The Rainmaker · 1997 — Chapter 22 of 23 · 3'14" · B2

Keeley Grilled Over Denied Claims, Explained: give or take a few

On the surface it's a witness who doesn't have the figures at his fingertips. Underneath, the numbers are the point: 11,462 claims filed, 9,141 denied. One line goes, "You've had 2 months, Mr. Keeley." Then a document Keeley's own committee wrote is produced.

What happens

A courtroom. Keeley is questioned about Great Benefit's policies and the number of claims filed, and he can't supply the figures. Asked how many of some 11,000 claims were denied, he says that would take more time. So a report from the company's own medical committee is brought out and read aloud.

CourtroomInterrogationsConfrontingAskingRivalsB2slowamericanClean
IMDb ↗

Listen for

give or take a fewapproach the witnessverify itfinancially justified

00:00 / 03:14
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

give or take a few

approximately, more or less

The question uses a rough figure to pin the witness down without demanding exact recall.

The repairs will take three weeks, give or take a few days.

Also in this scene

  • approach the witness

    ask permission to approach the witness

  • verify it

    check it; confirm it

  • financially justified

    justified in money terms

  • standard procedure

    the normal accepted way

  • I want the jury to hear this

    I want the decision-makers to hear it

Everything marked in this scene

29 notes across 45 lines

Phrase · B2
approach the witness

ask permission to approach the witness

A lawyer asks the judge for permission to step closer to the witness stand.

Your honor, approach the witness?
Grammar · B1
how many policies did Great Benefit have

wh-question: The auxiliary did carries the question; have stays in base form.

Now, Mr. Keeley, how many policies did Great Benefit have
Phrase · B2
be in effect

in force, active

in effect in the year 1995?
Phrase · B1
give or take + 数量

approximately, more or less

The question uses a rough figure to pin the witness down without demanding exact recall.

Does the figure 98,000 sound correct, give or take a few?
Grammar · B1
Does the figure 98,000 sound correct

linking verb: Sound links the figure to the adjective correct: does it seem right?

Does the figure 98,000 sound correct, give or take a few?
Sound
Does the figure

Keep does light and land the beat on figure and the number.

Does the figure 98,000 sound correct, give or take a few?
Sound
give or take

Blur or and link give to take as one quick phrase.

Does the figure 98,000 sound correct, give or take a few?
Phrase · B2
claims were filed

claims were submitted

Now, of these policies, how many claims were filed?
Phrase · B1
sound correct to someone

seem right to you

Does the figure of 11,400 sound correct to you, give or take a few?
Phrase · B2
verify something

check it; confirm it

The witness admits the rough number but refuses to make it official without checking.

That's about right, but I'd have to verify it, of course.
Phrase · B2
some odd thousand

an approximate thousand-odd

Can you tell the jury of the 11 some odd thousand claims filed, how many were denied?
Phrase · B1
how many were denied

how many were refused

Can you tell the jury of the 11 some odd thousand claims filed, how many were denied?
Grammar · B2
how many were denied

embedded question: The embedded question keeps statement order after tell the jury.

Can you tell the jury of the 11 some odd thousand claims filed, how many were denied?
Sound
some odd thousand

Link some to odd and let the d brush into thousand.

Can you tell the jury of the 11 some odd thousand claims filed, how many were denied?
Phrase · B1
take more time

require more time

I don't think I could. That would take more time.
Sound
2 months

Stress two months and rush you've had for a sharper challenge.

You've had 2 months, Mr. Keeley.
Phrase · B2
medical committee

medical committee

This is a report from Great Benefit's medical committee.
Phrase · B1
request permission to do something

ask for permission

Request permission under previous precedent to present it to Mr. Keeley.
Phrase · C1
under previous precedent

according to an earlier ruling

Request permission under previous precedent to present it to Mr. Keeley.
Phrase · B2
objection noted

objection recorded

The judge acknowledges the objection for the record while rejecting it.

Overruled. Objection noted.
Slang · B2
Overruled

objection denied — Judge's ruling; not used outside court.

Overruled. Objection noted.
Grammar · B2
which you chaired

relative clause: The relative clause adds that Keeley himself chaired the committee.

