Miss Sloane · 2016 — Chapter 8 of 19 · 2'58" · C1

Sloane Takes the Fifth, Explained: with a snap of your fingers

The nominal subject is influence and Indonesia; the real work is discrediting her. One line after another builds a picture of someone out of control, and the same formula keeps coming back: "Upon the advice of counsel, I must respectfully decline to answer your question."

What happens

At a hearing, a lobbyist is questioned about her influence, her chronic insomnia and accusations that she uses stimulants to stay awake. Every version of the question gets the same formula: declining to answer on the advice of counsel, under the Fifth Amendment. When the questioning returns to Indonesia, the pattern breaks and the reply defends her judgment.

InterrogationsSaying noConfrontingC1slowamericanClean
IMDb ↗

Listen for

with a snap of your fingersupon the advice of counselbeing steered by a drunksubstance abuse

00:00 / 02:58
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
  1. ❝ MonologueSloane's rebuttal speech6 linesPractice page ↗
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

with a snap of your fingers

instantly and effortlessly

In the hearing, someone uses an exaggerated image to accuse the other of terrifying power over Washington careers.

You can get a table at any restaurant with a snap of your fingers.

Also in this scene

  • upon the advice of counsel

    a formal legal refusal formula

  • being steered by a drunk

    a situation run by someone reckless

  • substance abuse

    harmful use of drugs or alcohol

  • get off to sleep

    to fall asleep

  • any more than

    not any more than; no more than

Everything marked in this scene

31 notes across 31 lines

Phrase · B1
the amount of something

how much of something

but, you see, what troubles me is the amount of influence you had.
Phrase · B2
destroy someone's career

to ruin someone's professional life

We've seen communications from senior figures in Washington who feared that you, a lobbyist, could destroy their careers with a snap of your fingers.
Phrase · B2
with a snap of one's fingers

instantly and effortlessly

In the hearing, someone uses an exaggerated image to accuse the other of terrifying power over Washington careers.

We've seen communications from senior figures in Washington who feared that you, a lobbyist, could destroy their careers with a snap of your fingers.
Grammar · C1
who feared that you, a lobbyist, could destroy their careers

relative appositive: The relative clause explains their fear, while 'a lobbyist' identifies the person being feared.

We've seen communications from senior figures in Washington who feared that you, a lobbyist, could destroy their careers with a snap of your fingers.
Phrase · C1
something someone has cultivated

an image deliberately built over time

Is this reputation something you've cultivated, Miss Sloane?
Phrase · C1
upon the advice of counsel

a formal legal refusal formula

Under questioning, the speaker keeps using one polished legal formula, making refusal sound automatic.

Upon the advice of counsel, I must respectfully decline to answer your question, based on my rights under the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution.
Phrase · B2
decline to do something

to refuse to do something

Upon the advice of counsel, I must respectfully decline to answer your question, based on my rights under the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution.
Phrase · C1
based on one's rights under

grounded in one's legal rights under

Upon the advice of counsel, I must respectfully decline to answer your question, based on my rights under the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution.
Sound
advice of

Practice linking advice of smoothly, with of kept very light.

Upon the advice of counsel, I must respectfully decline to answer your question, based on my rights under the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution.
Sound
decline to

Keep to weak and put the stress on decline and answer.

Upon the advice of counsel, I must respectfully decline to answer your question, based on my rights under the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution.
Grammar · C1
it's bad enough one person having that much influence

gerund subject: It is a placeholder subject; the real subject is the gerund phrase about one person having so much influence.

You see, it's bad enough one person having that much influence, but if they're out of control, if she has a problem,
Sound
steered by a

Run steered by a together instead of pausing after by.

it would be like the ship of American politics is being steered by a drunk.
Slang · B1
drunk

a drunk person — Informal and insulting; formal writing would use intoxicated person.

it would be like the ship of American politics is being steered by a drunk.
Phrase · C1
have problems with something

to struggle with drug or alcohol abuse

Do you, or have you ever had, any problems with substance abuse?
Phrase · C1
subpoena records

to legally demand records

We subpoenaed medical records.
Phrase · C1
a sufferer from a condition

someone who suffers from a condition

You're a long-time sufferer from chronic insomnia.
Phrase · B1
work over X hours a day

to work more than X hours daily

You regularly work over 16 hours a day.
Phrase · B2
get off to sleep

to fall asleep

After citing chronic insomnia, the questioner presses on whether the person cannot fall asleep at all.

But you can't get off to sleep. Is this accurate?
Slang · B1
Whatever

dismissive 'whatever' — Dismissive and casual; avoid it in formal settings.

