The Rainmaker · 1997 — Chapter 20 of 23 · 4'13" · C1

Drummond Cross-Examines Jackie, Explained: preyed on me

The fight is over a document: a senior claims manual with an executive memorandum marked section 'U.' An objection says the memoranda are stolen work papers and may not be admitted. The cross-examination turns to the witness herself — her stay in a facility, her affair, her $10,000. 'And that $10,000, that was just a piece of blackmail, wasn't it?'

What happens

The scene is in court. A senior claims manual containing an executive memorandum, section 'U,' is offered in evidence. An objection follows: the memoranda are stolen work papers and may not be admitted. Someone asks whether that can be proven. Then Jackie Lemancyzk is cross-examined about her stay in a facility, her affair with Lufkin, and the $10,000 she took.

CourtroomAccusationsConfrontingConfessingRivalsC1mediumamericanClean
IMDb ↗

Listen for

executive memorandummay not be admittedvoluntarily checked into a facilitydenying my claim

00:00 / 04:13
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

preyed on me

exploited my vulnerability

She explains that she was broke, single, and raising two kids, so they targeted her when she was vulnerable.

They preyed on me when I was broke and desperate.

Also in this scene

  • executive memorandum

    a memo from senior management

  • may not be admitted

    cannot be accepted as evidence

  • voluntarily checked into a facility

    entered a treatment center by choice

  • denying my claim

    refusing to pay my insurance claim

  • sleeping with him

    having a sexual relationship with him

Everything marked in this scene

31 notes across 59 lines

Phrase · C1
executive memorandum

a memo from senior management

Someone shows the judge a claims manual containing a high-level memo marked Section U.

Your honor, this is Jackie Lemancyzk's actual senior claims manual, and within it, there is an executive memorandum entitled section "U."
Sound
within it

Let within and it flow together in one breath.

Your honor, this is Jackie Lemancyzk's actual senior claims manual, and within it, there is an executive memorandum entitled section "U."
Phrase · B2
approach the bench

come up to the judge

objection, your honor. Approach the bench?
Phrase · C1
may not be admitted

cannot be accepted as evidence

The opposing lawyer argues the stolen papers cannot be admitted, trying to block them before the judge reads them.

Your honor, this document contains executive memoranda that are stolen work papers and may not be admitted.
Phrase · B2
stolen work papers

stolen work documents

Your honor, this document contains executive memoranda that are stolen work papers and may not be admitted.
Grammar · B2
that are stolen work papers

relative clause: The that-clause defines the memoranda as stolen work papers.

Your honor, this document contains executive memoranda that are stolen work papers and may not be admitted.
Phrase · C2
proffer something at the correct time

submitted at the proper time

It was not proffered at the correct time, nor do we know how it was obtained...
Grammar · C1
nor do we know

inversion after nor: Nor plus inversion adds a second formal objection: we do not know how it was obtained.

It was not proffered at the correct time, nor do we know how it was obtained...
Phrase · B2
get something in

get something admitted Here it means have the evidence admitted.

Assuming that I can't get this in now, do you have any more questions for the witness?
Grammar · B2
Assuming that I can't get this in now

participial condition: Assuming that sets up a condition: if the evidence cannot be admitted now, are there more questions?

Assuming that I can't get this in now, do you have any more questions for the witness?
Phrase · B2
be committed to an institution

involuntarily placed in a facility Not a promise; placed in a facility against one’s will.

That you have recently been committed to an institution for various problems?
Phrase · B2
voluntarily check into a facility

entered a treatment center by choice

Asked whether she was committed, she corrects the record: she chose to enter treatment for alcoholism and depression.

I am suffering from alcoholism and depression, and I voluntarily checked into a facility.
Phrase · B2
be covered by a group policy

protected by a group insurance plan

I was supposed to be covered by my group policy at Great Benefit, and they, of course, are denying my claim.
Phrase · B2
deny a claim

refusing to pay my insurance claim

She says her group policy should have covered her, yet the company is refusing to pay her claim.

I was supposed to be covered by my group policy at Great Benefit, and they, of course, are denying my claim.
Sound
most of the

Keep of very light and glide through most of the.

I hate Great Benefit and most of the worms that work there.
Slang · B2
worms

despicable people — An insult for private complaints, not formal settings.

I hate Great Benefit and most of the worms that work there.
Phrase · B1
sleep with someone

having a sexual relationship with him

After she calls company people worms, the lawyer asks whether she felt that way while sleeping with Mr. Lufkin, using her private life to attack her credibility.

Did you feel Mr. Lufkin was a worm when you were sleeping with him?
Phrase · B2
see where this takes us

see what this leads to

Let's see where this takes us.
Grammar · B2
As long as I had sex with certain executives

conditional clause: As long as introduces the condition; the main clause uses passive forms to describe the rewards.

