The Rainmaker · 1997 — Chapter 14 of 23 · 2'45" · B2

Drummond Claims Jury Tampering, Explained: tamper with

Court is still in session when a lawyer asks the panel, "Have any of y'all been contacted about this case?" — then declares the jury has been tampered with. The judge wants proof; the accuser says he can't explain. What looks like a procedural move is really a fight over who gets to shape the jury.

What happens

In a Tennessee courtroom, a lawyer questions the jury panel directly: has anyone been contacted about the case? He then tells the judge the panel has been tampered with, and when asked for proof says he cannot explain without divulging confidential information. The judge lets him keep questioning, and a juror, Billy Porter, is questioned about a phone call.

CourtroomAccusationsConfrontingExplainingRivalsB2mediumamerican
IMDb ↗

Listen for

tamper withdivulge confidential informationout of your mindwhat in the Sam hill

00:00 / 02:45
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

tamper with

interfere with something illegally

In court, someone claims the jury itself has been interfered with, making tamper with sound like a formal accusation, not a casual fix.

It's illegal to tamper with the safety records before an inspection.

Also in this scene

  • divulge confidential information

    reveal private or secret information

  • out of your mind

    completely unreasonable or crazy

  • what in the Sam hill

    what on earth is going on

  • son of a bitch

    bastard; strong insult

  • approach the bench

    come up to the judge's desk for a private talk

Everything marked in this scene

34 notes across 58 lines

Phrase · A2
about to do something

be just going to ask

Ladies and gentlemen, what I'm about to ask is the most important question of the day.
Phrase · A2
the most important question

the key question

Ladies and gentlemen, what I'm about to ask is the most important question of the day.
Grammar · B2
what I'm about to ask

subject clause: The whole what-clause is the subject of 'is'.

Ladies and gentlemen, what I'm about to ask is the most important question of the day.
Sound
about to ask

Blend 'about to' so it slides into 'ask' instead of three even beats.

Ladies and gentlemen, what I'm about to ask is the most important question of the day.
Phrase · B1
be contacted about something

be approached about something

Have any of y'all been contacted about this case?
Grammar · B2
Have any of y'all been contacted

present perfect passive: Asks whether they have been contacted; the passive keeps the focus on them.

Have any of y'all been contacted about this case?
Sound
any of y'all

Let 'any of y'all' run together; keep 'of' light and land on y'all.

Have any of y'all been contacted about this case?
Slang · A2
y'all

you all — Southern and casual plural 'you'; avoid in formal writing.

Have any of y'all been contacted about this case?
Phrase · B1
be serious business

a serious matter

This is serious business.
Slang · A2
Bingo

that's it; exactly — Said when something suddenly fits or is correct; too casual for formal meetings.

Bingo.
Phrase · B1
ask it another way

rephrase the question

Let me ask it another way.
Phrase · A2
have a conversation with someone

talk with someone

Did any of you have a conversation recently with either Mr. Rudy Baylor or directly behind him, Mr. Deck Schifflet.
Phrase · B2
have reason to believe (that) ...

have grounds to think

Your honor, we have reason to believe that this panel has been tampered with.
Phrase · B2
tamper with something

be interfered with illegally here it means the jury was improperly influenced

Your honor, we have reason to believe that this panel has been tampered with.
Grammar · B2
that this panel has been tampered with

object clause: The that-clause explains what they believe, with passive + perfect inside.

Your honor, we have reason to believe that this panel has been tampered with.
Sound
has been tampered

Keep 'has been' light, stress 'tampered,' and don't drop 'with.'

Your honor, we have reason to believe that this panel has been tampered with.
Phrase · B2
divulge confidential information

reveal private or secret information

Asked for proof, the speaker refuses to explain because doing so would mean revealing protected secrets.

I can't say without divulging confidential information, your honor.
Grammar · B2
without divulging confidential information

prepositional phrase: Without + -ing sets the condition: speaking would reveal secrets.

I can't say without divulging confidential information, your honor.
Phrase · B2
be out of one's mind

completely unreasonable or crazy

One side dismisses the accusation as absurd, turning a legal dispute into a personal attack.

You are just out of your mind.
Phrase · B1
allow someone to do something

let me complete what I am saying

Just allow me to finish questioning the panel.
Phrase · C1
come forth

emerge or be revealed

I think the truth will come forth.
Phrase · B2
what in the Sam hill ...

what on earth is going on

A bystander reacts to the courtroom chaos with a folksy, exasperated version of 'what on earth'.

What in the Sam hill is going on up there?
Phrase · B1
ask someone a direct question

a clear, blunt question

I want to ask you a direct question.
Phrase · B1
give someone an honest answer

a truthful reply

You ask an honest question, I'll give you an honest answer.
Phrase · A2
have a phone conversation with someone

a telephone talk

Did you, Mr. Porter, or did you not have a phone conversation a few days ago with Mr. Rudy Baylor?
Grammar · C1
Did you, Mr. Porter, or did you not have

parenthetical insertion: The address interrupts the question, making it slower and more pressuring.

