Clerks II · 2006 — Chapter 5 of 17 · 3'11" · B2

Trilogy Showdown at Mooby's, Explained: Say what you will about

Over fast food, a movie argument turns into a loyalty test: one side recites The Lord of the Rings, the other insists "There's only one trilogy." The fight is less about films than about who gets to define taste, and the reply is a flat verdict on the other side's entire worldview.

What happens

At Mooby's, an order for a shake and onion rings turns into a full-blown argument about film trilogies. One person recites the ring verse; another counts repeat viewings; the talk escalates from Oscar credentials to where the third film should have ended.

Ordering foodArgumentsTeasingConfrontingB2mediumamerican
IMDb ↗

Listen for

I'm the geekwhipping out your preciousesdownfucking morons

00:00 / 03:11
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

I'm the geek

So I'm the geek now?

After being called a Star Wars geek, the reply throws the label straight back with mock surprise.

I'm the geek? You're the one with three box sets.

Also in this scene

  • whipping out your preciouses

    pulling out your prized things; a crude double entendre

  • down

    okay with; into

  • fucking morons

    fucking idiots

  • Mannequin Skywalker

    a pun on Anakin Skywalker: wooden acting

  • massive achievement

    a huge accomplishment

Everything marked in this scene

29 notes across 61 lines

Phrase · A2take someone's order

take someone's order

Welcome to Mooby's. May I take your order?
Soundtake your order

Keep 'your' light; land the beat on 'order'.

Welcome to Mooby's. May I take your order?
Slang · B1ain't

isn't / aren't — Informal speech; avoid it in formal writing.

All right, look, there's only one Return, okay, and it ain't of the king... it's of the Jedi.
Slang · B1geek

nerd; obsessive fan — Fine among friends, but it can sting if aimed at someone.

Oh, Star Wars geek.
Phrase · B1excuse someone

make allowances for him

You'll have to excuse him.
Slang · B2what the fuck

what the hell — Strong profanity; never use it in formal settings.

Oh, what the fuck happened to this world?
Phrase · B1start calling someone something

start calling someone something

Maybe we should start calling your friend Padme, because he loves Mannequin Skywalker so much, right?
Soundboring as hell

Hit 'hell' hard and glide through 'boring as'.

Those fucking hobbit movies were boring as hell.
Slang · B1as hell

extremely — Casual intensifier; too crude for formal writing.

Those fucking hobbit movies were boring as hell.
Phrase · A2a bunch of something

a lot of; a group of

All it was was a bunch of people walking.
Grammar · B2All it was was

double was construction: The first was belongs to 'All it was'; the second links it to 'a bunch of people walking'.

All it was was a bunch of people walking.
Phrase · B1be way off

completely wrong Here it means 'completely wrong', not physically far away.

He is way off. Loser.
Slang · B2Fuckin' A

hell yeah; absolutely — Vulgar slang for enthusiastic agreement; keep it casual.

Fuckin' A.
Phrase · B1have had enough of someone

be fed up with someone

I've had enough of you.
Soundenough of you

Let 'enough of' blur; 'of' barely takes a beat.

I've had enough of you.
Phrase · B2a simplistic analysis of something

an overly simple analysis

Your simplistic analysis of the trilogy aside,
Grammar · C1Your simplistic analysis of the trilogy aside,

fronted aside: The aside is fronted to dismiss the analysis before the main claim arrives.

Your simplistic analysis of the trilogy aside,
Grammar · C1that even the Academy recognized when they gave Peter Jackson the Best Directing Oscar

relative clause: The that-clause qualifies 'achievement'; the when-clause adds the Academy's award moment.

The Lord of the Rings was a massive achievement that even the Academy recognized when they gave Peter Jackson the Best Directing Oscar...
Slang · B2sick burn

a great comeback — Praise among friends for a sharp comeback; not for formal settings.

Oh, sick burn.
Grammar · C1If Peter Jackson really wanted to blow me away

counterfactual if-clause: The if-clause sets up a hypothetical; the result arrives in the next line with would've ended.

If Peter Jackson really wanted to blow me away with those "Rings" movies,
Phrase · C1a logical closure point

a logical point to end the story

he would've ended the third one on the logical closure point, not the 25 endings that followed.
Phrase · C1enlighten someone

explain it to us A sarcastic 'do tell', not a sincere request for enlightenment.

