Capítulo 17 de 30 · 3'24"
At a front-line command post, officers navigate the dark, deal with a broken telephone line, and receive a batch of Ulan prisoners taken from the river with a hundred pounds of dynamite. The talk turns to whether the Germans are starting to fight foul, and someone offers to carry the men's letters home.
Van Zijl Loots Umbrellas
Letters Home Before the Fighting
❝ Monólogo · 4 frases Fighting Foul Is a Sign of Weakness
On the Western Front, officers lose their way in the dark until Murdoch's nose finds the road. At the command post, the telephone line is down, prisoners are brought in, and the men debate whether the Germans are beginning to fight foul. Candy argues that cheating is a sure sign of weakness, and offers to take the soldiers' letters home.
The scene is a war chapter that behaves like a conversation in a club. Men who could die at any moment talk about roads, looted umbrellas, and a leave train; the prisoners are discussed as a curiosity. The moral argument is the film's real subject: "Nobody starts to fight foul till he sees he can't win any other way," which is both a shrewd observation and a comfort to officers who believe their enemy still observes the rules. The joke about Hindenburg's 'arms with honour' — "I admit he said nothing about her legs!" — turns the idea of fair play into a pun, and shows how easily honour talk slides into wit. Even the offer to carry letters home keeps the tone light while naming the danger everyone is living with.
A1–C2 es la escala MCER. Las tarjetas por encima del nivel elegido se atenúan y la reproducción no se pausa en ellas.
“Nobody starts to fight foul till he sees he can't win any other way.”
It compresses a whole theory of cheating into one line: foul play is what losing looks like.
Neutral
“I admit he said nothing about her legs!”
After quoting a noble claim, it snaps the sentence back to the body, and the dignity collapses.
Informal
“I had a boom across, and netted them like salmon.”
It turns a military capture into a fisherman's catch, which makes the boast sound casual and complete.
Informal
“I know it at night, sir. In the daytime it looks different.”
Two short halves set night knowledge against daylight strangeness, and the calm tone carries a soldier's worn familiarity with war.
Neutral
“The Germans know how to make them talk.”
The line states torture as a matter of fact, and the absence of any adjective makes it colder than a graphic description.
Neutral
“If any of you have any important letters or messages home, I'll take them.”
A quiet offer to carry letters home before the fighting, turning an officer's courtesy into one of the tenderest lines in the film.
Neutral
Well, if they are, they're cracking, my dear chap. It's a sure sign. Nobody starts to fight foul till he sees he can't win any other way. I quite believe Hindenburg, who I heard said the other day that until now, Germany has used her arms with honour. I admit he said nothing about her legs!
Siguiente · 18play deafLa escena: The Brigadier Interrogates PrisonersThe telephone line is down between the command post and Mile 14, so a runner has to be sent instead with the message about holding a place on the leave train.
They were floating down the river early in the morning, and the officer had a boom stretched across the water, so they were netted like salmon. They had a hundred pounds of dynamite with them.
Blowing up the new pontoon bridge below St Mangy. The question of how they knew about it leads to the darker suggestion that a captured British patrol talked.
Someone reports Hindenburg saying Germany had used "her arms with honour," and Candy answers with the joke about her legs. His real point is that fighting foul is a sign the enemy is losing.
Because he is about to leave. By offering to take any important letters or messages, he turns an ordinary errand into a last favour, and quietly admits that some of them may not come back.
