00:00 / 05:50
00:00 / 05:50

Steve and Rob Rank Their Careers, Explained

The Trip · 2011

Capítulo 9 de 20 · 5'50"

Over scallops and pigeon, one man tells the other that greatness is a problem he will only ever imagine. "I'd rather have these moments of genius than a lifetime of mediocrity" is both a boast and a ranking. The same edge follows them through age, a phone call, and a valley where three thousand years shrinks to nothing.

ArgumentsTravel & hotelsTeasingConfrontingFriendsB2british

Key moments

Start here, then watch the full scene
  1. No Such Thing as a Haggis Hunt

    1:39–2:15
    36s

Steve and Rob Rank Their Careers, explained

What happens

At dinner one man tells the other that greatness is a problem he will only ever imagine. Scallops and pigeon arrive, Coleridge is set beside a pop song, and a haggis story warns that someone is taking you for a fool. A call sets tomorrow's photographer. On the fell, three thousand years is the blink of an eye, and Dove Cottage turns them away at five past five.

What's really going on

The meal is a contest in the shape of chat. "I'd rather be me than you" ranks two careers in one breath, a few flashes of genius against "a lifetime of mediocrity." "My career is not mediocre" never gets a real answer, because the plates arrive and the scoring changes costume. Setting Coleridge beside Olivia Newton-John "with varying degrees of success" sounds even-handed and still refuses either of them a clean win. The haggis bit is a trap told twice: "They've taken you for a fool," then the flat punchline that no such hunt exists. On the fell the scale flips. Three thousand years becomes "the blink of an eye" next to rock formed 400 million years ago, and the dinner's scoreboard suddenly looks small. Dove Cottage is shut at five past five, so the day ends on a closed door rather than a winner.

Key lines & what they mean

“Yeah, and you'll always imagine, because it's not a problem you'll ever have to contend with.”
Dressed as sympathy, it tells the other man he will only ever picture greatness, because his career will never force him to face the problem of matching it.
“I'd rather be me than you, because I'd rather have these moments of genius than a lifetime of mediocrity.”
He chooses his own uneven flashes of brilliance over what he calls the other man's ordinary life, and he says that choice out loud.
“You can't treat your entire life like a Radio 4 panel show.”
It accuses the other man of living as if every day were a comic panel show, always reaching for the next laugh.
“everything's exhausting when you're past 40.”
Once the baby question is answered with a yes, fatigue stops being one chore and becomes the rule for everything past forty.

Theme

  • Pride — One man sets moments of genius against a lifetime of mediocrity, and the other man answers that his career is not mediocre.
  • Satire — A pop song is weighed against Coleridge, a haggis hunt is exposed as a trick, and a whole life is likened to a panel show.

Qué aprendes en este capítulo

Puntos de enseñanza

Repasa justo después de ver
Mi nivel0/4

A1–C2 es la escala MCER. Las tarjetas por encima del nivel elegido se atenúan y la reproducción no se pausa en ellas.

The Trip: tu progreso

Capítulo 9 de 20 · quedan unos 56 min

← Anterior
Siguiente · 10not unlikeLa escena: Turned Away at Dove Cottage

Ideas clave

Lo que te llevas
  1. Taken for a fool as a sting
  2. Last admission as a hard stop
  3. Mediocrity as a life sentence

Preguntas frecuentes

La pregunta, luego la frase
Why would he rather have moments of genius than a lifetime of mediocrity?

It is a ranking, not a confession. He would rather be himself, with a few flashes of brilliance, than live what he calls the other man's ordinary career. The reply is "My career is not mediocre," and the plates arrive before it can be settled.

Who is the phone call with, and what is it about?

He answers "Hi, Emma." She is reminding him about a photographer named Yolanda, who will meet him at Hipping Hall tomorrow. Emma is coming up with her, and the photos are for the article they already discussed at the office.

Why do they stop on the Langdale walk?

The light is failing and it is late. One asks how far they are going. The other says a little bit further, then admits they shouldn't go much further "just because of the light."

Why can't they visit Dove Cottage?

They ask for two tickets and are told the last admission was 5:00. It is already five past. The visit ends at the door.

Is the haggis hunt real?

No. The pigeon is "a little like haggis," which sets up the warning that anyone who invites you on a haggis hunt has taken you for a fool. The line that closes it is "There's no such thing as a haggis hunt."