As long as I had sex with certain executives at Great Benefit, my pay was increased, and I was promoted.
Phrase · C1
disclose confidential information

reveal confidential claims data

Miss Lemancyzk, as an employee of Great Benefit, you promised not to disclose confidential private claims information.
Slang · B1
pocketbook

wallet or purse — Informal or dated; use wallet or purse in formal contexts.

You put it right in your pocketbook.
Phrase · B2
intend to keep a promise

never planned to honor the promise

Even though in your mind, you never intended to keep that promise.
Grammar · B2
Even though in your mind, you never intended

concessive clause: Even though concedes a point only to sharpen the accusation that she never meant to keep the promise.

Even though in your mind, you never intended to keep that promise.
Phrase · B2
prey on someone

exploited my vulnerability

She explains that she was broke, single, and raising two kids, so they targeted her when she was vulnerable.

You know, they preyed on me, because I was broke, and I was single, and I had 2 kids.
Slang · B1
broke

having no money — Casual for having no money; avoid in formal writing.

You know, they preyed on me, because I was broke, and I was single, and I had 2 kids.
Phrase · B2
go to the newspapers

take the story to the press Not visiting a newspaper office; exposing the story to the press.

So you told him you're gonna go to his wife, go to the newspapers.
Sound
wasn't it

The t in wasn't is often softened before it; keep the tag light.

And that $10,000, that was just a piece of blackmail, wasn't it?
Phrase · C1
extort money from someone

illegally force money from the company

A way to extort money from the company you hated!
Phrase · C2
Hell hath no fury like...

nothing is as furious as... A taunting prompt to the proverb about a scorned woman’s rage.

Hell hath no fury as what, Miss Lemancyzk?
Phrase · C2
strike something from the proceedings

removed from the case record

Your honor, I move that all documents provided the plaintiff by Miss Jackie Lemancyzk be deemed stolen work papers and struck from these proceedings.
Phrase · C1
the evidence before the court

the evidence the court currently has

Based on the evidence presently before the court, these documents are inadmissible.

Drummond Cross-Examines Jackie, explained

What's really going on

The document is the real target, but the witness is what can be hit. The objection about stolen work papers and timing is procedural; the questions that follow are about character — was she committed, did she sleep with Lufkin, did she take $10,000 and never mean to keep her promise. One line does the work of an argument: "You stole company work papers, confidential reports as blackmail for revenge." Nothing in it is about the claim that was denied; it is about why she is not to be believed. Her answer is just as blunt — "they preyed on me, because I was broke, and I was single, and I had 2 kids" — which turns the same facts into leverage rather than shame. When the documents are ruled inadmissible, the point has already been made.

Theme

JusticeA document that could prove a denied claim is thrown out because of how it was obtained, not what it says.
RevengeThe cross-examination reframes the witness's testimony as a woman scorned getting even with the company she hates.

Listen for

  • within it — Let within and it flow together in one breath.
  • most of the — Keep of very light and glide through most of the.
  • wasn't it — The t in wasn't is often softened before it; keep the tag light.
I hate Great Benefit and most of the worms that work there.

A blunt admission of hatred — the company's staff are "worms." It hands the other side the motive: she is angry, not impartial.

As long as I had sex with certain executives at Great Benefit, my pay was increased, and I was promoted.

She describes a trade: sex with executives brought raises and promotion. It answers the affair question and makes the company look like the one with a confession to make.

When I stopped, I was demoted.

The other half of the trade: the perks end when the sex does. Two short clauses, and the affair becomes evidence about how the company treats employees.

You stole company work papers, confidential reports as blackmail for revenge.

The accusation that turns the documents into theft and her testimony into revenge — the ground for striking them from the case.

Questions about this scene

Why are the documents ruled inadmissible?

Because the objection calls them stolen work papers, says they were not proffered at the correct time, and that no one knows how they were obtained. The ruling: "these documents are inadmissible."

Why does the cross-examination bring up her affair and the $10,000?

The questions build a picture of an angry witness. She has just said 'I hate Great Benefit,' and the payment is framed as 'a piece of blackmail' and 'a way to extort money from the company you hated.' The point is to make her look like someone with a motive to lie.

What does "Hell hath no fury" mean?

It is the first half of the old saying "Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned" — a woman who has been cast aside is the most dangerous thing to provoke. The next line completes it: "A woman scorned!"

Why do the stolen documents matter so much?

Because the whole motion is about them: the request is that every document Lemancyzk provided the plaintiff be deemed stolen work papers and struck from the proceedings. Once they are out, the manual and the executive memorandum go with them.

The Rainmaker · 23 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 20 of 23 · about 8 min to go