Witness for the Prosecution · 1957 — 第 6 / 27 章 · 4'01" · B2

Leonard Recounts the Night of the Murder, Explained:a hot potato

Leonard walks Sir Wilfrid through the night Mrs French died: he visited her at eight, left at nine, and walked home. The lawyer presses on money and motive, then warns that a loving wife's testimony does not count for much, because "Blood is thicker than evidence." What looked like a defence is slowly turning into a case.

あらすじ

Leonard tells Sir Wilfrid the story of the night Mrs French was killed: he went to her house about eight, listened to music with her, and left around nine. Sir Wilfrid questions him about money and about why he never brought his wife, then warns that Christine's testimony will not be worth much. Brogan-Moore joins the case.

InterrogationsPolice questioningExplainingConfrontingLawyer & clientB2fastbritishClean
IMDb ↗

注目の表現

in love with someoneget along with someonecarry weightblood is thicker than evidence

00:00 / 04:01
Space 再生 · ← → セリフ移動 · R リピート
いま
  1. ❝ 独白the no-motive argument8 行練習ページ ↗
セリフをタップするとそこから再生

このシーンの表現

a hot potato

a tricky problem nobody wants

Brogan-Moore sums up the case as circumstantial with no alibi, a hot potato for any lawyer.

The new tax plan is a political hot potato.

このシーンの他の表現

  • in love with someone

    be in love with someone

  • get along with someone

    have a good relationship

  • carry weight

    be taken seriously

  • blood is thicker than evidence

    a twist on a proverb about loyalty

  • sponging off

    living off someone's money

このシーンのメモ一覧

62 行のセリフに 24 件のメモ

表現 · A2go around to see someone

visit someone at their place

I went around to see her about eight o'clock.
発音went around

Link went and around so they run together.

I went around to see her about eight o'clock.
表現 · A2fix a sandwich

make a sandwich

She fixed a sandwich, we talked, listened to The Mikado.
表現 · A1half past (the hour)

thirty minutes past the hour

I left about nine. I walked home. I got there about half past.
発音half past

The h in half often drops, giving alf past.

I left about nine. I walked home. I got there about half past.
表現 · B1swear to something

vouch for something on oath

I can prove that. I can swear to it, in or out of court, in the witness box, anywhere!
文法 · B1I can swear to it

modal can: Can states what the speaker is able and willing to do here.

I can prove that. I can swear to it, in or out of court, in the witness box, anywhere!
表現 · A2be in love with someone

be in love with someone

Sir Wilfrid throws the line at Vole to tie his story to money and romance.

- Why should she give me any money? - Because she was in love with you.
表現 · B1get along with someone

have a good relationship

Vole says the widow believed his marriage was unhappy, which gave him a reason to hide his wife.

Because she was under the impression we didn't get along too well.
表現 · B1lose interest in someone

stop being interested

- You never corrected her. Why? - I was afraid she'd lose interest.
表現 · B2be after someone's money

want someone's money

Because she was rich, and you were after her money.
表現 · B1hope for a loan

want to borrow money

I was hoping for a loan for my new invention. Just a few hundred pounds.
表現 · A2someone's day off

a day away from work

You knew it was the housekeeper's day off?
表現 · B1as for something

as far as something is concerned

As for things looking bad, they don't look bad, Mr Vole, they look terrible.
表現 · B1no ... at all

none whatsoever

- Apparently you've no alibi at all. - But I have. I left Mrs French's at nine.
表現 · B2carry weight

be taken seriously

Sir Wilfrid warns Vole that a devoted wife's testimony will not be trusted by a jury.

You realise, Mr Vole, the testimony of a devoted wife does not carry much weight.
文法 · B2It has been known

present perfect passive: The passive present perfect says such things have happened before, without naming who saw them.

It has been known, Mr Vole. Blood is thicker than evidence.
表現 · B2a hot potato

a tricky problem nobody wants

Brogan-Moore sums up the case as circumstantial with no alibi, a hot potato for any lawyer.

A mass of circumstantial evidence. No alibi whatsoever. It's a hot potato.
発音It's a hot

It's a runs together as itsa; stress hot.

A mass of circumstantial evidence. No alibi whatsoever. It's a hot potato.
表現 · B1rule out something

exclude a possibility

You will agree that we can rule out a crime of passion, hm?
表現 · B2sponge off someone

living off someone's money

Sir Wilfrid poses a hypothetical: why would Vole kill the source of money he was living on?

If Mr Vole had been sponging off Mrs French, why cut off the source of supply?
文法 · C1had been sponging off

past perfect continuous: Had been doing marks an action continuing up to a past point, here inside a hypothetical.

If Mr Vole had been sponging off Mrs French, why cut off the source of supply?
表現 · B2a golden egg

an easy source of money here it means the money the widow might leave him

Or, if he'd been hoping for a golden egg, why kill the goose before it was laid?
表現 · B2as far as something goes

within its limits

- You find some flaw in this reasoning? - No, no, it's very sound as far as it goes.

