recall or consider
When I think of Donny Ray Black...The Rainmaker · 1997 — Chapter 23 of 23 · 2'44" · C1
The lawyer says he's disgusted with himself and his profession, then turns to exhibit 16. The closing turns on one warning to the jury: 'You could be their next victim.'
A lawyer gives the closing argument in a case against Great Benefit. He tells the jury he doesn't feel good enough about himself as a lawyer to make his own summation, and instead presents exhibit 16 — the patient explaining why he never got the transplant that could have saved him.
Listen for
gasping for his last breathdisgusted with myselfmake my own summationthe only thing that could save my life
Phrase of the scene
refuse to pay an insurance claim
In the testimony, the line says the insurer denied our claim — a refusal to pay, not a dispute over the facts.
Some insurers deny a claim without giving a reason.
struggling to breathe before death
ashamed and sick at oneself
give one's own closing argument
the sole possible lifesaver
the extreme extent someone goes to
28 notes across 28 lines
recall or consider
When I think of Donny Ray Black...ashamed and sick at oneself
At the start, the speaker says he is disgusted with himself, a heavy self-accusation before turning on the legal profession.
I am disgusted with myself...all lawyers as a group
And with the entire legal profession that could not save him.feel confident enough about oneself
I don't even feel good enough about myself as a lawyer to make my own summation.closing argument — Legal settings only; too technical for casual talk.
I don't even feel good enough about myself as a lawyer to make my own summation.with more than enough time
The leukemia was detected in plenty of time.bone marrow transplant
I was in the hospital being treated when the doctors realized that the only thing that could save my life would be a bone-marrow transplant.relative clause: The clause identifies the only thing that could save his life; without it, the sentence loses the medical hope.
I was in the hospital being treated when the doctors realized that the only thing that could save my life would be a bone-marrow transplant.lack money to pay
So, I got released from the hospital, 'cause my family couldn't afford to pay the bill for what they had recommended.refuse to pay an insurance claim
In the testimony, the line says the insurer denied our claim — a refusal to pay, not a dispute over the facts.
Great Benefit insurance denied our claim.a 90 percent survival chance
If I had had a bone-marrow transplant, I would have had a 90% chance of living.past counterfactual: The structure imagines a past that did not happen; it makes the missed transplant the cause of the lost chance.
If I had had a bone-marrow transplant, I would have had a 90% chance of living.The two hads can blur into one beat before a; keep the rhythm light.
If I had had a bone-marrow transplant, I would have had a 90% chance of living.extract money from someone
at the lengths to which a wealthy insurance company, like the defendant, will go to take money from a low-income family and then keep it by denying a legitimate claim.reject a valid claim
at the lengths to which a wealthy insurance company, like the defendant, will go to take money from a low-income family and then keep it by denying a legitimate claim.prepositional relative clause: The preposition is fronted before which, making the accusation sound formal and tightly connected to lengths.
at the lengths to which a wealthy insurance company, like the defendant, will go to take money from a low-income family and then keep it by denying a legitimate claim.from a can shrink into a quick blur; stress low-income family.
at the lengths to which a wealthy insurance company, like the defendant, will go to take money from a low-income family and then keep it by denying a legitimate claim.spend heavily on something
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.persuade us that we need
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.damages meant to punish
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.it is not surprising
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.stop something completely
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.object clause: The missing that after convince us introduces what the public is being persuaded to believe.
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.Let put an end to glide as one chunk; land stress on the key noun after it.
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.changes to tort law — Common in legal and political debate, not everyday chat.
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.deep in one's conscience
Do what you think is right in your hearts.the next person they harm
You could be their next victim.Keep could be their light; put the weight on next victim.
You could be their next victim.The lawyer's move is to step out of the way. Instead of making the case in his own voice, he says, 'I don't even feel good enough about myself as a lawyer to make my own summation,' and lets exhibit 16 do the talking. That gambit also does the argumentative work: the patient's own voice supplies the numbers — 110 pounds, a 90% chance of living — that no lawyer's paraphrase could. After the patient's numbers, the closing pivots from grief to warning: if the jury doesn't punish Great Benefit, 'You could be their next victim.' The scene is less about the law than about who gets to speak and what the jury is willing to hear.
I don't even feel good enough about myself as a lawyer to make my own summation.He doubts he deserves to sum up the case himself, so he hands that job to someone else's voice.
If I had had a bone-marrow transplant, I would have had a 90% chance of living.The line states what the denied claim cost him: a very good chance of survival.
It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.He says the insurer spends heavily on lawyers, lobbyists and PR to persuade the public to back tort reform and end punitive damages.
Do what you think is right in your hearts.He asks the jury to follow their conscience.
You could be their next victim.The warning aimed at the jury: the insurer that denied this claim could deny theirs too.
He says he doesn't feel good enough about himself as a lawyer to make his own summation, then introduces exhibit 16 and lets Donny Ray speak.
In the exhibit he explains it plainly: he was released because his family couldn't afford to pay the bill for what the doctors had recommended.
He warns them that if they don't punish Great Benefit, they could be the company's next victim. The line is: 'You could be their next victim.'
Exhibit 16 is what the lawyer presents after saying he'll let Donny Ray speak — the patient describing his weight loss, the bone-marrow transplant he needed and the denied claim.
Chapter 1cover your drawRudy Gets Hired by Bruiser
Chapter 2every man for himselfA Rookie Is Shown Bruiser's Office
Chapter 3deny a claimRudy Gets the Blacks to Sign
Chapter 4cut someone out of somethingRudy Visits Miss Birdie About Her Will
Chapter 5not charge a dimeDeck Pitches a Hospital Patient
Chapter 6day in courtRudy Meets Kelly Riker
Chapter 7passed the barRudy Passes the Bar
Chapter 8on a shoestringTwo Lawyers Plan to Go It Alone
Chapter 9on my behalfRudy Enters Court Without a License
Chapter 10throw money atAmbush in the Judge's Chambers
Chapter 11place an undue burden onNew Judge Grills Defense Lawyer
Chapter 12take depositionsRudy Tells Dot About the Depositions
Chapter 13jury tamperingRudy Learns His Phone Is Bugged
Chapter 14tamper withDrummond Claims Jury Tampering
Chapter 15deny a claimDot Black Takes the Stand
Chapter 16less than truthfulDrummond Cross-Examines Dot Black
Chapter 17a little late for an apologyLufkin Cross-Examined Over His Letter
Chapter 18paper pusherJackie Explains the Black File
Chapter 19playing the oddsJackie Testifies Against Great Benefit
Chapter 20preyed on meDrummond Cross-Examines Jackie
Chapter 21played no part inCiting Club Ruby to Admit Stolen Files
Chapter 22give or take a fewKeeley Grilled Over Denied Claims
Watching · Chapter 23deny a claimClosing Argument, Exhibit 16The expressions marked in the script, each on its own page with the lines where it is said.
“- Wow, you've given me a lot to think about, lawyer man. You're right, I need to be better. I'm going to be better.”
“For me, becoming a lawyer wasn't just ambition. It was identity, a proof that I was capable and I fought for it through the exhaustion, through the self-doubt, through the closed doors, through moments where I questioned whether I was enough, particularly if I was smart enough.”
“But my dear audience, I have learned from my life and me being a stammerer, who can't even speak my name properly. You can believe me, the world doesn't need me perfect lawyers, perfect doctors.”
“Like I I didn't even see myself as Jasmine. Like I'm an attorney. Like I am a lawyer. Like that's what I'm going to do. And you know, I I think, you know, looking back on it, I didn't take the time to like get to know myself.”