The Rainmaker · 1997 — Chapter 19 of 23 · 3'10" · B2

Jackie Testifies Against Great Benefit, Explained: playing the odds

Jackie is on the stand. There is a letter saying she quit for personal reasons — "The letter is a lie," she says. She was fired, given $10,000 in cash to keep quiet, and signed a promise never to discuss the Black file.

What happens

Jackie takes the stand in the Great Benefit trial. She says she was fired, not resigned; that a letter calling it a resignation is false; that the company paid her $10,000 to stay quiet about the Black file; and that Great Benefit's policy was to deny all claims for a year and bank the savings.

CourtroomAccusationsConfessingExplainingB2mediumamericanClean
IMDb ↗

Listen for

for the recordresignquit for personal reasonsplaying the odds

00:00 / 03:10
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

playing the odds

betting on likely outcomes

She says the company was not innocent; it was betting that people would not sue.

The airline is playing the odds that most passengers won’t claim compensation.

Also in this scene

  • for the record

    for official record

  • resign

    leave a job voluntarily

  • quit for personal reasons

    leave a job for personal reasons

  • pot of gold

    a large profit or prize

  • senior claims examiner

    senior insurance claims reviewer

Everything marked in this scene

28 notes across 49 lines

Phrase · B2
for the record

for official record

At the start of testimony, the witness is told to give her name for the official record.

State your name for the record.
Sound
was fired

Keep was light and land the beat on fired.

I was fired.
Phrase · B2
quit for personal reasons

leave a job for personal reasons

The lawyer uses a letter that says she quit for personal reasons to contradict her testimony.

I am baffled, Miss Lemancyzk, because I have this letter here, and it says you quit for personal reasons.
Sound
I am baffled

Let I am blur together; put the stress on baffled.

I am baffled, Miss Lemancyzk, because I have this letter here, and it says you quit for personal reasons.
Phrase · B2
no longer work there

was no longer employed there

I was fired so the company could claim that I no longer worked there.
Grammar · B2
so the company could claim that I no longer worked there

purpose clause: The so-clause explains the company's purpose, not the result: they wanted grounds to say she had left.

I was fired so the company could claim that I no longer worked there.
Phrase · B1
point out someone/something

identify someone in a group

Can you please point out the man in the courtroom who made you write this letter?
Phrase · B1
make someone do something

forced you to write this letter Not helping; forcing her to write it.

Can you please point out the man in the courtroom who made you write this letter?
Phrase · B2
leave with nothing

go away with no money

I could call it a firing and leave with nothing, or I could write that letter, call it a resignation, and the company would give me $10,000 in cash to keep quiet.
Phrase · B2
call it a [label]

label it a resignation A label trick: firing rewritten as quitting.

I could call it a firing and leave with nothing, or I could write that letter, call it a resignation, and the company would give me $10,000 in cash to keep quiet.
Phrase · B1
keep quiet

stay silent; keep a secret

I could call it a firing and leave with nothing, or I could write that letter, call it a resignation, and the company would give me $10,000 in cash to keep quiet.
Sound
call it a

Run call it a together, then contrast firing and resignation.

I could call it a firing and leave with nothing, or I could write that letter, call it a resignation, and the company would give me $10,000 in cash to keep quiet.
Phrase · B2
in someone's presence

with him there

And I had to make that decision right there in his presence.
Phrase · B2
claims files

insurance claim records

And I also signed a letter saying I would never discuss any of my claims files with anybody.
Grammar · B2
a letter saying I would never discuss any of my claims files

participial phrase: The -ing phrase describes the letter; what follows is the promise printed inside it.

And I also signed a letter saying I would never discuss any of my claims files with anybody.
Phrase · B2
should have been done

ought to have been paid out

So you knew that claim should have been paid?
Phrase · B2
play the odds

betting on likely outcomes

She says the company was not innocent; it was betting that people would not sue.

But the company was playing the odds.
Phrase · B1
consult a lawyer

ask a lawyer for advice

The odds that the insured would not consult a lawyer.
Grammar · B2
that the insured would not consult a lawyer

appositive clause: The that-clause spells out exactly what odds the company was betting on.

