Best in Show · 2000 — Chapter 2 of 11 · 2'46" · B2

A Hostage Negotiator at Dinner, Explained: talk people down

One guest answers a bad day with a job title: chief hostage negotiator, the person they call when someone is on a ledge. Then comes the trade secret — "They all jump" — and a fall described step by step: gargoyle, grape, pinata. Around the table, a lake-and-pinata memory gets disputed, and the dog has vanished.

What happens

A dinner-table conversation. Someone at the table explains they are the chief hostage negotiator for Akron and the tri-county area, that they talk people down off buildings — and then, asked how many they have saved, says: they all jump. What follows (gargoyle, grape, pinata) is described in detail; then the dog goes missing.

StorytellingThreatsExplainingThreateningB2fastamerican
IMDb ↗

Listen for

I've got news for youtalk people downa picture is worth a thousand wordsI shit you not

00:00 / 02:46
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
  1. ❝ MonologueA Negotiator's Confession6 linesPractice page ↗
  2. ❝ MonologueThe falling-body story10 linesPractice page ↗
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

talk people down

persuade someone out of a crisis

Max explains his job with this phrase: he is called when someone is threatening to jump.

Police officers try to talk people down from bridges.

Also in this scene

  • I've got news for you

    Here's the grim truth.

  • a picture is worth a thousand words

    An image says more than words.

  • I shit you not

    I'm not kidding.

  • gargoyle

    stone grotesque on a building

  • lose their lives

    die

Everything marked in this scene

30 notes across 54 lines

Phrase · B1
get rid of something

remove or free yourself from

I can't get rid of it in my head.
Sound
get rid of it

Practice the whole phrase as one rushed chunk, not four separate words.

I can't get rid of it in my head.
Phrase · B1
lose one's life

die

The phrase lifts a bad-day complaint into life-and-death language, making the contrast brutal.

I do and lives get lost. People lose their lives.
Phrase · B2
chief hostage negotiator

top crisis negotiator

I'm the chief hostage negotiator for the Akron and tri-county area.
Phrase · B2
tri-county area

three-county region

I'm the chief hostage negotiator for the Akron and tri-county area.
Phrase · B2
get a jumper on a building

have someone threatening to jump Here jumper means a person threatening to jump, not a sweater.

And I talk people down. When they get a jumper on a building, they call me.
Slang · B2
jumper

person threatening to jump — Cop/negotiator jargon; avoid in ordinary polite talk.

And I talk people down. When they get a jumper on a building, they call me.
Phrase · B2
a secret from the trade

insider secret Here the trade means the profession, not a business deal.

I've got news for you. It's a little secret from the trade. They all jump.
Slang · B2
the trade

the profession — Insider jargon for one's profession; sounds informal.

I've got news for you. It's a little secret from the trade. They all jump.
Sound
drop like rocks

Keep the beat on drop and rocks; let like slide past.

You think they drop like rocks. They don't.
Phrase · B1
on the way down

during the fall

He hit a gargoyle on the way down.
Phrase · B2
pop off

come off suddenly

...pops off like a grape, the body continues to spin down like a whirligig.
Phrase · B1
pop out

burst out

...everything pops out. It's like a pinata.
Phrase · B1
seems like [time period]

feels very recent

Seems like last week, I'll tell you.
Phrase · B1
be just talk

empty words

-No, it's just talk! -He's just like an animal.
Phrase · B2
compliment someone on something

praise someone for

I forgot to compliment you on your luscious, uh, melon breasts tonight.
Phrase · A2
talking about something

discussing something

-What are you talking about now? -Thank you, Gerry.
Grammar · B2
what you don't understand is

subject clause: The what-clause is the subject; it sets up the point that follows.

You know, what you don't understand is...
Phrase · A2
go on

continue talking

If I wanted to go on, I could go 800 words more.
Grammar · B1
If I wanted to go on, I could go

second conditional: A hypothetical: he isn't going on, but could if he chose.

