Deconstructing Harry · 1997 — 第 12 / 17 章 · 5'03" · B2

Max's Dark Secret at the Dinner Table, Explained:let sleeping dogs lie

A family dinner explodes over a story: someone retells Max's dark secret — a man who killed his wife, his mistress and her children — and the table turns on Harry when they realize it is his portrait of their father. "Maybe the best course of action is let sleeping dogs lie," one voice suggests, much too late.

あらすじ

At a family dinner, a relative recounts the monstrous "dark secret" of Max Pincus: an affair, mounting debts, a murdered wife, and bodies disposed of by eating them. Harry then admits the story is his own early writing about their father. The table turns on him, and the evening ends in insults and a confrontation about a therapist's patient.

Family dinnersArgumentsConfrontingConfessingSiblingsB2mediumamerican
IMDb ↗

注目の表現

hang a pictureI should be so luckylet sleeping dogs liein order to

00:00 / 05:03
Space 再生 · ← → セリフ移動 · R リピート
いま
  1. ❝ 独白Elsie's horror story33 行練習ページ ↗
セリフをタップするとそこから再生

このシーンの表現

let sleeping dogs lie

leave old trouble alone

After the murder story, the advice offered is to leave old matters alone.

I decided to let sleeping dogs lie.

このシーンの他の表現

  • hang a picture

    put a picture on the wall

  • I should be so lucky

    sarcastic wishful phrase

  • in order to

    for the purpose of

  • a direct line to God

    claiming a hotline to the truth

  • the opposite of

    the reverse of

このシーンのメモ一覧

107 行のセリフに 31 件のメモ

表現 · B2from a prior marriage

an earlier marriage

No. The woman's children, From a prior marriage.
表現 · B2begin an affair

start an affair

He began an affair with the downstairs neighbor...
表現 · B2get into debt

fall into debt

Meanwhile, he got into debt deeper and deeper and... and carry on with the neighbor.
表現 · C1get out of a predicament

escape a difficult situation

So he can't get himself out of a predicament.
表現 · B2be nothing with something

be useless with something

He's nothing with tools.
発音can't even

Can't even runs together as can-even.

He can't even hang a picture.
表現 · C1the capper

the final blow

And this is not the capper.
表現 · B2hear someone's side

listen to someone's account

Whatever you do, first, hear Max's side.
表現 · B2the best course of action

the best way to proceed

Maybe the best course of action is let sleeping dogs lie.
表現 · C1let sleeping dogs lie

leave old trouble alone

After the murder story, the advice offered is to leave old matters alone.

Maybe the best course of action is let sleeping dogs lie.
文法 · B2is let sleeping dogs lie

bare infinitive after is: After is, the bare infinitive let appears without to, which is common in speech.

Maybe the best course of action is let sleeping dogs lie.
表現 · B2get steamed up about something

get worked up

What are you getting so steamed up about?
表現 · B2an authority on something

an expert on

What makes you such an authority on the weather?
表現 · A2watch out for something

be careful about

With my arteries, you gotta watch out for the cholesterol.
スラング · A2gotta

have got a — Spoken shorthand; not for writing.

I gotta headache. Please.
表現 · B2promise not to do something

give your word not to

If I tell you why I did it, do you promise not to nudge me?
表現 · B2in order to do something

for the purpose of

Someone repeats Fishbein's claim that Max ate the bodies to hide them.

Wolf fishbein said in order to hide the bodies you ate them!
発音hide the bodies

Hide the links up, with the d often dropped.

Wolf fishbein said in order to hide the bodies you ate them!
表現 · B2make a fuss

make a scene

So what are you making a fuss?
表現 · B2bet everything on something

stake it all on

He's betting everything on physics and pussy!
発音physics and

Physics and links across, the s sliding into and.

He's betting everything on physics and pussy!
スラング · B2pussy

a crude word for women or sex — Very crude sexual slang; never in polite company.