「Leonard Recounts the Night of the Murder」を読み解く

What's really going on

Leonard keeps answering like a man with nothing to hide, which only makes the lawyer more careful. His alibi is real but useless — "I can prove that. I can swear to it, in or out of court, in the witness box, anywhere!" — because the only witness is his devoted wife, and Sir Wilfrid warns him that such testimony "does not carry much weight," adding, "Blood is thicker than evidence." The interview is really a rehearsal for court: every honest answer gives the prosecution another thread, from the money he hoped to borrow to the housekeeper's day off. Sir Wilfrid's summary of the case, "they don't look bad, Mr Vole, they look terrible," is the film's sharpest joke and its fairest warning. Leonard may be innocent, but the evidence does not need him to be guilty.

Theme

JusticeCircumstantial evidence and a weak alibi can make an innocent man look guilty, as Sir Wilfrid warns.
TrustLeonard's most reliable defence is his wife's word, which the lawyer says a jury will discount.

このチャプターで学べること

  • A tidy alibi can still leave a motive wide open.
  • The will turns sympathy into suspicion in one line.
  • Courtroom talk hides threats inside polite questions.
  • A twisted proverb can be a warning, not comfort.

発音のポイント

  • went around — Link went and around so they run together.
  • half past — The h in half often drops, giving alf past.
  • It's a hot — It's a runs together as itsa; stress hot.
As for things looking bad, they don't look bad, Mr Vole, they look terrible.

Sir Wilfrid's summary of Leonard's position: worse than bad, delivered dryly so the joke lands as a warning.

I can prove that. I can swear to it, in or out of court, in the witness box, anywhere!

Leonard's insistence that his alibi is real, which sounds convincing until you notice the only witness is his wife.

It has been known, Mr Vole. Blood is thicker than evidence.

Sir Wilfrid's twist on an old proverb: a devoted spouse may lie to protect you, so a jury will not trust the testimony.

Or, if he'd been hoping for a golden egg, why kill the goose before it was laid?

The defence argument Sir Wilfrid builds: a man hoping to profit would not kill the source of his money.

このシーンについての質問

Why does Sir Wilfrid doubt Leonard's alibi?

Leonard says he left Mrs French at nine, but no one saw him on the way home except Christine, his wife. The lawyer warns that a devoted wife's testimony carries little weight.

What does Sir Wilfrid ask Leonard about money?

He asks whether Mrs French gave Leonard money and whether he was after her money. Leonard admits he hoped for a loan for his invention, which gives the prosecution a possible motive.

Why is the case called a hot potato?

There is a mass of circumstantial evidence and no alibi, so it is awkward and dangerous to handle. Brogan-Moore says it is a hot potato as he hands it to Sir Wilfrid.

What is Sir Wilfrid's planned defence?

He argues there was no motive: if Leonard was sponging off Mrs French, killing her would cut off his supply, just as killing the goose destroys the golden egg.

情婦 · 全 27 章

すべて見る →
次のチャプター · 第 7 章with flying coloursInspector Hearne Arrests Leonard
第 1 章put it in mothballsSir Wilfrid Goes Home第 2 章when her back is turnedSir Wilfrid Hides Cigars in His Cane第 3 章circumstantial evidenceVole Tries to Hire Sir Wilfrid第 4 章in the hands ofLeonard Tells Sir Wilfrid His Story第 5 章not cricketHow Vole Met Mrs French再生中 · 第 6 章a hot potatoLeonard Recounts the Night of the Murder第 7 章with flying coloursInspector Hearne Arrests Leonard第 8 章call it what you likeChristine Vole Meets the Lawyers第 9 章a way with womenChristine and the Green Socks第 10 章worships the ground I walk onChristine Denies She's His Wife第 11 章on the chance thatWilfrid Photographs Vole in Prison第 12 章gave someone ideasLeonard Meets Christine in Hamburg第 13 章clutching at a razor bladeVole Tells How He Married Christine第 14 章to a pointLeonard Vole Pleads Not Guilty第 15 章take someone by surpriseHearne Testifies About the Prints第 16 章account forThe Bloodstained Jacket in Court第 17 章hither and thitherJanet McKenzie Takes the Stand第 18 章a scheming rascalWilfrid Cross-Examines the Housekeeper第 19 章an accomplice toChristine Testifies Against Vole第 20 章a chronic and habitual liarMyers Destroys Christine on the Stand第 21 章shed new light onSir Wilfrid Calls Leonard Vole第 22 章establish an alibiMyers Cross-Examines Leonard Vole第 23 章wild-goose chaseThe Call About the German Wife第 24 章on the slySir Wilfrid Buys the Letters第 25 章a pack of liesSir Wilfrid's Blue Letter Trap第 26 章dispose ofVole Is Found Not Guilty第 27 章call someone namesChristine Reveals Leonard Was Guilty
第 6 / 27 章 · 残り約 72 分