The Rainmaker · 1997 — Chapter 3 of 23 · 4'25" · B2

Rudy Gets the Blacks to Sign, Explained: deny a claim

Rudy is at the Blacks' house to collect three signatures on a contract; Mrs. Black has letters from the insurer to show him. The company has written, "We now deny it for the eighth and final time," and the family's answer is still to sign — because Donny Ray needs an operation.

What happens

Rudy Baylor, who is handling the family's case, comes to the Black house in Memphis to get them signed up for a lawsuit against Great Benefit. Donny Ray needs an operation; Buddy is out in the car; and the insurer's latest letter gets read aloud inside.

Parents & kidsNegotiationExplainingPersuadingLawyer & clientB2mediumamerican
IMDb ↗

Listen for

right in the headgo offdeny a claimfile a claim

00:00 / 04:25
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

deny a claim

refuse an insurance claim

The lawyer traces the delay back to the moment the insurer first denied a claim after Donny Ray was diagnosed.

Insurers can deny a claim for tiny paperwork errors.

Also in this scene

  • right in the head

    mentally normal

  • go off

    to sound suddenly

  • file a claim

    officially submit a claim

  • take care of the case

    handle the case

  • No wonder

    that explains it

Everything marked in this scene

35 notes across 86 lines

Phrase · B1
handle someone's case

be in charge of someone's case

Remember? I'm handling your case against Great Benefit.
Phrase · B2
a case against someone/something

a legal case against a party

Remember? I'm handling your case against Great Benefit.
Slang · A2
ain't

isn't / aren't — Common in Southern speech and casual talk; avoid in formal writing.

He ain't right in the head. War injury.
Grammar · B2
would go off

hypothetical would: Would marks the result that would happen in the imagined situation.

He can walk through one buck naked, and the thing would go off.
Slang · B1
buck naked

completely naked — Colorful casual phrase; avoid in formal description.

He can walk through one buck naked, and the thing would go off.
Phrase · B2
a plate in one's head

a metal plate in the head

He's got a plate in his head.
Phrase · B2
good days and bad days

up and down

Well, good days and bad.
Phrase · B2
deny a claim

refuse an insurance claim

The lawyer traces the delay back to the moment the insurer first denied a claim after Donny Ray was diagnosed.

Great Benefit first denied your claim last August when Donny Ray was diagnosed.
Grammar · B1
when Donny Ray was diagnosed

time clause: The when-clause tells the time, and was diagnosed is passive because Donny Ray received the diagnosis.

Great Benefit first denied your claim last August when Donny Ray was diagnosed.
Phrase · B1
consult a lawyer

talk to a lawyer

Why'd y'all wait till now to consult a lawyer?
Sound
Why'd y'all

Blend Why'd into y'all and stress wait and lawyer.

Why'd y'all wait till now to consult a lawyer?
Slang · A2
y'all

you all — Southern casual address; avoid in formal documents.

Why'd y'all wait till now to consult a lawyer?
Phrase · B1
write someone back

reply to someone in writing

I just kept writing 'em, and they kept writing me back, and this here is the latest one.
Phrase · B1
the latest one

the most recent one

I just kept writing 'em, and they kept writing me back, and this here is the latest one.
Slang · B2
bastards

bastards / jerks — Strong insult; not for polite or formal use.

She says you're suing those bastards over at Great Benefit.
Phrase · B2
make someone pay

force someone to pay or suffer Here pay means face the consequences, not just hand over money.

Gonna make 'em pay, huh?
Slang · A2
Gonna

going to — Casual contraction; not for formal writing.

Gonna make 'em pay, huh?
Slang · A2
'em

them — Casual written form of them; use with friends.

Gonna make 'em pay, huh?
Phrase · B2
file a claim

officially submit a claim

The lawyer turns the signing into the next required step before he can file a claim for the family.

Well, before we can file a claim, I need all 3 of you to sign this.
Phrase · B1
take care of something

handle the case

The lawyer uses take care of the case to make the contract sound simple: they hire him, and he handles everything.

It basically says that y'all hire us to be your attorneys, and we take care of the case for you.
Grammar · B2
says that y'all hire us

object clause: The that-clause is the object of says; it spells out what the contract says.

It basically says that y'all hire us to be your attorneys, and we take care of the case for you.
Phrase · B2
get a third of any recovery

take a third of the money recovered Recovery here means money won or paid out, not healing.

