A Night to Remember · 1958 — 第 7 / 14 章 · 2'58" · B2

Andrews: She's Going to Sink, Explained:a mathematical certainty

Andrews lays out the damage on the bridge: five compartments are flooding below the waterline and the pumps cannot keep up. "She's going to sink, Captain," he says, and the reply — "She's unsinkable" — is answered flatly with "She can't float." From there it is arithmetic: the ship has an hour and a half.

あらすじ

After the collision, Andrews is called to the bridge and reports the damage: the forepeak, holds one and two, the mail room and boiler rooms five and six are flooding, a gash 300 feet long below the waterline. He tells Captain Smith plainly that the ship will sink, and works out that she has about an hour and a half left.

MeetingsExplainingWarningCoworkersB2mediumbritishClean
IMDb ↗

注目の表現

blow off steamgive someone a handturn backcan't float

00:00 / 02:58
Space 再生 · ← → セリフ移動 · R リピート
いま
  1. ❝ 独白Andrews Reads the Damage24 行練習ページ ↗
セリフをタップするとそこから再生

このシーンの表現

a mathematical certainty

something certain to happen

Andrews closes his calculation with a verdict no one can dispute.

With three players injured, a defeat was a mathematical certainty.

このシーンの他の表現

  • blow off steam

    release pressure

  • give someone a hand

    help someone

  • turn back

    go back the way you came

  • can't float

    unable to stay on water

  • watertight compartments

    sealed sections of a ship

このシーンのメモ一覧

59 行のセリフに 23 件のメモ

表現 · A2as soon as you can

as fast as possible

Chief, I'd get those men up as soon as you can.
発音get those men up

The t in get is often dropped before those.

Chief, I'd get those men up as soon as you can.
発音What have we

Blend what have into one sound when listening.

- What have we stopped for? - There's talk of an iceberg, ma'am.
表現 · B1so as not to do something

in order to avoid

I expect we've stopped so as not to run over anything.
スラング · A2What's up

what's happening — Casual; for friends or when something seems off.

What's up?
表現 · B1blow off steam

release pressure

A crew member explains the stopped ship to a worried passenger.

Oh, we're stopped and blowing off steam. Something's wrong. I don't know what.
スラング · B1Bumped

hit lightly — Casual way to say something hit another thing.

Bumped a bit of ice, I think.
表現 · A2give someone a hand

help someone

A sleepless passenger offers the operator some help.

Well, I can't sleep with this racket going on. Do you want me to give you a hand?
発音give you a

Give you often runs together as a single sound.

Well, I can't sleep with this racket going on. Do you want me to give you a hand?
スラング · B1racket

loud noise — Informal; means ongoing loud noise.

Well, I can't sleep with this racket going on. Do you want me to give you a hand?
表現 · A2turn back

go back the way you came

A passenger asks whether the ship will have to turn around.

- Do you think we'll have to turn back? - Oh, don't say it.
文法 · B1If we do

conditional clause: If we do stands in for the action just mentioned.

If we do, we won't get a moment's peace in here.
文法 · B2with any three of her first five watertight compartments flooded

with phrase: The with-phrase sets the condition under which she could float.

She could float with any three of her first five watertight compartments flooded.
表現 · B1with something gone

with something missing

She could even float with four of them gone.
表現 · B1go as high as something

reach up to

- But she can't float with all five full up. - Yes, but - These watertight bulkheads here only go as high as E Deck.
文法 · B2as high as E Deck

as-as comparison: As high as marks the upper limit the bulkheads reach.

- But she can't float with all five full up. - Yes, but - These watertight bulkheads here only go as high as E Deck.
表現 · B2a mathematical certainty

something certain to happen

Andrews closes his calculation with a verdict no one can dispute.

It's a mathematical certainty.
表現 · B1stay afloat

keep from sinking

With that amount of underwater damage, she can't stay afloat.
表現 · B1work something out

calculate or figure out

Andrews says he is still calculating how long the ship will last.

Just trying to work that out now.
表現 · A2an hour and a half

ninety minutes

another hour and a half.
表現 · B1there must be no something

absolutely no

There must be no panic.
表現 · B1be careful what you say

choose your words

You'll be careful what you say to the passengers?
表現 · A2room for something

space available

And room in the boats for...

「Andrews: She's Going to Sink」を読み解く

What's really going on

The scene turns a rumour into arithmetic. Until now the passengers have only guesses — "Bumped a bit of ice, I think" — but on the bridge Andrews gives the cold sum: five compartments flooding, water that will spill over the tops of the bulkheads one after another. "She's going to sink, Captain," he says, and when someone insists "She's unsinkable," the correction is blunt: "She can't float." What unsettles the men is not panic but inevitability; Andrews calls it "a mathematical certainty." The last exchange is the real horror: twenty-two hundred people on board, and room in the boats for twelve hundred. Smith's order, "There must be no panic," is voiced as discipline, yet it also means the truth will be kept from most of the ship.

Theme

DutyAndrews and Smith face the numbers calmly and plan for the boats, even as the ship is doomed.
SurvivalThe arithmetic of the sinking and the shortage of lifeboat space decide who can live.

このチャプターで学べること

  • A calm number can end an argument faster than an opinion.
  • Calling it mathematics removes doubt and any hope.
  • An order in a crisis names the real priority.
  • The unsinkable claim dies in a single four-word reply.

発音のポイント

  • get those men up — The t in get is often dropped before those.
  • What have we — Blend what have into one sound when listening.
  • give you a — Give you often runs together as a single sound.
- She's unsinkable. - She can't float.

The film's central irony in one exchange: the boast that the ship cannot sink meets the engineer's flat answer that she simply will not float.

With that amount of underwater damage, she can't stay afloat.

Andrews rules out hope: the length of the gash means the flooding cannot be stopped and the ship cannot be kept up.

There must be no panic.

Smith's first order once he understands the scale of it: whatever happens, the crew must keep the passengers calm.

She's going to sink, Captain.

The moment the sinking stops being a possibility and becomes a fact delivered to the man in command.

このシーンについての質問

Why does Andrews say the Titanic must sink?

Water is flooding five compartments, more than the ship can survive. With the bulkheads only reaching E Deck, water spills from one compartment into the next and pulls the bow down — which Andrews calls a mathematical certainty.

Why do some people still think the ship is unsinkable?

It had been promoted as practically unsinkable, and the watertight-compartment design sounded foolproof. Andrews corrects that belief: she can float with four compartments flooded, but not with all five.

How long does Andrews think the ship has left?

About an hour and a half. He works it out from the amount of water taken on in the first ten minutes after the collision.

Why is the lifeboat capacity a problem?

There are twenty-two hundred or more people on board, but the boats have room for only about twelve hundred. The Board of Trade regulations never imagined a situation like this.

SOSタイタニック/忘れえぬ夜 · 全 14 章

すべて見る →
第 7 / 14 章 · 残り約 24 分