“What the public had was superstition and fear.”
Why it's great
Two nouns finish the indictment, and the verb makes them sound like all the public owned.
Register
Formal
Use it yourself
What the town had was rumor and panic.
00:00 / 02:58
00:00 / 02:58
Orca Families Each Have a Language, Explained
blackfish-2013 · 2013
Chapter 5 of 8 · 2'58"
On the surface this is a nature lesson: orcas live in families, stay with their mothers, and each community keeps its own calls. Underneath it is a reversal of the old monster story. "What the public had was superstition and fear" gives way to brains, emotion, and a self that may be shared across the group.
Key moments
Start here, then watch the full scene- 0:02–0:50
When Killer Whales Were Pure Fear
49s - 1:03–1:48
❝ Monologue · 8 lines Each Family Keeps Its Own Calls
45s - 1:48–2:57
❝ Monologue · 6 lines A Self Spread Across the Group
69s
Orca Families Each Have a Language, explained
What happens
Someone recalls a time only 35 years earlier, when the public saw killer whales as vicious animals that would rip a person to shreds. The account then turns: orcas are described as friendly, with no record of a wild orca harming a human. Adult offspring never leave their mothers, each community has its own calls, and a brain scan is offered as evidence of intelligence and emotion.
What's really going on
The opening sells the old story: a "fight to the death" "between the two most dangerous animals on Earth," and killer whales with "48 sharp teeth that would rip you to shreds." Then the same telling empties that story out. Friendliness replaces the monster. There is "no record of an orca doing any harm to any human in the wild." What follows is not a list of cute facts. Families and the line "the adult offspring never leave their mother's side" put the social bond first. Separate calls, "with no overlap," let someone say you could call them languages, while science still hesitates to grant that word to any animal but humans. Intelligence "screams out" of the brain, a region lies beside the system that processes emotion, and "the safest inference" is a rich emotional life. Bonding has been "taken to another level," past other mammals, "including humans." The animals "stand by each other," and one suggestion goes further: the self is "distributed among" the group.
Key lines & what they mean
- “What the public had was superstition and fear.”
- The public image 35 years earlier was not knowledge at all, only superstition and fear of killer whales.
- “And to this day there is no record of an orca doing any harm to any human in the wild.”
- A flat claim that no wild orca is on record for harming a human. It answers the old monster picture and limits itself to the wild.
- “But the adult offspring never leave their mother's side.”
- Grown offspring stay beside the mother for life. In this account the orca family does not split when the young become adults.
- “The scientific community is reluctant to say any other animal but humans uses languages, but there's every indication that they use languages.”
- Science hesitates to call any nonhuman system a language, but someone says the evidence points that way for orca calls. Reluctance and indication sit in the same breath.
- “Everything about them is social-- everything.”
- Nothing here is treated as solitary. Family, calls, emotion, and even the sense of self are all framed as social.
- “It's been suggested that their whole sense of self is distributed among the individuals in their group.”
- A cautious suggestion, not a settled fact. The orca sense of self may be spread across the whole group rather than held inside one animal.
Theme
- Family love — Adult offspring never leave their mother's side, and the animals stand by each other even in mass strandings, so the family bond is the whole point of the account.
- Identity — Someone suggests the orca's sense of self is distributed among the group, which makes identity a shared thing rather than a private one.
What this chapter teaches
Teaching points
Review right after watchingMy level1/8
A1–C2 is the CEFR scale. Cards above the level you pick fade, and playback will not auto-pause on them.
Language points
Click a card to jump to its moment in the videoGolden lines
A great line in its own right — why and how to use it“And to this day there is no record of an orca doing any harm to any human in the wild.”
Why it's great
The time phrase and the stacked negatives leave no room for a single exception.
Register
Formal
Use it yourself
To this day nobody has found a single case of that bridge failing.
“But the adult offspring never leave their mother's side.”
Why it's great
Never makes the bond absolute, and mother's side turns it into a picture you can see.
Register
Neutral
Use it yourself
The older dog never leaves the child's side.
“The scientific community is reluctant to say any other animal but humans uses languages, but there's every indication that they use languages.”
Why it's great
It grants the official hesitation in full, then the second clause hands the same claim back.
Register
Formal
Use it yourself
The panel is reluctant to call the drug a cure, but every indication says patients improve.
“Everything about them is social-- everything.”
Why it's great
The repeated everything closes the point without adding a single new fact.
Register
literary
Use it yourself
Everything about this team is careful-- everything.
“It's been suggested that their whole sense of self is distributed among the individuals in their group.”
Why it's great
The passive lets a radical idea about the self arrive without a personal boast.
Register
Formal
Use it yourself
It's been suggested that the writer's guilt is shared by every character in the book.
Monologue
One character carrying the scene — shadow the whole passage❝ From families to languages
They live in these big families. And they have life spans very similar to human life spans. The females can live to about 100, maybe more, males to about 50 or 60. But the adult offspring never leave their mother's side. Each community has a completely different set of behaviors. Each has a complete repertoire of vocalizations with no overlap. You could call them languages. The scientific community is reluctant to say any other animal but humans uses languages, but there's every indication that they use languages.
Lifespan and staying close make the separate calls feel like languages, then the claim is risked and returned.
❝ A self shared by the group
The safest inference would be these are animals that have highly elaborated emotional lives. It's becoming clear that dolphins and whales have a sense of self, a sense of social bonding that they've taken to another level-- much stronger, much more complex than in other mammals, including humans. We look at mass strandings, the fact that they stand by each other. Everything about them is social-- everything. It's been suggested that their whole sense of self is distributed among the individuals in their group.
Emotion and not leaving each other end in a self that no single body holds.
Up next · 06making such a big dealThe scene: Supervisor Yells Get Her AwayPeople also search
Questions, then the linesWhy were killer whales once treated as monsters?
Someone says that if you go back only 35 years, "we knew nothing," in fact "less than nothing," and "what the public had was superstition and fear." The picture that follows is a fight to the death, and "vicious killer whales" with "48 sharp teeth that would rip you to shreds if they got a chance."
Does this scene claim a wild orca has ever harmed a human?
It claims the opposite. "And to this day there is no record of an orca doing any harm to any human in the wild." The line speaks only about the wild.
Do adult orcas leave their mothers?
This account says they do not. "The adult offspring never leave their mother's side." Females "can live to about 100, maybe more," males "to about 50 or 60," and the offspring still stay.
Are orca vocalizations really languages?
Someone says each community has "a complete repertoire of vocalizations with no overlap," and "you could call them languages." The scientific community is "reluctant to say any other animal but humans uses languages," but "there's every indication that they use languages." The lines give both the hesitation and the indication.
What is the brain scan used to argue?
Someone says "this tremendous brain" was put in a magnetic resonance imaging scanner, and the finding was "astounding": orcas have "a part of the brain that humans don't have," "extended out right adjacent to their limbic system," the system that "processes emotions." From that, "the safest inference" is that they "have highly elaborated emotional lives."