Yeah, friend, enlighten us.
Phrase · A2wake up from something

come out of sleep or a coma

When fucking Frito wakes up from his little coma or whatever, and the little hobbits are jumping up and down on his bed, and Sam leans in the doorway and gives him that very fuckin' gay look.
Phrase · B2say what you will about something

whatever you say about

Say what you will about Jesus, but leave the Rings out of this.
Phrase · B2leave something out of something

keep something out of this

Say what you will about Jesus, but leave the Rings out of this.
Soundout of this

Run 'out of' together, with the t kept light.

Say what you will about Jesus, but leave the Rings out of this.
Phrase · A2take a walk

go away for a while Here it means 'go away for a while', not a casual stroll.

That look was so gay, I thought Sam was gonna tell the little hobbits to take a walk so he could saunter over to Frodo and suck his fuckin' cock.
Slang · C1faggot

a homophobic slur — A homophobic slur; never use it.

Hey, faggot, they're not gay. They're hobbits.
Phrase · B2right before something happens

just before the closing credits

And then right after the Sam-Frodo suckfest, right before the credits roll,

Trilogy Showdown at Mooby's, explained

What's really going on

The ordering counter is a stage for status games. The ring verse, the repeat-viewing tally, the Oscar citation: each detail is offered as proof that the speaker belongs to the right fandom and the other does not. The argument keeps shifting from taste to authority—who has seen more, who understands structure, who can invoke the Academy. "Say what you will about Jesus, but leave the Rings out of this" turns a movie debate into a mock-sacred boundary, and the reply about "the Shire" answers in the same register. Under the jokes, the scene is about the pleasure and pettiness of defending the thing you love in front of people who don't.

Theme

Dark humorThe debate treats fandom trivia as life-or-death, turning fan culture into black comedy.
IdentityThe argument is really about who belongs in the right fandom and whose taste counts.

Listen for

  • take your order — Keep 'your' light; land the beat on 'order'.
  • boring as hell — Hit 'hell' hard and glide through 'boring as'.
  • enough of you — Let 'enough of' blur; 'of' barely takes a beat.
  • out of this — Run 'out of' together, with the t kept light.
There's only one trilogy, you fucking morons.

The speaker declares that only one trilogy counts and calls the others idiots; in this argument, that means Star Wars.

Those fucking hobbit movies were boring as hell.

A blunt verdict that the fantasy films are tedious; 'as hell' intensifies 'boring' rather than adding literal meaning.

Even the fuckin' trees walked in those movies.

An exaggerated complaint about slow pacing: the films are so full of walking that even the trees join in.

Say what you will about Jesus, but leave the Rings out of this.

You may say what you like about Jesus, but The Lord of the Rings is off-limits here; the line draws a joking sacred boundary.

I am gonna kick your ass back to the Shire if you don't shut your fuckin' mouth.

A mock threat to beat someone and send them 'back to the Shire' unless they stop talking; the place name turns the threat into a fantasy-flavored joke.

Now, that would've been an Academy Award-worthy ending.

A sarcastic claim that a crude imagined ending would deserve an Oscar; 'worthy' is used as mock praise.

Questions about this scene

Why does the film argument turn into a fight about trilogies?

Because each side treats the word as a claim to legitimacy. One line insists, "There's only one trilogy," while another defends The Lord of the Rings as "a massive achievement" backed by Peter Jackson's Oscar. The disagreement is about which films count and whose taste has authority.

What is the joke about "Return"?

One line says there is only one Return and "it ain't of the king... it's of the Jedi." The joke is that the word Return belongs to a different film, which sets up the claim that only one trilogy counts.

Why does the argument suddenly bring up Jesus?

The line sets up a contrast: "Say what you will about Jesus, but leave the Rings out of this." Jesus can be discussed, but The Lord of the Rings is treated as untouchable. The joke is the mock-sacred exception.

Is the Oscar brought up as praise or as a weapon?

As a weapon. One line calls The Lord of the Rings a "massive achievement" and notes that the Academy gave Peter Jackson Best Directing, then contrasts that with George Lucas never winning. The award is used to win the argument.

Why does someone count repeat viewings?

The count serves as evidence in the fandom argument: three for Fellowship, two for Towers, and five for Return are offered as proof of commitment and knowledge. The exact numbers matter less than the claim they support.

Clerks II · 17 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 5 of 17 · about 37 min to go