The Rainmaker · 1997 — Chapter 23 of 23 · 2'44" · C1

Closing Argument, Exhibit 16, Explained: deny a claim

The lawyer says he's disgusted with himself and his profession, then turns to exhibit 16. The closing turns on one warning to the jury: 'You could be their next victim.'

What happens

A lawyer gives the closing argument in a case against Great Benefit. He tells the jury he doesn't feel good enough about himself as a lawyer to make his own summation, and instead presents exhibit 16 — the patient explaining why he never got the transplant that could have saved him.

CourtroomSpeechesPersuadingWarningC1mediumamericanClean
IMDb ↗

Listen for

gasping for his last breathdisgusted with myselfmake my own summationthe only thing that could save my life

00:00 / 02:44
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
  1. ❝ MonologueThe Insurance Tirade9 linesPractice page ↗
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

deny a claim

refuse to pay an insurance claim

In the testimony, the line says the insurer denied our claim — a refusal to pay, not a dispute over the facts.

Some insurers deny a claim without giving a reason.

Also in this scene

  • gasping for his last breath

    struggling to breathe before death

  • disgusted with myself

    ashamed and sick at oneself

  • make my own summation

    give one's own closing argument

  • the only thing that could save my life

    the sole possible lifesaver

  • the lengths to which

    the extreme extent someone goes to

Everything marked in this scene

28 notes across 28 lines

Phrase · A2
think of someone/something

recall or consider

When I think of Donny Ray Black...
Phrase · B1
be disgusted with oneself

ashamed and sick at oneself

At the start, the speaker says he is disgusted with himself, a heavy self-accusation before turning on the legal profession.

I am disgusted with myself...
Phrase · B2
the entire [professional group]

all lawyers as a group

And with the entire legal profession that could not save him.
Phrase · B1
feel good enough about oneself

feel confident enough about oneself

I don't even feel good enough about myself as a lawyer to make my own summation.
Slang · C1
summation

closing argument — Legal settings only; too technical for casual talk.

I don't even feel good enough about myself as a lawyer to make my own summation.
Phrase · B1
in plenty of time

with more than enough time

The leukemia was detected in plenty of time.
Phrase · B2
bone-marrow transplant

bone marrow transplant

I was in the hospital being treated when the doctors realized that the only thing that could save my life would be a bone-marrow transplant.
Grammar · B2
that could save my life

relative clause: The clause identifies the only thing that could save his life; without it, the sentence loses the medical hope.

I was in the hospital being treated when the doctors realized that the only thing that could save my life would be a bone-marrow transplant.
Phrase · B1
can't afford to do something

lack money to pay

So, I got released from the hospital, 'cause my family couldn't afford to pay the bill for what they had recommended.
Phrase · B2
deny a claim

refuse to pay an insurance claim

In the testimony, the line says the insurer denied our claim — a refusal to pay, not a dispute over the facts.

Great Benefit insurance denied our claim.
Phrase · B2
a [number]% chance of doing something

a 90 percent survival chance

If I had had a bone-marrow transplant, I would have had a 90% chance of living.
Grammar · C1
If I had had a bone-marrow transplant, I would have had

past counterfactual: The structure imagines a past that did not happen; it makes the missed transplant the cause of the lost chance.

If I had had a bone-marrow transplant, I would have had a 90% chance of living.
Sound
had had a

The two hads can blur into one beat before a; keep the rhythm light.