He's betting everything on physics and pussy!
文法 · C1Not only do I know

inversion after not only: When not only opens a clause, the subject and auxiliary invert.

Not only do I know that we lost 6 million,
表現 · B2a version of something

a variant of

Max is a version of daddy... a man you hated, a man you think committed the crime of being a terrible parent.
表現 · C1have a direct line to God

claiming a hotline to the truth

Harry asks whether the world would be better if no group claimed a direct line to God.

Hey, look, wouldn't it be a better world if not every group thought they had a direct line to God?
文法 · C1wouldn't it be a better world if

unreal conditional question: The unreal conditional question imagines a world that does not exist.

Hey, look, wouldn't it be a better world if not every group thought they had a direct line to God?
発音direct line

The t in direct drops before line.

Hey, look, wouldn't it be a better world if not every group thought they had a direct line to God?
スラング · B2son of a bitch

a heavy insult — A heavy insult; do not use it lightly.

You son of a bitch!
スラング · B2bastard

a strong insult — An insult; keep it out of formal speech.

You sick, sick, sick, sick fucking bastard!
表現 · B2have an affair with someone

be sexually involved with someone

So you've had an affair with one of my patients.
文法 · B2you've had an affair

present perfect: The present perfect presents the affair as an established fact affecting the present.

So you've had an affair with one of my patients.

「Max's Dark Secret at the Dinner Table」を読み解く

What's really going on

The dinner is a trap of Harry's own making. He defends it as old work: "I wrote it when I was much younger." But the family hears the accusation underneath, because Max is "a version of daddy... a man you hated, a man you think committed the crime of being a terrible parent." The wildness of the story — a man who butchers his family and devours them — makes it impossible to dismiss as a joke, and the table splits between those who want peace and those who want a reckoning. "Maybe the best course of action is let sleeping dogs lie," is the plea for calm, but Harry has already woken the dogs. The evening is about how a writer's material is never really his own when the people in it are still alive.

Theme

Family conflictA dinner turns into an open fight once the family sees itself in Harry's story about their father.
Dark humorMurder and cannibalism are delivered as a punchline, and the horror is exactly what makes the accusation land.

このチャプターで学べること

  • A murder story becomes dinner conversation here.
  • The advice to let it rest is absurdly calm.
  • Harry keeps arguing while the family dodges.
  • The scene ends by turning the spotlight on Harry.

発音のポイント

  • can't even — Can't even runs together as can-even.
  • hide the bodies — Hide the links up, with the d often dropped.
  • physics and — Physics and links across, the s sliding into and.
  • direct line — The t in direct drops before line.
He's betting everything on physics and pussy!

A jab at a young man in the family who puts all his hopes on science and women; the blunt rhyme is meant to get a laugh at the table.

Maybe the best course of action is let sleeping dogs lie.

The polite suggestion to drop the whole subject: keep quiet about the past instead of dragging the family's wounds back into the open.

I think you go around with the insane delusion that people like you.

The closing insult to Harry: it is not that everyone is out to get him, it is that he wrongly assumes the world is fond of him.

So you've had an affair with one of my patients.

The confrontation that ends the evening: someone accuses Harry of sleeping with a patient, turning a private dinner into an open scandal.

このシーンについての質問

Who is Max Pincus supposed to be?

Max is the character in an early story Harry wrote. The family recognizes him as a version of their father, which is exactly what makes the story so offensive to them.

Why does the family react so badly to the story?

They hear their own father in a killer who butchers his wife, his mistress and her children. To them it is a sick, even anti-Semitic portrait, not harmless fiction.

What does 'let sleeping dogs lie' mean?

It means to leave an old problem alone instead of stirring it up again. Here it is the plea to stop digging into the family's past, which Harry has already done.

How does the dinner end?

It ends in a shouting match. Someone calls Harry a sick bastard, and the evening closes with an accusation that he had an affair with one of his therapist's patients.

地球は女で回ってる · 全 17 章

すべて見る →
第 12 / 17 章 · 残り約 23 分