00:00 / 03:34
00:00 / 03:34

Reporters Question the Frightened Clerk, Explained

Woodward and Bernstein knock on a committee secretary's door and ask about documents shredded at the committee. At first she talks, naming John Mitchell and his raincoat trick, then she pulls back: "I'd just as soon not... Okay? Maybe I could call you." The real question is no longer what she knows, but whether someone has already gotten to her.

InvestigationAskingPersuadingStrangersB2fastamerican

Key moments

Start here, then watch the full scene
  1. The Key to the Whole Cover-Up

    2:22–2:56
    35s
  2. Woodward Won't Publish on a Hunch

    3:04–3:25
    21s

Reporters Question the Frightened Clerk, explained

What happens

Woodward and Bernstein track down Betty Milland, a frightened clerk at the Committee to Reelect. At her door they ask whether she was there when documents were shredded at the committee. She was, and she adds that Attorney General John Mitchell once came in at night with a raincoat over his head. Then she stops answering and asks them to leave before "they" see them.

What's really going on

This is where the reporting stops being paperwork. A clerk who has nothing personal against the reporters gives them a real lead — shredding, and the attorney general walking in with a raincoat over his head — and then locks up. The raincoat detail is the kind of evidence that sounds like a joke until you think about why a man hides his face: "You have some idea what's in the papers when the attorney general comes in... it's at the committee, and he's got a raincoat over his head." Woodward and Bernstein already sense they have been beaten to her. "Someone got to that woman," one of them says, "It's the key to the whole cover-up." But they still can't write it, and the argument in the car is the movie's real subject: they have a frightened source, a strange image, and not enough verified fact.

Key lines & what they mean

“I need more fact for a story, and I think you should need the same.”
Woodward's answer to the pressure to publish: a good story needs verified facts, not just a hunch, and he tells his partner to hold the same standard.
“A guy can come up to me on the street, and he can ask me an address.”
Woodward's point is that a question is not evidence. Someone asking an address might be lost, not interrogating him, so he can't build a story on what it seems to mean.
“I don't have enough gut feeling. I wish I did.”
Bernstein wants to trust his instinct that the woman is helping them. Woodward admits his instinct isn't enough to print — and that he would prefer it were.
“It's the key to the whole cover-up.”
One reporter believes the frightened clerk holds the proof that the break-in was covered up, which is why losing her to silence is such a blow.

Theme

  • Corruption — A committee clerk describes documents being shredded and the attorney general arriving in disguise — small details that point to an organized effort to bury the truth.
  • Secrets — The reporters have a frightened source who knows where the evidence went, but the truth stays locked behind fear and pressure from people she won't name.

What this chapter teaches

Teaching points

Review right after watching
My level4/9

A1–C2 is the CEFR scale. Cards above the level you pick fade, and playback will not auto-pause on them.

All the President's Men: your progress

Chapter 9 of 18 · about 31 min to go

← Previous
Up next · 10bury the reportThe scene: Nixon Renominated, Report Buried

Takeaways

What you walk away with
  1. Gut feeling is instinct, and he admits he does not have enough.
  2. Get to someone means reach them first and change their mind.
  3. A cover-up hides the whole crime, not just one lie.
  4. A stranger asking for directions is not yet a story.

People also search

Questions, then the lines
Why does the clerk stop answering questions?

She is scared. She gives them real details, then asks to quit, says she would just as soon not continue, and asks them to leave before "they" see them — suggesting she has been warned or watched by people at the committee.

Who is the frightened clerk and what does she reveal?

She is Betty Milland, a secretary at the Committee to Reelect. She confirms she was there during the shredding and says Attorney General John Mitchell once came in at night with a raincoat over his head.

Why do the reporters find the raincoat detail important?

A man covering his face to enter the committee suggests he didn't want to be seen, which hints the meeting was about something secret — even if the reporters can't yet prove what.

Why can't Woodward and Bernstein write the story yet?

They have one frightened source, a claim about shredding, and an odd detail about a raincoat, but no proof of what was destroyed or who ordered it. Woodward insists the paper needs more verified fact first.