Mind telling me what the hell's wrong?The Proposal · 2009 — Chapter 12 of 14 · 5'43" · B1
The Sham Marriage Exposed, Explained: off the hook
The boat ride is supposed to be a break, not a reckoning. Margaret is furious, Andrew is hurt, and the sham marriage collapses into the open when the deal is named: confess, or go to prison. "You tell the truth, you're off the hook."
What happens
Out on the water near Sitka, Margaret and Andrew argue on a boat. Margaret admits she misses having a family; Andrew says their engagement is a lie they're both telling. When the boat drifts off, Margaret falls overboard and Andrew pulls her back in. Back on shore, the father and a lawyer confront them about the sham marriage.
Listen for
off the hookscrewing it upcheck up onon your behalf
Phrase of the scene
off the hook
free from blame, punishment, or an obligation
父亲带来移民官做交易:只要安德鲁声明婚姻是假的、说出真相,他就能脱身,而玛格丽特会被遣返加拿大。
The witness lied, so the real suspect got off the hook.
Also in this scene
- screwing it up
ruining or messing something up
- check up on
to make sure someone is behaving or doing well
- on your behalf
as your representative or for your benefit
Everything marked in this scene
27 notes across 77 lines
Would you mind telling me what's happening now, Margaret?I forgot what it was like to have a family.embedded question
I forgot what it was like to have a family.We'd love to come down for the holidays.ruining or messing something up
and you have Gertrude, and I'm... I'm just screwing it up.I know that. Yes, you know that. And you're still willing to put them through this?They're not gonna find out.liaison
They're not gonna find out.If Gammy finds out, she's gonna have a heart attack.She's gonna have a heart attack. Will you calm down? Hold on.elision
She's gonna have a heart attack. Will you calm down? Hold on.Whoa. I don't think that hijacking a boat is a proper way to express your frustration.Whoa. I don't think that hijacking a boat is a proper way to express your frustration.Now you decide to shut up, Margaret.Now you decide to shut up, Margaret.All right, come on. Give me your hand.Come on, come on. I got you. I got you.flap
Come on, come on. I got you. I got you.Could've gotten yourself killed.could have + past participle
Could've gotten yourself killed.Told you I'd check up on you.as your representative or for your benefit
The father claims he struck the deal for his son's benefit, without asking him.
Dad! Luckily for you, your father negotiated a deal on your behalf.You're gonna make a statement admitting this marriage is a sham, or you're gonna go to prison.participial phrase
You're gonna make a statement admitting this marriage is a sham, or you're gonna go to prison.free from blame, punishment, or an obligation
You tell the truth, you're off the hook.Ah, well. Take the deal.The Sham Marriage Exposed, explained
What's really going on
On the surface this is a fight about a boat and a lie, but both of them are circling something they can't say out loud. Margaret is used to being alone and calls herself the one who is "screwing it up"; Andrew keeps pointing out that his family would be humiliated by the deception. The scene turns when the father, who has been investigating, lays out the legal reality: "You tell the truth, you're off the hook." The offer is built to split them, because only Andrew gets the soft landing. Andrew's answer, that he asked her to marry him, is the first time either of them chooses the other over self-interest, even if it may still be part of the lie.
Theme
What you'll learn
- Use off the hook to describe escaping blame
- Understand sham as fake or deceptive
- Ask politely with Would you mind
- Use calm down to soothe a tense scene
Listen for
- find out — liaison
- calm down — elision
- got you — flap
You tell the truth, you're off the hook.Confess, and you walk away with no charges. The deal only covers Andrew, so it turns the confession into a test of loyalty.
You'd do the same for me.He claims she would sacrifice herself for him too, turning a business arrangement into something that sounds mutual.
I forgot what it was like to have a family.After years alone, she admits the family reminds her of everything she has been missing, and it hurts.
Whoa. I don't think that hijacking a boat is a proper way to express your frustration.A dry joke while she is at the wheel: taking the boat is not the way to show how upset she is.
Questions about this scene
Why does Margaret panic about Gammy finding out?
Gammy is the grandmother who took Margaret in, and Margaret says "if Gammy finds out, she's gonna have a heart attack." She is more afraid of hurting the family than of the legal trouble.
Does Andrew mean it when he says he proposed?
In this scene he stands up and tells the room, "I asked her to marry me. She said yes." It reads as both a defense and a confession, which is why the film keeps it ambiguous.
What deal is offered to Andrew?
Confess that the marriage is a sham and Andrew goes free, while Margaret is sent back to Canada. "You tell the truth, you're off the hook" is the offer, and it is meant to test whether he will turn on her.
Who is Gilbertson and why is he there?
He is the official who called the father after suspecting the marriage was fake. He is flown to Sitka to force a statement, even though the family already seems to know the truth.
The Proposal · 14 chapters
All chapters →
Up next · Chapter 13get my head on straightMargaret Confesses at the Wedding
Chapter 1let someone goMargaret Fires Bob
Chapter 2turn operations over toMargaret Announces a Fake Engagement
Chapter 3out of your hairMargaret Fakes a Marriage Interview
Chapter 4with cherries on topAndrew Makes Margaret Propose
Chapter 5a meal ticketMargaret Meets the Paxton Family
Chapter 6pulling your legAndrew Brings Margaret Home to Sitka
Chapter 7from the ground upAndrew Turns Down the Family Business
Chapter 8called it offMargaret Meets Andrew's Ex
Chapter 9take this the wrong wayMargaret and Andrew Trade Secrets
Chapter 10a shamThe Paxtons Plan a Barn Wedding
Chapter 11burst into tearsAnnie Gives Margaret the Heirloom Dress
Watching · Chapter 12off the hookThe Sham Marriage Exposed
Chapter 13get my head on straightMargaret Confesses at the Wedding
Chapter 14dawned on meAndrew Proposes to Margaret