The odds that the insured would not consult a lawyer.
Phrase · C1
senior claims examiner

senior insurance claims reviewer

The lawyer confirms her job title, which gives her access to claims files and manuals.

You were a senior claims examiner?
Grammar · B2
an occasion when you were given instructions regarding how you should handle claims

relative clause: The when-clause defines the occasion; the passive hides who gave the instructions.

During that time, was there ever an occasion when you were given instructions regarding how you should handle claims?
Phrase · B2
deny all claims

reject every claim

Deny all claims for a year.
Phrase · C1
quick court settlements

fast court settlements

Add up the money saved, deduct the amount spent on quick court settlements, and there's a pot of gold left.
Phrase · B2
a pot of gold

a large profit or prize

She repeats the company's calculation: deny claims, subtract settlements, and keep the profit.

Add up the money saved, deduct the amount spent on quick court settlements, and there's a pot of gold left.
Phrase · C1
defense exhibit number X

defense evidence item 6

Here's what has heretofore been marked defense exhibit number 6.
Phrase · B2
flip over to section X

turn to a section

Would you do me a favor and just flip over to section "U," please?
Sound
Would you

Would you can blend; the request peaks at do me a favor.

Would you do me a favor and just flip over to section "U," please?
Phrase · C1
executive memorandum

senior-management memo

She says Section U was an executive memorandum rather than a routine manual chapter, pointing to senior management.

Section "U" was an executive memorandum in the senior examiners manual.

Jackie Testifies Against Great Benefit, explained

What's really going on

On paper the letter buries her: it says she quit for personal reasons, and she took the money. Her answer is that the paperwork was the crime. "I was fired so the company could claim that I no longer worked there." The $10,000 isn't severance, it's a purchase — of her silence about the Black file specifically, the claim everybody knew should have been paid. What she describes isn't one bad decision by one manager but a system: deny all claims for a year, add up the money saved, deduct what's spent on quick settlements, and what's left is "a pot of gold." She is the witness who can turn an insurance company's ordinary business into a pattern.

Theme

CorruptionA quit letter, a cash payoff and a memo called section "U" turn routine claims handling into a calculated scheme.
JusticeOne fired examiner on the stand hands a denied claim the paper trail it was missing.

Listen for

  • was fired — Keep was light and land the beat on fired.
  • I am baffled — Let I am blur together; put the stress on baffled.
  • call it a — Run call it a together, then contrast firing and resignation.
  • Would you — Would you can blend; the request peaks at do me a favor.
The letter is a lie.

The resignation letter in evidence is false: she was fired, and the letter was written so her exit would look voluntary.

I was fired so the company could claim that I no longer worked there.

She says the firing served a purpose: with her off the staff, the company could say she no longer worked there.

I could call it a firing and leave with nothing, or I could write that letter, call it a resignation, and the company would give me $10,000 in cash to keep quiet.

She says she was given two choices on the spot: be fired with nothing, or write a letter calling it a resignation and take $10,000 in cash for her silence.

But the company was playing the odds.

The company denied claims and bet that policyholders would not hire a lawyer, so the money stayed with the company.

Add up the money saved, deduct the amount spent on quick court settlements, and there's a pot of gold left.

Denying claims made money: add up what was saved by not paying, deduct what quick settlements cost, and a large profit is left over.

Questions about this scene

Was Jackie fired or did she resign?

She says she was fired, and that the employment ended on October 30th. The letter in evidence says she quit for personal reasons; she calls it a lie and says she was fired so the company could claim she no longer worked there.

Why did Great Benefit pay Jackie $10,000?

To keep her quiet. She says she had two choices: call it a firing and leave with nothing, or write the letter calling it a resignation and take $10,000 in cash — plus signing an agreement never to discuss her claims files.

What was section "U"?

She says it was an executive memorandum in the senior examiners manual. Asked to flip to it in the claims manual, she finds there is no section "U" — but she remembers it.

What does "playing the odds" mean here?

It describes the company's strategy: deny claims and bet that the insured won't consult a lawyer. The money saved, minus what's spent on quick settlements, is what's left as profit.

Who is Jack Underhall?

The man Jackie names when asked to point him out in the courtroom: he told her she was leaving immediately and gave her the choice between a firing and a resignation letter.

The Rainmaker · 23 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 19 of 23 · about 13 min to go