Chicago · 2002 — Chapter 2 of 11 · 2'13" · C1

Roxie's Self-Defense Story Collapses, Explained: pull the wool over someone's eyes

The questioning over Fred Casely's death looks routine until the story everyone was told starts to crack. The line "Your story doesn't wash, Mrs. Hart" turns the room: what looked like self-defense becomes a lie about a married lover and a meal ticket.

What happens

Fred Casely's name is read out first, followed by a detail: he sold the Harts their furniture at ten percent off. Someone describes a body covered with a sheet, and a wife asking her husband to say he did it. The self-defense claim — "it was self-defense, he was trying to burgle me" — is answered with Fred's wife and five children.

Police questioningAccusationsConfrontingConfessingSpousesC1mediumamerican
IMDb ↗

Listen for

cock-and-bull storyget offtwo-time someonepull the wool over someone's eyes

00:00 / 02:13
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
  1. ❝ MonologueAmos Turns on Roxie9 linesPractice page ↗
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

pull the wool over someone's eyes

deceive me

After admitting he believed his wife, Amos uses this line to reclaim some pride: she thought she could keep fooling him.

Don't try to pull the wool over my eyes—I saw the receipt.

Also in this scene

  • cock-and-bull story

    nonsense excuse

  • get off

    escape punishment

  • two-time someone

    cheat on someone

  • doesn't wash

    story is not believable

  • once was enough

    ironic: one time was plenty

Everything marked in this scene

39 notes across 46 lines

Phrase · B2
name of the deceased

the dead person's name

* He loves me so * * That funny honey of mine * Name of deceased , Fred Casely.
Phrase · B1
sell someone something

sold us furniture

My wife knows him . He sold us our furniture.
Phrase · B2
a cock-and-bull story

nonsense excuse

Amos recalls how his wife spun a story to make him take the fall, and his tone shifts from explaining to accusing.

She had him covered in a sheet, and she's telling me some cock-and-bull story and how I ought to say I did it 'cause I was sure to get off.
Phrase · B2
get off (with something)

escape punishment

Amos explains why his wife told him to confess: she promised he would get off. In this legal sense it means escape punishment.

She had him covered in a sheet, and she's telling me some cock-and-bull story and how I ought to say I did it 'cause I was sure to get off.
Grammar · B2
had him covered in a sheet

causative have: It means she caused him to be covered; the past participle follows the object.

She had him covered in a sheet, and she's telling me some cock-and-bull story and how I ought to say I did it 'cause I was sure to get off.
Grammar · C1
how I ought to say I did it

embedded wh-clause: The how-clause is the object of telling, and inside it sits the reported instruction I ought to say I did it.

She had him covered in a sheet, and she's telling me some cock-and-bull story and how I ought to say I did it 'cause I was sure to get off.
Sound
get off

In fast speech, get off can blur together; let t slide into off.

She had him covered in a sheet, and she's telling me some cock-and-bull story and how I ought to say I did it 'cause I was sure to get off.
Phrase · B2
in one's hour of need

a time of desperate need

''''Help me, Amos,'' she says. ''It's my goddamn hour of need .'' * Now he shot off his trap * * I
Phrase · C1
shoot off one's trap

blabbed; talked too much

''''Help me, Amos,'' she says. ''It's my goddamn hour of need .'' * Now he shot off his trap * * I
Slang · B2
goddamn

damn — Strong curse for emphasis; not for formal situations.

''''Help me, Amos,'' she says. ''It's my goddamn hour of need .'' * Now he shot off his trap * * I
Phrase · B2
rat on someone

snitching on me Not about rats; it means snitching on me.

- * Rattin' on me * -That cheap little tramp.
Slang · C1
tramp

slut; loose woman — A harsh insult for a woman; not for real-life use.

- * Rattin' on me * -That cheap little tramp.
Phrase · B2
two-time someone

cheat on someone

After hearing about his wife and the dead man, Amos moves from being framed to being cheated on. The line is half question, half bitter realization.

She was two-timing me, huh?
Sound
two-timing me

Stress two, glide through timing, and keep me light.

She was two-timing me, huh?
Phrase · B2
be through doing something

done protecting her

I'm through protecting her now.
Phrase · B2
someone can [do something] for all I care

I don't care at all

She can swing for all I care.
Phrase · B1
munch on something

eating candy

I'm down at the garage working 1 4 hours a day, and she's up here munching on bonbons and tramping around Like some goddamn floozy!
Slang · C1
floozy

loose woman — Old-fashioned insult; never use it in formal settings.

I'm down at the garage working 1 4 hours a day, and she's up here munching on bonbons and tramping around Like some goddamn floozy!
Phrase · B2
pull the wool over someone's eyes

deceive me

After admitting he believed his wife, Amos uses this line to reclaim some pride: she thought she could keep fooling him.

Thought she could pull the wool over my eyes.
Phrase · B2
not be born yesterday

not naive

- * That scummy, crummy * -Well , I wasn't born yesterday.
Sound
wasn't born

The t in wasn't often softens; put weight on born.