Did you, Mr. Porter, or did you not have a phone conversation a few days ago with Mr. Rudy Baylor?
Slang · B1
Hell, no

absolutely not — A forceful, slightly vulgar no; not for polite or formal settings.

Hell, no.
Slang · B1
damn sure

completely certain — Strong certainty with mild swearing; avoid with clients or elders.

I'm damn sure.
Phrase · B2
provide an honest answer

give a truthful response

I say you did not provide an honest answer!
Sound
son of a bitch

Run 'son of a' together, keep 'of' tiny, and hit 'bitch' hard.

You son of a bitch.
Slang · B2
son of a bitch

bastard; strong insult — A severe insult for real anger or conflict; never use it formally.

You son of a bitch.
Phrase · B1
remove someone from a place

take someone out of a place

Bailiff, remove Mr. Porter from this courtroom.
Phrase · B2
be excused from something

be officially released from jury duty

Mr. Billy Porter, you are excused from the jury.
Grammar · B2
are excused from

passive voice: Passive removes the agent; the judge's authority is implied.

Mr. Billy Porter, you are excused from the jury.

Drummond Claims Jury Tampering, explained

What's really going on

On the surface this is a lawyer asking the jury a procedural question. Underneath, the accusation is the argument: whoever touched the panel decides the verdict. "Your honor, we have reason to believe that this panel has been tampered with" puts the charge on the record, and "I can't say without divulging confidential information" refuses to back it with anything the court can check, so the judge is left asking for proof: "I want proof." Then the tone stops being procedural. A juror is asked about a phone call, answers "Hell, no," and insists he gave an honest answer. From there the exchange turns personal — "I say you did not provide an honest answer!" and "Don't call me a liar." — and the judge clears it up by removing the juror: "Mr. Billy Porter, you are excused from the jury."

Theme

JusticeA courtroom overrides procedure: the charge is made on the record, the proof is withheld, and the judge decides who stays on the jury.
LiesThe whole fight is about who is telling the truth, and the only evidence offered is "an honest answer" promised and doubted.

Listen for

  • about to ask — Blend 'about to' so it slides into 'ask' instead of three even beats.
  • any of y'all — Let 'any of y'all' run together; keep 'of' light and land on y'all.
  • has been tampered — Keep 'has been' light, stress 'tampered,' and don't drop 'with.'
  • son of a bitch — Run 'son of a' together, keep 'of' tiny, and hit 'bitch' hard.
Have any of y'all been contacted about this case?

A direct question to the whole panel: has anyone contacted them about the case? The 'y'all' keeps it Southern and spoken, not lawyerly.

Your honor, we have reason to believe that this panel has been tampered with.

The formal accusation, made in open court: someone has interfered with the jury. The passive 'has been tampered with' leaves out who did it.

You ask an honest question, I'll give you an honest answer.

A condition rather than a promise: ask straight and I will answer straight. It comes as the reply to a request for an honest response.

Don't call me a liar.

The answer to being told he did not answer honestly. It turns a courtroom exchange into a personal one, and the room erupts soon after.

Mr. Billy Porter, you are excused from the jury.

The judge's ruling: this juror is off the panel. 'Excused' sounds polite, but it removes him from the case for good.

Questions about this scene

What is the lawyer claiming about the jury panel?

He asks the jurors whether anyone contacted them about the case, including whether they spoke with Mr. Rudy Baylor or Mr. Deck Schifflet, and then tells the judge the panel has been tampered with. When the judge demands proof, he says he cannot explain without divulging confidential information.

Who is Billy Porter in this scene?

He is a juror. He is asked directly whether he had a phone conversation a few days earlier with Mr. Rudy Baylor, answers 'Hell, no,' and is later told, 'Mr. Billy Porter, you are excused from the jury.'

Why is Billy Porter excused from the jury?

The scene does not give a stated reason. After the juror insists 'I gave you an honest answer,' someone says he did not answer honestly and someone snaps, 'Don't call me a liar.' Order is called for, the bailiff is told to remove Mr. Porter, and then he is told he is excused from the jury.

Does anything in the scene prove the jury was actually tampered with?

No. The claim is made—'this panel's been tampered with'—but when proof is demanded, the answer is that it cannot be given without divulging confidential information. The scene shows an accusation and a fight over an honest answer, not evidence of tampering.

Why does the judge let the questioning continue?

Proof is demanded, but the answer is that it cannot be given without divulging confidential information. The judge then asks for objections and gets 'No, no objection,' so the questioning goes on: 'Very well. Proceed.'

The Rainmaker · 23 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 14 of 23 · about 29 min to go