を読み解く

What's really going on

The Monte Cristo screening is V's way of explaining himself without saying it outright. The line he loves, "It is not my sword, Mondego, but your past that disarmed you," is the whole plot of V for Vendetta in miniature: a man undone by what was done to him. Evey misses the point at first, only seeing that the hero neglected Mercedes, but her complaint lands on V, who has invited her into his world while keeping her at arm's length. Her line, "he cared more about revenge than he did about her," is both film criticism and the film's central question. Right after it, the broadcast reports Prothero's death, and V reads the anchor's lie off her blinking: revenge has already become method. The scene quietly sets up the choice Evey will later have to make.

Theme

RevengeMonte Cristo and V both let revenge outlast everything. Evey names it: he cared more about revenge than about her.
DeceptionThe state announces Prothero died of heart failure, and V exposes the lie by watching the anchor blink on air.

このチャプターで学べること

  • Revenge in the film mirrors what V is doing to the city.
  • A veteran stops calling anything a coincidence.
  • No evidence can be its own kind of evidence.
  • The news praises a man the scene has just watched fall.

発音のポイント

  • but your past — Link but your into one sound, and run past that together.
  • like a ghost — Run like, a and ghost together as one string of sound.
  • at this as — At, this and as blur into a single run of sound.
It is not my sword, Mondego, but your past that disarmed you.

A line from the Monte Cristo film V is watching: the hero tells his enemy that guilt and memory, not steel, have already beaten him.

No prints, no hair, no fibers. The guy is like a ghost.

Finch's team found no forensic evidence at the scene, so the attacker seems to leave nothing behind at all.

When you're at this as long as I've been, you stop believing in coincidence.

The veteran detective says that with experience, two suspicious deaths in one week stop looking like chance.

Because he cared more about revenge than he did about her.

Evey's answer about the Monte Cristo hero: she pities Mercedes because the man chose vengeance over the woman he loved.

She blinks a lot when she does a story she knows is false.

V's proof that the news anchor is lying: he has watched her on air and knows her tell.

Lewis, you will be sorely missed.

The closing line of the broadcast's tribute to Prothero, delivered as if the state truly mourns him.

このシーンについての質問

Why does V show Evey The Count of Monte Cristo?

It is his favorite film, but it is also his argument. The Monte Cristo story is a man destroyed and then rebuilt around revenge, and V wants Evey to see both the romance and the cost, even before he tells her his own plans.

Why does Evey feel sorry for Mercedes?

In the film, Edmond Dantes devotes himself to revenge and neglects Mercedes, the woman he loves. Evey notices that the hero's obsession costs him the person he is avenging himself for, and she says so out loud.

How does V know the news anchor is lying about Prothero?

He has studied her broadcasts. He points out that she blinks a lot when she reads a story she knows is false, so when she reports Prothero's death he treats it as a lie rather than news.

What does the news report claim about Prothero's death?

It says the Voice of London passed away late at night from apparent heart failure, and that his body was found at his office, where he often worked long hours alone.

V フォー・ヴェンデッタ · 全 25 章

すべて見る →
第 9 / 25 章 · 残り約 52 分