If I wanted to go on, I could go 800 words more.
Phrase · B1
this is what I do

this is my job

-Please, honey, this is what I do. -Don't be mad at him, please.
Phrase · A2
be mad at someone

be angry with someone

-Please, honey, this is what I do. -Don't be mad at him, please.
Phrase · C1
gouge something out

dig something out violently

I'll gouge your eye out with my thumb. I shit you not, you freak.
Sound
I shit you not

Stress shit and not; keep you light for a harsher rhythm.

I'll gouge your eye out with my thumb. I shit you not, you freak.
Slang · C1
I shit you not

I'm not kidding — Very vulgar; only among close friends or in fiction.

I'll gouge your eye out with my thumb. I shit you not, you freak.
Slang · B2
freak

weirdo; creep — Insulting; likely to start a fight.

I'll gouge your eye out with my thumb. I shit you not, you freak.
Phrase · B1
punch someone in the eye

hit someone's eye

Get down! I'm gonna punch you in the eye till it turns to jelly.
Slang · A2
gonna

going to — Casual speech for going to; avoid in formal writing.

Get down! I'm gonna punch you in the eye till it turns to jelly.
Sound
look at him

Treat look at him as one quick block, with at and him very light.

Don't look at him in the eyes, it challenges him.
Phrase · B1
stab someone with something

pierce someone with forks

I'll stab you with forks until you bleed.

A Hostage Negotiator at Dinner, explained

What's really going on

The table is being held hostage by a story. The job title — 'chief hostage negotiator' — is used to justify detail nobody asked for, and the punchline is the trade secret: "They all jump." That line does two jobs: it makes the teller the only expert in the room, and it makes the listener's bad day ("someone returns a sweater") sound trivial. The graphic description reads as a performance, not a confession; only "Forgive me" suggests it might not be dinner talk. The lake-and-pinata memory that follows is a second negotiation — someone claims it was "you and me," gets "Are you sure that was you?", and the reply is a flat "I know."

Theme

Dark humorA suicide story is told like a dinner anecdote, with a pinata punchline — the horror and the small talk are played at exactly the same volume.
SatireA life-or-death credential is offered as dinner conversation, and the horror lands as comedy.

Listen for

  • get rid of it — Practice the whole phrase as one rushed chunk, not four separate words.
  • drop like rocks — Keep the beat on drop and rocks; let like slide past.
  • I shit you not — Stress shit and not; keep you light for a harsher rhythm.
  • look at him — Treat look at him as one quick block, with at and him very light.
I've got news for you. It's a little secret from the trade. They all jump.

The setup before bad news: what follows is not going to be pleasant. Here it means no one this negotiator talks down actually survives.

You think they drop like rocks. They don't.

A correction to what the listener assumes about a fall: bodies don't fall straight and heavy, which sets up the gargoyle detail.

He hit a gargoyle on the way down.

The detail that turns the story graphic: on the way down, the falling man struck a carved stone figure on the building.

I'll gouge your eye out with my thumb. I shit you not, you freak.

A flat-out threat, with 'I shit you not' as the swear-heavy way of saying 'I'm not kidding.'

Don't look at him in the eyes, it challenges him.

Advice about handling whoever is being threatened: eye contact reads as a challenge.

Questions about this scene

Why does the negotiator say "they all jump"?

It is offered as the trade secret of the job: after saying he is the chief hostage negotiator for Akron and the tri-county area, he says the people he talks down all jump — and repeats, "They all jump."

What does gargoyle mean here?

A carved stone figure on a building. According to the story, the man who jumped hit one on the way down and his head was caught in its mouth.

Is the lake and pinata story about the person being spoken to?

That is exactly what the table argues about. Someone says, "I was remembering that time with you and me at the lake. With the pinata," and the answer is "Was that you? Are you sure that was you?" — then "I know."

Who is Winky?

The dog. Early on someone asks if Winky can walk around; later people are calling "Winky? Winky?" and asking where the dog is.

What kind of threats get thrown around at the end?

Eyes and forks: gouging an eye out with a thumb, punching an eye until it turns to jelly, stabbing with forks until the person bleeds — plus the warning not to look him in the eyes.

Best in Show · 11 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 2 of 11 · about 28 min to go