Uh, Mr. Keeley, that is a report from Great Benefit's own medical committee, which you chaired.
Phrase · B2
become standard procedure

the normal accepted way

The report calls bone-marrow transplants standard procedure, undercutting the denial.

"Since bone-marrow transplants "have become standard procedure, "Great Benefit would be financially justified in investing in bone-marrow clinics."
Phrase · C1
invest in something

putting money into bone-marrow clinics

"Since bone-marrow transplants "have become standard procedure, "Great Benefit would be financially justified in investing in bone-marrow clinics."
Grammar · B2
have become standard procedure

present perfect: The present perfect marks a change that is now established as standard.

"Since bone-marrow transplants "have become standard procedure, "Great Benefit would be financially justified in investing in bone-marrow clinics."
Grammar · C1
would be financially justified in investing

would + adjective: Would softens the conclusion into a formal, report-style judgment.

"Since bone-marrow transplants "have become standard procedure, "Great Benefit would be financially justified in investing in bone-marrow clinics."
Slang · B1
Objection

formal objection — Courtroom jargon; not for ordinary arguments.

Objection, your honor. Repetitious.
Slang · C1
Repetitious

needlessly repeated — Legal objection term; everyday speech says repetitive.

Objection, your honor. Repetitious.
Phrase · C1
financially justified

justified in money terms

The phrase is repeated alone so the jury hears money logic where patient care should be.

Financially justified.

Keeley Grilled Over Denied Claims, explained

What's really going on

The point isn't that Keeley is forgetful. It's that the questions are built so each "I don't know" costs him: the figures exist, they're in a book he has, and the jury is watching him not know them. "I see. So the information that I want is right there in that book?" makes the trap explicit, and the answer "Yes" is all the questioner needs. Then comes the document — the company's own medical committee, which the witness chaired — describing bone-marrow transplants as standard procedure and investment in clinics as financially justified. He is made to read the committee's words aloud, twice, over an objection. What's really being argued is not medicine but money, in the company's own language.

Theme

CorruptionA company committee report calls bone-marrow transplants standard procedure, then treats investment in clinics as financially justified — the company's own paperwork about money.
MoneyThe whole cross-examination runs on figures: 98,000 policies, 11,462 claims, 9,141 denials. Treatment becomes an accounting question.

Listen for

  • Does the figure — Keep does light and land the beat on figure and the number.
  • give or take — Blur or and link give to take as one quick phrase.
  • some odd thousand — Link some to odd and let the d brush into thousand.
  • 2 months — Stress two months and rush you've had for a sharper challenge.
You've had 2 months, Mr. Keeley.

It shuts down the excuse that checking the figures takes time: the witness has already had two months to prepare.

I have yet another document.

A courtroom move — new paperwork is introduced right after the witness fails to answer, moving the exchange to something written down.

That's about right, but I'd have to verify it, of course.

A careful half-agreement: the figure sounds close, but the witness won't confirm it on the record without checking first.

I want the jury to hear this.

The examiner asks for the passage to be read louder so the jury takes it in, not for his own benefit.

"Since bone-marrow transplants "have become standard procedure, "Great Benefit would be financially justified in investing in bone-marrow clinics."

A sentence from the company's own committee report: if transplants are routine, paying for clinics makes financial sense — the company's own logic about money.

Questions about this scene

What does Keeley say when asked how many claims were denied?

He says he doesn't think he could and that it would take more time. The next line points out that he has had two months and tells him to answer; the figures 11,462 filed and 9,141 denied are then read out.

How does the medical committee report hurt the company?

Keeley chaired that committee. The passage he reads says bone-marrow transplants "have become standard procedure" and that Great Benefit "would be financially justified in investing in bone-marrow clinics" — the company's own words about money and treatment.

What does "approach the witness" mean in court?

It's a request to walk up to the witness stand: "Your honor, approach the witness?" is answered with "You may." The same request comes up a second time, right before the passage is read aloud again.

Does the judge side with the objection?

No. The first objection is met with Overruled and Objection noted — recorded, but not accepted. Later, when the objection calls the reading repetitious, the ruling is only Overruled.

The Rainmaker · 23 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 22 of 23 · about 3 min to go