If I had had a bone-marrow transplant, I would have had a 90% chance of living.
Phrase · B1
take money from someone

extract money from someone

at the lengths to which a wealthy insurance company, like the defendant, will go to take money from a low-income family and then keep it by denying a legitimate claim.
Phrase · C1
deny a legitimate claim

reject a valid claim

at the lengths to which a wealthy insurance company, like the defendant, will go to take money from a low-income family and then keep it by denying a legitimate claim.
Grammar · C1
to which a wealthy insurance company, like the defendant, will go

prepositional relative clause: The preposition is fronted before which, making the accusation sound formal and tightly connected to lengths.

at the lengths to which a wealthy insurance company, like the defendant, will go to take money from a low-income family and then keep it by denying a legitimate claim.
Sound
from a low-income

from a can shrink into a quick blur; stress low-income family.

at the lengths to which a wealthy insurance company, like the defendant, will go to take money from a low-income family and then keep it by denying a legitimate claim.
Phrase · B1
spend money on something

spend heavily on something

It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.
Phrase · B2
convince someone (that) they need

persuade us that we need

It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.
Phrase · C1
punitive damages

damages meant to punish

It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.
Phrase · B1
it's no wonder (that) ...

it is not surprising

It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.
Phrase · B2
put an end to something

stop something completely

It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.
Grammar · B2
to convince us we need

object clause: The missing that after convince us introduces what the public is being persuaded to believe.

It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.
Sound
put an end to

Let put an end to glide as one chunk; land stress on the key noun after it.

It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.
Slang · C1
tort reform

changes to tort law — Common in legal and political debate, not everyday chat.

It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.
Phrase · B1
in one's heart(s)

deep in one's conscience

Do what you think is right in your hearts.
Phrase · B1
someone's next victim

the next person they harm

You could be their next victim.
Sound
could be their

Keep could be their light; put the weight on next victim.

You could be their next victim.

Closing Argument, Exhibit 16, explained

What's really going on

The lawyer's move is to step out of the way. Instead of making the case in his own voice, he says, 'I don't even feel good enough about myself as a lawyer to make my own summation,' and lets exhibit 16 do the talking. That gambit also does the argumentative work: the patient's own voice supplies the numbers — 110 pounds, a 90% chance of living — that no lawyer's paraphrase could. After the patient's numbers, the closing pivots from grief to warning: if the jury doesn't punish Great Benefit, 'You could be their next victim.' The scene is less about the law than about who gets to speak and what the jury is willing to hear.

Theme

JusticeA lawyer asks the jury to punish an insurer that denied a family's claim.
Death & griefThe patient's own voice does the persuading, making the denied claim personal.

Listen for

  • had had a — The two hads can blur into one beat before a; keep the rhythm light.
  • from a low-income — from a can shrink into a quick blur; stress low-income family.
  • put an end to — Let put an end to glide as one chunk; land stress on the key noun after it.
  • could be their — Keep could be their light; put the weight on next victim.
I don't even feel good enough about myself as a lawyer to make my own summation.

He doubts he deserves to sum up the case himself, so he hands that job to someone else's voice.

If I had had a bone-marrow transplant, I would have had a 90% chance of living.

The line states what the denied claim cost him: a very good chance of survival.

It's no wonder they spend so much money on their lawyers and their lobbyists and their public relations machine to convince us we need tort reform, that we need to put an end to punitive damages.

He says the insurer spends heavily on lawyers, lobbyists and PR to persuade the public to back tort reform and end punitive damages.

Do what you think is right in your hearts.

He asks the jury to follow their conscience.

You could be their next victim.

The warning aimed at the jury: the insurer that denied this claim could deny theirs too.

Questions about this scene

Why does the lawyer present exhibit 16 instead of giving his own summation?

He says he doesn't feel good enough about himself as a lawyer to make his own summation, then introduces exhibit 16 and lets Donny Ray speak.

Why did the patient leave the hospital?

In the exhibit he explains it plainly: he was released because his family couldn't afford to pay the bill for what the doctors had recommended.

What does the lawyer warn the jury will happen if they don't punish Great Benefit?

He warns them that if they don't punish Great Benefit, they could be the company's next victim. The line is: 'You could be their next victim.'

What is exhibit 16?

Exhibit 16 is what the lawyer presents after saying he'll let Donny Ray speak — the patient describing his weight loss, the bone-marrow transplant he needed and the denied claim.

The Rainmaker · 23 chapters

All chapters →
That's all 23 chapters of this film