A Star Is Born · 2018 — 第 3 / 13 章 · 3'34" · B2

Jackson Tells Ally She's Talented, Explained:talent comes everywhere

Ally can't get past her looks, but Jackson won't let her hide behind them. "Talent comes everywhere," he tells her, insisting the real test is having something to say and a way to make people listen. She accuses him of lying; he keeps going anyway.

あらすじ

In a cop bar after her drag-club set, Ally tells Jackson her nose has held her back and that she once almost had a hit song. Jackson recalls being born unable to hear in one ear and still becoming a singer. Fans interrupt for a photo; a scuffle breaks out and Ally gets hit in the face, so Jackson takes her out to treat it.

Comforting a friendMonologuesPersuadingComfortingStrangersB2fastamerican
IMDb ↗

注目の表現

bullshita whole other bagget throughthe thing about

00:00 / 03:34
Space 再生 · ← → セリフ移動 · R リピート
いま
  1. ❝ 独白Jack on talent6 行練習ページ ↗
セリフをタップするとそこから再生

このシーンの表現

bullshit

nonsense, crap

Ally blames her nose, and Jack fires back that the whole idea is bullshit.

That report is complete bullshit.

このシーンの他の表現

  • a whole other bag

    a completely different matter

  • get through

    make someone understand

  • the thing about

    the key fact about

  • get ahead of

    act before something worsens

  • take a picture of

    photograph someone

このシーンのメモ一覧

80 行のセリフに 23 件のメモ

表現 · A2feel comfortable

feel at ease

I just don't feel comfortable.
表現 · B1full of shit

talking nonsense

I'm not full of shit. - You're full of shit.
表現 · B2if it wasn't for something

were it not for

I could've had maybe a hit song if it wasn't for my nose.
スラング · B2fucking

crude intensifier — A strong swear used for emphasis; never in formal settings.

That's fucking bullshit.
文法 · B1born with this thing in my ear

past participle phrase: Born with marks a condition she had from birth, attached to the subject.

I was born with this thing in my ear, couldn't hear.
表現 · B2wind up doing something

end up

What do I wind up being? A singer, so you never know.
表現 · B2a whole other bag

a completely different matter

Jack draws a line between having something to say and making people listen.

and the way to say it so people listen to it, that's a whole other bag.
表現 · B1get out there

go out and try

And unless you get out there and you try to do it, you'll never know.
文法 · B2If there's one reason we're supposed to be here

if-clause: The if-clause sets a condition and the main clause delivers the point like a creed.

If there's one reason we're supposed to be here, it's to say something so people wanna hear it.
発音Don't you

Listen for don't you compacting into don-chu.

Don't you understand what I'm trying to tell you?
表現 · B2get through to someone

making them understand

I think I'm getting through a little bit. I can see it.
表現 · A2a good thing

a lucky thing

It's a good thing we met.
表現 · A2get famous

become famous

That's the thing about when you get famous, people start saying your full name.
文法 · B1when you get famous

time clause: The when-clause marks the moment fame starts, followed by what people do.

That's the thing about when you get famous, people start saying your full name.
発音get famous

Listen for the t in get dropping before famous.

That's the thing about when you get famous, people start saying your full name.
表現 · B1speaking of something

talking of

Oh, speaking of...
スラング · B2fucked

ruined, screwed up — Crude slang for ruining something; friends only.

I fucked that fucking song up so bad.
表現 · B1be supposed to do something

meant to

Hey, I know that we're not supposed to do this.
表現 · A2take a picture of someone

photograph someone

A drunk fan wants to take a picture of Jack to send to his ex.

But I gotta take a picture of you because I gotta send it to her because I'm gonna show her that you look nothing fucking like that fucking guy.
スラング · C1whore

a slur for a woman — A deeply offensive slur; do not use it at all.

- Get the fuck off, you little whore. - What? What?
発音Why did I

Listen for did I linking into a single sound.

- No, no, it's all right. - Why did I...
表現 · B2get ahead of something

act before something worsens

After Ally is hit, Jack tells her to get ahead of the swelling instead of crying.

No, you gotta get ahead of the swelling.
表現 · A2wrap something up

wrap it up

Gotta wrap something up with it. Find it.

「Jackson Tells Ally She's Talented」を読み解く

What's really going on

The scene is really about permission. Ally has already decided she isn't allowed to be a star — she blames her nose for a career that stalled, and Jackson, drunk and famous, is the one person who tells her the obstacle is imaginary. "If there's one reason we're supposed to be here, it's to say something so people wanna hear it," he says, which is less flattery than a confession about his own life: he can barely hear, he messed up his own song, and he still believes the point of the whole thing is to be heard. She answers "It's a good thing we met," half joking, half not. When the bar turns on her and she takes a punch, the talk stops being abstract; he becomes the person who picks her up.

Theme

DreamsJackson argues that talent is cheap and the real dream is being heard; Ally has talked herself out of hers.
IdentityAlly blames her nose for who she can't be; Jackson, born half-deaf, shows her the flaw isn't the story.

このチャプターで学べること

  • Jack answers self-doubt with a blunt, generous claim.
  • A whole other bag separates two very different skills.
  • Get ahead of means acting before things worsen.
  • The monologue turns talent into a reason to be heard.

発音のポイント

  • Don't you — Listen for don't you compacting into don-chu.
  • get famous — Listen for the t in get dropping before famous.
  • Why did I — Listen for did I linking into a single sound.
Look, talent comes everywhere. Everybody's talented.

Jackson's point: talent itself is common, so Ally can stop treating her looks as the reason she failed.

If there's one reason we're supposed to be here, it's to say something so people wanna hear it.

For him the whole point of making art is being heard — the hard part is the saying, not the talent.

It's a good thing we met.

Ally's line lands between a joke and a confession; the night has already changed something for both of them.

My nose has not made me lucky.

She says her looks never helped her — the opposite of what Jackson keeps insisting.

このシーンについての質問

Is Jackson right that Ally's nose has nothing to do with her career?

He can't know that for certain, but his own life is the argument: born unable to hear in one ear, he still became a star. Ally's version is that labels rejected her voice because of her looks.

Why does Ally bring up her nose instead of just accepting the compliment?

Because she has heard the same verdict in real meetings — 'you sound great, but you don't look so great.' Agreeing with Jackson would mean admitting she gave up for no reason.

What happens right after the photo request?

A man in the bar insults Ally, a fight starts, and she gets hit in the face. Jackson walks her out and has her ice the swelling before it gets worse.

Who is 'Jack' and why does he correct people about his name?

It's Jackson. He jokes that once you get famous, people stop using your first name and start saying your full name, so he asks her to just call him Jack.

アリー/ スター誕生 · 全 13 章

すべて見る →
第 3 / 13 章 · 残り約 34 分