Whatever.
Phrase · C1
with the aim of doing something

with the purpose of doing something

witnesses, you've been procuring, off-prescription, a course of psycho-stimulants, with the aim of keeping you awake a little longer.
Grammar · C1
with the aim of keeping you awake

purpose phrase: The phrase 'with the aim of' introduces the intended result: keeping the person awake.

witnesses, you've been procuring, off-prescription, a course of psycho-stimulants, with the aim of keeping you awake a little longer.
Slang · C1
off-prescription

without a prescription — Medical or legal jargon; everyday speech says without a prescription.

witnesses, you've been procuring, off-prescription, a course of psycho-stimulants, with the aim of keeping you awake a little longer.
Phrase · B2
affect someone's judgment

to influence someone's decision-making

My medication doesn't affect my judgment any more than a double espresso.
Phrase · C1
not ... any more than ...

not any more than; no more than

My medication doesn't affect my judgment any more than a double espresso.
Sound
doesn't affect

Let the t in doesn't fade and slide straight into affect.

My medication doesn't affect my judgment any more than a double espresso.
Phrase · B2
recite something from memory

to say something from memory

I can recite from memory a list of upstanding, elected Senators who voted on legislation while severely inebriated.
Phrase · B2
vote on legislation

to vote on a law or bill

I can recite from memory a list of upstanding, elected Senators who voted on legislation while severely inebriated.
Phrase · C1
in no danger of doing something

sarcastic: we will definitely remember

Just after the questioner promises to return to Indonesia, she replies with mock-polite certainty that everyone already knows the basic facts.

And just so you know, I think, by now, we are fully aware, and in no danger of forgetting, that Indonesia is a republic, which happens to be situated on the continent of Asia.
Phrase · B1
be situated on/in a place

to be located in a place

And just so you know, I think, by now, we are fully aware, and in no danger of forgetting, that Indonesia is a republic, which happens to be situated on the continent of Asia.
Grammar · C1
which happens to be situated on the continent of Asia

non-restrictive clause: The which-clause adds extra information about Indonesia and can be removed without breaking the sentence.

And just so you know, I think, by now, we are fully aware, and in no danger of forgetting, that Indonesia is a republic, which happens to be situated on the continent of Asia.
Sound
danger of forgetting

Link danger of forgetting as one fast group.

And just so you know, I think, by now, we are fully aware, and in no danger of forgetting, that Indonesia is a republic, which happens to be situated on the continent of Asia.

Sloane Takes the Fifth, explained

What's really going on

The Fifth Amendment is a shield, not an answer, and it is used as one: the same sentence, word for word, again and again, until the refusal itself becomes a kind of statement. Then it stops. "My medication doesn't affect my judgment any more than a double espresso" is the first real answer, and it lands harder for arriving after so much silence — the pills are not denied, they are redefined as ordinary. The counter-punch does the same thing: a claim that a list of upstanding, elected senators who "voted on legislation while severely inebriated" can be recited from memory hands the charge of intoxication back to the institution. And "in no danger of forgetting" quietly tells the room that every condescending word has been heard.

Theme

PowerOne lobbyist is described as able to end careers with a snap of her fingers — and this hearing is how the institution pushes back.
CorruptionThe defence is that elected senators have voted on legislation while severely inebriated, so the institution is already compromised.

Listen for

  • advice of — Practice linking advice of smoothly, with of kept very light.
  • decline to — Keep to weak and put the stress on decline and answer.
  • steered by a — Run steered by a together instead of pausing after by.
  • doesn't affect — Let the t in doesn't fade and slide straight into affect.
We've seen communications from senior figures in Washington who feared that you, a lobbyist, could destroy their careers with a snap of your fingers.

The claim is that Washington insiders themselves saw a lobbyist as dangerous: someone whose single gesture could end their careers.

it would be like the ship of American politics is being steered by a drunk.

A comparison meant to turn a private habit into a public danger: the whole system off course, steered by a drunk.

My medication doesn't affect my judgment any more than a double espresso.

The reply does not deny taking medication; it argues the effect on judgment is as ordinary as coffee.

I can recite from memory a list of upstanding, elected Senators who voted on legislation while severely inebriated.

The addiction charge is handed back to the Senate: the claim is that elected senators have voted on legislation while severely inebriated.

And just so you know, I think, by now, we are fully aware, and in no danger of forgetting, that Indonesia is a republic, which happens to be situated on the continent of Asia.

A sarcastic jab at how often the phrase "the Asian Republic of Indonesia" has been repeated: nobody in the room needs reminding.

Questions about this scene

Why is the same answer repeated again and again?

Every version of the question is met with the same formula: declining to answer on the advice of counsel, under the Fifth Amendment. The line is repeated word for word after questions about influence, substance abuse, insomnia and medication.

How does the hearing know about her insomnia and pills?

Medical records were subpoenaed, and a witness's deposition says she has been getting psycho-stimulants off-prescription to stay awake longer. The questioner also notes chronic insomnia and sixteen-hour workdays.

Why bring up senators who voted while drunk?

It turns the addiction charge on the Senate: the claim is that a list of upstanding, elected senators who voted on legislation while severely inebriated can be recited from memory.

What does the double espresso comparison concede?

That medication is not denied — the reply argues its effect on judgment is no greater than that of an ordinary double espresso.

Miss Sloane · 19 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 8 of 19 · about 31 min to go