- * That scummy, crummy * -Well , I wasn't born yesterday.
Phrase · B2
push someone too far

went too far with me

- * Hubby of mine * -She pushed me too far.
Slang · C1
chiseler

cheat; swindler — Old slang for someone who cheats people out of money.

That little chiseler.
Slang · B2
sap

fool — Casual self-mockery or mild insult; avoid in formal settings.

Boy, what a sap I was!
Slang · B2
double-crosser

betrayer — Use when accusing someone of betrayal, usually in anger.

You double-crosser! You big blabbermouth !
Slang · B2
blabbermouth

big mouth — For someone who cannot keep a secret; angry or teasing.

You double-crosser! You big blabbermouth !
Slang · B2
stringin' me

stringing me along — Casual, angry complaint when you realize you were played.

You been stringin' me, Roxanne!
Slang · C1
jazzin' him

fooling around with him — Old slang with sexual overtones; use with caution.

The whole time, you been up here jazzin' him .
Phrase · B1
from what I hear / from what I've heard

from what I've been told

From what I hear, he's been burgling you three times a week for the Last month .
Grammar · B2
he's been burgling you

present perfect continuous: The present perfect continuous stresses repeated action continuing up to now.

From what I hear, he's been burgling you three times a week for the Last month .
Phrase · B2
something doesn't wash

the story is not believable

Your story doesn't wash , Mrs. Hart. . .
Sound
doesn't wash

Let the t in doesn't soften; hit wash like a verdict.

Your story doesn't wash , Mrs. Hart. . .
Phrase · C1
try something on for size

consider this version Literally trying clothes; here it means consider this version.

so try this on for size.
Phrase · B2
something on the side

an affair or side activity Here it means an affair, not a side job.

Fred was a good time on the side with Goofy here as a meal ticket.
Grammar · C1
with Goofy here as a meal ticket

with-complex: The with-phrase adds a circumstance: Amos is being cast as the meal ticket.

Fred was a good time on the side with Goofy here as a meal ticket.
Phrase · B1
forget to mention something

fail to mention

Or did he forget to mention them?
Slang · B2
bastard

bastard; jerk — A strong insult; avoid in formal or unfamiliar company.

Oh , that bastard .
Sound
kill him again

In fast speech him is light; stress kill and land again.

Yeah , I killed him . I would kill him again .
Phrase · B1
take someone downtown

take her to the police station Downtown points to the police station here, not just the city center.

Take her downtown . Come on !

Roxie's Self-Defense Story Collapses, explained

What's really going on

The scene plays like theatre: one story is performed, then dismantled line by line. The self-defense claim — "But it was self-defense. He was trying to burgle me" — is answered by a joke: "From what I hear, he's been burgling you three times a week for the last month." A burglar who comes back three times a week is not a burglar, and everyone in the room knows it. The next move is colder. A wife and five children are produced not as grief but as a motive, and the composure breaks into "Oh, that bastard" — twice. What the scene sells is the moment a lie stops being useful, and the person telling it drops the mask.

Theme

LiesA story is repeated in public until it stops working; the furniture discount and the five children take the self-defense cover apart.
BetrayalThe husband's testimony and "I'm through protecting her now" turn a marriage into evidence against the wife.

Listen for

  • get off — In fast speech, get off can blur together; let t slide into off.
  • two-timing me — Stress two, glide through timing, and keep me light.
  • wasn't born — The t in wasn't often softens; put weight on born.
  • doesn't wash — Let the t in doesn't soften; hit wash like a verdict.
I'm through protecting her now.

He is done covering for her. "Through" means finished — the protection stops here, and he says it as a decision, not a threat.

She can swing for all I care.

"Swing" means to be hanged; "for all I care" means he doesn't care what happens to her. It's a cold way of saying he's out.

Thought she could pull the wool over my eyes.

To pull the wool over someone's eyes is to fool them. He's saying she thought she could deceive him, and she couldn't.

Your story doesn't wash , Mrs. Hart. . .

"Doesn't wash" means the story doesn't hold up — it isn't believable. The name is addressed to the woman telling it.

Yeah , I killed him . I would kill him again .

An open admission of the killing, plus a claim that the same choice would be made again — no self-defense left in it.

Questions about this scene

Why does the self-defense story collapse?

The details don't fit it. Fred knew the family — he sold them their furniture at ten percent off — and once a wife and five children come up, the burglary story has nowhere left to stand.

Who is Fred Casely in this scene?

The deceased whose name is read out first. He sold the Harts their furniture and gave them 10% off, and he is described as having a wife and five little Caselys.

What does 'meal ticket' mean here?

Someone who keeps another person fed — a reliable source of money. It's used to describe the husband, and the reply rejects it: "He couldn't buy my liquor."

Is the burglary claim believable?

The dialogue answers it with a joke: a burglar who came back three times a week for the last month, from a man who knew the family well enough to sell them furniture at a discount.

Chicago · 11 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 2 of 11 · about 25 min to go