An American Crime · 2007 — 第 14 / 16 章 · 2'39" · B1

Reverend Collier Visits Gertrude, Explained:get to the bottom of something

Reverend Collier comes to check on the Baniszewski household after Paula's visit to his church. He offers to help and mentions that Paula may be pregnant. Gertrude calls the rumor "a vicious lie," blames Sylvia, and claims she "had to send her to juvenile."

あらすじ

At the Baniszewski house, Reverend Bill Collier visits Gertrude because Paula came to his church worried about the family. He tells Gertrude that Paula may be pregnant and offers whatever support he can. Gertrude denies it, blames Sylvia, and says she sent the girl to juvenile. The reverend believes her and offers to visit Sylvia there.

AccusationsArgumentsExplainingConfrontingFriendsB1slowamericanClean
IMDb ↗

注目の表現

get to the bottom of somethingbe a bad influence on someonea vicious liespeak for someone

00:00 / 02:39
Space 再生 · ← → セリフ移動 · R リピート
いま
  1. ❝ 独白Gertrude's defense13 行練習ページ ↗
セリフをタップするとそこから再生

このシーンの表現

get to the bottom of something

find out the real cause

Told that Paula spoke for herself, Gertrude offers to look into it, sounding cooperative.

We need to get to the bottom of why the order was cancelled.

このシーンの他の表現

  • be a bad influence on someone

    lead someone astray

  • a vicious lie

    a cruel, deliberate lie

  • speak for someone

    represent a group

  • offer support

    give help

  • drop someone with someone

    leave someone in another's care

このシーンのメモ一覧

53 行のセリフに 24 件のメモ

スラング · A2lord

goodness — A mild spoken exclamation; fine casually.

Oh, lord.
表現 · A2come by (somewhere)

stop in for a visit

I've been meaning to come by and visit...
文法 · B1I've been meaning to

present perfect continuous: It marks an intention you keep postponing up to now.

I've been meaning to come by and visit...
発音been meaning to

Link been and meaning so they blur into one run.

I've been meaning to come by and visit...
表現 · B1bother someone with something

pester you about something

Now, what's that girl been bothering you with?
スラング · B1that girl

that girl, dismissively — Dismissive behind someone's back; rude to their face.

Now, what's that girl been bothering you with?
表現 · A2be concerned about someone

worried about someone

Well, she's concerned about you and the whole house.
表現 · B1offer what help one can

help as much as one can

Now, I'm prepared to offer what support I can...
表現 · B1speak for someone

represent a group

The reverend offers help but refuses to commit the whole congregation.

but, I can't speak for the entire congregation.
発音lie and

Lie and runs together with almost no break.

but, it's a vicious lie and rumor...
表現 · B2get to the bottom of something

find out the real cause

Told that Paula spoke for herself, Gertrude offers to look into it, sounding cooperative.

I'll try to get to the bottom of that with Paula...
表現 · B1be a bad influence on someone

lead someone astray

Gertrude blames Sylvia for changing her daughter since she moved in.

but Sylvia has been a very bad influence on her...
表現 · B1discipline a child

keep the child in line

I just can not discipline that girl.
表現 · B1not do something in weeks

for weeks at a time

and I haven't seen Sylvia, in church in weeks...
文法 · B1I'm afraid

softener: I'm afraid softens bad news before it lands.

I'm afraid, I had to send her to juvenile.
表現 · B1catch someone doing something

see someone in the act

Gertrude claims she caught Sylvia stealing to justify sending her away.

I caught her stealing from me...
文法 · A2Have you spoken with

present perfect: The present perfect asks whether the talk has happened by now.

Have you spoken with her parents about this?
表現 · B2drop someone with someone

leave someone in another's care

Gertrude grumbles that Sylvia's parents simply dumped her on her.

why they just dropped her with me.
スラング · B2just dropped her with me

dumped her on me — Said in complaint when someone shirks a duty.

why they just dropped her with me.
表現 · A2go by (a place)

stop by a place

The reverend offers to stop by the juvenile center and see Sylvia himself.

I just can go by the juvenile center...
スラング · A1kids

children — A casual word for children; too informal for formal talk.

Hey, kids.
表現 · B1continue a discussion

pick the talk up again

We can continue this discussion later.
表現 · A2before the end of the week

by the week's end

I'm excepting you in my office before the end of the week.
発音end of the

End of the links into one soft run.

I'm excepting you in my office before the end of the week.

「Reverend Collier Visits Gertrude」を読み解く

What's really going on

The scene runs on politeness, and that is what makes it dangerous. Reverend Collier means well, but he lets Gertrude control the story. He says he will "get to the bottom of that with Paula," yet when Gertrude calls the pregnancy rumor "a vicious lie" and says Sylvia "had to send her to juvenile," he does not push back. Instead he accepts her framing and offers to visit Sylvia at the detention center — a place she was never sent. Gertrude's real skill here is redirection: she turns a question about a child's safety into a complaint about Sylvia being a "bad influence," and the reverend leaves satisfied that he has been helpful. His goodwill becomes cover for the abuse in that house.

Theme

DeceptionGertrude answers a welfare check with a lie about juvenile, and the reverend leaves believing the story.
FaithA church visit that should protect a child becomes the moment the wrongdoing is sealed off from outside help.

このチャプターで学べること

  • Polite offers of help can still draw a firm line.
  • Calling the truth a vicious lie is a calculated move.
  • The reverend's calm visit becomes an implied threat.
  • Here juvenile means a detention center, not a child.

発音のポイント

  • been meaning to — Link been and meaning so they blur into one run.
  • lie and — Lie and runs together with almost no break.
  • end of the — End of the links into one soft run.
Now, I'm prepared to offer what support I can...

The reverend offers help but limits it right away; support yes, full backing no.

I'll try to get to the bottom of that with Paula...

He says he will find out the truth about Paula, but he never questions the story Gertrude tells him about Sylvia.

I just could not handle that girl.

Gertrude uses a helpless tone to justify sending Sylvia away, framing her own cruelty as exhaustion.

I just can not discipline that girl.

The same excuse again: instead of admitting what she is doing, Gertrude says Sylvia is simply beyond control.

このシーンについての質問

Why does Reverend Collier visit Gertrude's house?

Paula came to his church worried about the family, and Sylvia has not been seen at church for weeks. He visits to check on the household and ends up accepting Gertrude's explanation.

Does Reverend Collier suspect Gertrude is lying?

He does not seem to. He asks about Sylvia's parents and offers to visit the juvenile center, which suggests he takes the story at face value rather than doubting it.

Why does Gertrude call the pregnancy rumor a lie?

Calling it "a vicious lie" shifts attention from Paula to the person Gertrude wants to blame. It lets her sound wronged while avoiding the question the reverend actually came to ask.

What is actually happening to Sylvia while the reverend visits?

She is being held and punished inside the house, not in any institution. Gertrude's claim that she was sent to juvenile is false, and the reverend's visit ends up making the cover-up stronger.

アメリカン・クライム · 全 16 章

すべて見る →
第 14 / 16 章 · 残り約 6 分