We handle any expenses that we might have, and then we get 1/3 of any recovery.
Phrase · B1
take X pages to say something

require two pages to explain

Well, why does it take 2 pages to say all that?
Phrase · B1
No wonder + clause

that explains it

Right after being told not to light up, someone throws out No wonder I'm dying as a dark, ironic joke.

No wonder I'm dying.
Phrase · B1
make someone do something

force someone to sign

Take the pen and go out there and make him sign the damn thing.
Sound
make him sign

Keep him very light; punch make and sign.

Take the pen and go out there and make him sign the damn thing.
Slang · B1
damn

damn / annoying — Mild profanity for irritation; avoid in formal settings.

Take the pen and go out there and make him sign the damn thing.
Phrase · B2
get the operation someone needs

receive the needed surgery

Now, Buddy, you gotta sign this paper so Donny Ray can get that operation he needs, and I don't want no trouble out of you.
Grammar · B2
don't want no trouble

double negative: In this dialect, don't want no trouble still means the speaker wants no trouble.

Now, Buddy, you gotta sign this paper so Donny Ray can get that operation he needs, and I don't want no trouble out of you.
Grammar · B1
operation he needs

relative clause: The relative clause he needs describes which operation Donny Ray should get.

Now, Buddy, you gotta sign this paper so Donny Ray can get that operation he needs, and I don't want no trouble out of you.
Sound
gotta sign this

Slide through gotta and link sign into this.

Now, Buddy, you gotta sign this paper so Donny Ray can get that operation he needs, and I don't want no trouble out of you.
Slang · A2
gotta

got to / have to — Casual; say have to in formal situations.

Now, Buddy, you gotta sign this paper so Donny Ray can get that operation he needs, and I don't want no trouble out of you.
Sound
got it

Run got it together; the t is a light flap, not two beats.

It's OK. I got it.
Phrase · A2
be all right

will be okay

You're gonna be all right.
Phrase · A2
rest a little bit

rest for a short while

Donny Ray, why don't you just rest a little bit?

Rudy Gets the Blacks to Sign, explained

What's really going on

The paperwork is almost beside the point. Mrs. Black wrote to Great Benefit and kept the replies, and the one she has now — "We now deny it for the eighth and final time" — tells her what the company thinks of her family. Someone still asks why the contract runs to two pages, and the answers offered are "the usual" and "standard language." The signatures depend on a man who won't leave the car; someone has to carry a pen out and "make him sign the damn thing." Getting three names onto one page is the whole fight, and the letter already shows what the fight is against.

Theme

JusticeA dying man's family signs on with a young lawyer because a form letter calls them stupid.
MoneyThe contract gives the lawyers a third of any recovery, and the insurer has already said no eight times.

Listen for

  • Why'd y'all — Blend Why'd into y'all and stress wait and lawyer.
  • make him sign — Keep him very light; punch make and sign.
  • gotta sign this — Slide through gotta and link sign into this.
  • got it — Run got it together; the t is a light flap, not two beats.
He ain't right in the head. War injury.

Said of Buddy: he isn't mentally sound, and the reason offered is a war wound. Blunt, no medical language.

He can walk through one buck naked, and the thing would go off.

A joke about the metal plate in Buddy's head: he would set off an airport metal detector even with no clothes on.

I just kept writing 'em, and they kept writing me back, and this here is the latest one.

She explains the whole delay: she wrote, the company replied, and this letter is the newest in the stack.

You must be stupid, stupid, stupid."

The line from the insurer's letter — the company insulting the person it is refusing to pay.

Well, why does it take 2 pages to say all that?

A plain question about a two-page contract: if the arrangement is so simple, why does it need so much paper?

Take the pen and go out there and make him sign the damn thing.

An order to carry the contract out to the car and get Buddy's signature, by nagging if necessary.

Questions about this scene

Why won't Buddy come inside to sign?

He stays in the car, and the family says he isn't right in the head — a war injury, with a plate in his head. Someone has to take the pen out to him and get the signature there.

What does the Great Benefit letter say?

That the company has denied the claim on seven prior occasions in writing and now denies it for the eighth and final time. It is signed by a vice president of claims, and the insult is part of the official letter.

Does Donny Ray sign the contract himself?

Yes. When someone tells him to rest, he says, "No, no. I want to do this now," and the reply is, "You're doing it." He signs it while his nose is bleeding instead of waiting.

What does the contract actually say?

That the family hires the lawyers, the lawyers handle the case and cover expenses up front, and they take one-third of any recovery. Someone calls the wording "the usual" and "standard language."

The Rainmaker · 23 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 3 of 23 · about 58 min to go