V for Vendetta · 2006 — 第 7 / 25 章 · 2'22" · B2

Breakfast and a Debate With V, Explained:put someone off

Evey apologizes for the night before, and V serves her breakfast with butter he stole from Sutler's supply train. The small talk turns into an argument about his plan, and the exchange lands on a line that defines him: "People should not be afraid of their governments."

あらすじ

Evey shares breakfast with V and apologizes for her reaction the night before. When she marvels at real butter, he admits he stole it from a government supply train headed for Sutler. The meal becomes a debate: she doubts blowing up Parliament can help, he argues that symbols gain power from people, and says governments should fear their people.

Small talkArgumentsApologizingPersuadingB2mediumbritishClean
IMDb ↗

注目の表現

put someone offwould you care forstarvingused to

00:00 / 02:22
Space 再生 · ← → セリフ移動 · R リピート
いま
  1. ❝ 独白V on symbols4 行練習ページ ↗
セリフをタップするとそこから再生

このシーンの表現

put someone off

make someone lose interest

Showing his burned hands at breakfast, V politely checks that the sight has not ruined Evey's appetite.

That smell really put me off my dinner.

このシーンの他の表現

  • would you care for

    a polite way to offer something

  • starving

    extremely hungry

  • used to

    did something regularly in the past

  • the telly

    British informal for television

  • blow up

    destroy with an explosion

このシーンのメモ一覧

45 行のセリフに 24 件のメモ

表現 · A2apologize for something

say sorry for something

I just wanted to apologize for my reaction last night.
表現 · A2want someone to know

wish someone to be aware

I understand what you did for me, and I want you to know I am grateful.
発音didn't put you

The t in didn't is barely released, and put you links into one sound.

I hope I didn't put you off your appetite.
表現 · A1a long time ago

many years back

There was a fire. A long time ago.
表現 · B1be ancient history

long past and forgotten

Ancient history, for some.
表現 · B2table conversation

talk suitable for a meal

Not really very good table conversation.
発音care for a

Link care, for and a so the offer rolls out as one phrase.

Now, would you care for a cup of tea with your egg?
表現 · A2since someone was a little kid

from one's childhood onward

God, I haven't had real butter since I was a little girl.
文法 · B1since I was a little girl

present perfect with since: The present perfect with since marks a state that has lasted from a past point until now.

God, I haven't had real butter since I was a little girl.
スラング · A2God

a mild exclamation — A casual exclamation; keep it out of formal speech.

God, I haven't had real butter since I was a little girl.
表現 · A2on its way to somewhere

travelling toward a place

A government supply train on its way to Chancellor Sutler.
スラング · B1insane

mad or crazy — Fine as a joke between friends, harsh if aimed at a stranger.

You're insane.
スラング · A2mum

British word for mom — British everyday speech; American English uses mom.

My mum, she used to read all his plays to me...
表現 · B1ever since

from then until now

...and ever since, I've always wanted to act.
表現 · B1mean it

be sincere

-Did you mean it? -Every word.
表現 · A2show up

arrive or appear

You can be pretty certain that if anyone does show up...
表現 · A2be afraid of someone

fear someone

People should not be afraid of their governments.
発音not be afraid

Run not, be and afraid together and weaken should.

People should not be afraid of their governments.
表現 · B2as is something else

and so is the other thing

The building is a symbol, as is the act of destroying it.
文法 · B2as is the act of destroying it

inversion with as: As is plus a noun replaces a repeated clause, meaning the second thing is also a symbol.

The building is a symbol, as is the act of destroying it.
表現 · B2be given power by someone

receive power from someone

Symbols are given power by people.
表現 · A2change the world

transform the whole world

...blowing up a building can change the world.
表現 · B1as ... as possible

possible; the pattern as ... as possible means as much as one can

I wish I believed that was possible.
文法 · B2I wish I believed

wish plus past tense: Wish with a past tense shows a desire that is contrary to present reality.

I wish I believed that was possible.

「Breakfast and a Debate With V」を読み解く

What's really going on

The scene is a quiet two-hander that slowly turns into the film's argument. It starts as manners — an apology, an offer of tea, a compliment about the food — and the first real information arrives almost as a joke: the butter came from 'a government supply train on its way to Chancellor Sutler.' Evey's reaction is disbelief, and V answers with Shakespeare rather than a defense. Then she asks about his broadcast, and the talk becomes political. He concedes there's no certainty — 'There's no certainty, only opportunity' — and gives the thesis plainly: 'People should not be afraid of their governments. Governments should be afraid of their people.' The scene's tension is that his logic is confident while her experience is the opposite: 'Every time I've seen this world change, it's always been for the worse.'

Theme

PowerThe two argue over whether destroying a symbol can move a country, and who is really supposed to fear whom.
PhilosophyTheir breakfast becomes a debate about certainty, symbols, and whether change for the better is even possible.

このチャプターで学べること

  • Fear should flow from power, not toward it.
  • A symbol only matters when enough people back it.
  • A polite offer can reset a tense conversation.
  • Small talk here hides grief and politics at once.

発音のポイント

  • didn't put you — The t in didn't is barely released, and put you links into one sound.
  • care for a — Link care, for and a so the offer rolls out as one phrase.
  • not be afraid — Run not, be and afraid together and weaken should.
There's no certainty, only opportunity.

His answer to her doubt: he can't promise a better country, only a chance, which is enough for him to act.

People should not be afraid of their governments.

The first half of his thesis: in a healthy society, fear runs the other way, and citizens are not the ones who should be scared.

Governments should be afraid of their people.

The second half, and the line the film is remembered for: power should answer to the public, not the reverse.

Symbols are given power by people.

His theory of change: a building or a mask means nothing on its own; it matters only when people invest it with meaning.

I wish I believed that was possible.

Evey's quiet reply: she isn't arguing with his logic so much as admitting she has lost the ability to hope for it.

Every time I've seen this world change, it's always been for the worse.

Her experience set against his theory: whatever change she has witnessed has made things worse, which is why his optimism sounds impossible to her.

このシーンについての質問

Where did the butter come from?

V stole it from a government supply train headed for Chancellor Sutler. That's why Evey is startled — the food on her plate is, in effect, stolen from the regime.

What are V and Evey arguing about?

Whether blowing up Parliament can make the country better. Evey doubts it and says change has always been for the worse; V argues a symbol gains power from people, so it can change the world.

What does 'black-bag' mean?

It means to seize someone secretly and without a trace — to disappear them. Evey warns that if anyone shows up, Creedy will black-bag every one of them.

Why does V quote Macbeth?

Evey calls him insane for robbing Sutler, and he answers with Macbeth — 'I dare do all that may become a man' — which tells her he knows the risk and accepts it.

What does Evey reveal about herself?

That her mother used to read Shakespeare to her, that she once played Viola in Twelfth Night, that she wanted to act — and that her mother is dead.

V フォー・ヴェンデッタ · 全 25 章

すべて見る →
第 7 / 25 章 · 残り約 58 分