Vicky Cristina Barcelona · 2008 — Chapter 5 of 7 · 4'15" · B2

Maria Elena Moves In, Explained: come to nothing

A woman is introduced upstairs, then told she will stay because she has nowhere else to go. The surface question is where she stays and for how long; underneath, "a few months at most" is less a reassurance than a limit.

What happens

Upstairs, Maria Elena is introduced to Cristina. It emerges that her plans collapsed, she overdosed at the bus terminal, and she now needs to stay because she has no money and no one to care for her. The conversation turns to how long she will stay.

ArgumentsPersuasionExplainingPersuadingB2slowamerican
IMDb ↗

Listen for

come to nothingcapable of caring for herbe trusted to stay aloneat most

00:00 / 04:15
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
  1. ❝ MonologueThe salt metaphor speech10 linesPractice page ↗
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

come to nothing

fail completely; amount to nothing

Someone explains that all her plans had come to nothing before describing the overdose at the bus terminal.

All our careful plans can come to nothing overnight.

Also in this scene

  • capable of caring for her

    able to look after her

  • be trusted to stay alone

    can be safely left alone

  • at most

    no more than

  • been through this with her

    have experienced this with her

  • Shit

    damn it

Everything marked in this scene

24 notes across 63 lines

Phrase · B1
feel + adjective

be embarrassed

Oh, no... Please, don't feel embarrassed.
Phrase · A2
anything at all

any little thing

Can I get you anything at all?
Sound
get you

In fast speech 'get you' can blur together; keep the ending slightly rising to sound like an offer.

Can I get you anything at all?
Sound
you have to

In the rush of the sentence, 'have to' is usually squeezed; let 'to' almost disappear.

Maria Elena, when you are here, you have to speak English, all right?
Phrase · A2
what's going on

what is happening

- So... what's going on? - Nothing.
Phrase · B1
things work out for someone

things did not go well for her

Things didn't work out for her in Madrid, and... she came bus...
Phrase · B2
something comes to nothing

fail completely; amount to nothing

Someone explains that all her plans had come to nothing before describing the overdose at the bus terminal.

Her whole world looked black and all her plans had come to nothing, and she overdosed in the bus terminal.
Phrase · B2
be capable of doing something

able to look after her

Someone explains why she must stay: she has no money and no one capable of caring for her.

I mean, she has no money, she has no one capable of caring for her...
Grammar · B2
no one capable of caring for her

postmodifier phrase: The adjective phrase after 'no one' specifies what kind of person is missing: anyone able to care for her.

I mean, she has no money, she has no one capable of caring for her...
Phrase · B2
someone's connection to something

link to ordinary reality

I was always her connection to the real life.
Phrase · B2
be trusted to do something

can be safely left alone

Someone states the problem plainly: she cannot be trusted to stay alone, so she needs company.

I think that she can't be trusted to stay alone, that's the problem.
Phrase · B2
need psychiatric help

professional mental health care

Well, maybe she needs psychiatric help.
Phrase · B1
have bad experiences with someone

had bad experiences with doctors

No, she's always had bad experiences with doctors.
Grammar · B1
what you had in mind

what-clause: The clause names the plan the other person expected; 'what' is the object of 'had in mind'.

- this is not what you had in mind. - No... I understand.
Phrase · B1
X at most

no more than

When asked how long the stay will be, someone says a short time and then caps it at a few months at most.

Yes, a few months at most.
Sound
months at most

Put the beat on 'most' and glide through 'months at' so the limit lands.

Yes, a few months at most.
Phrase · B2
be through something with someone

have experienced this with her

Someone warns that this has happened before, using the line to show experience and a little fatigue.

Listen, I've been through this with her before.
Slang · B1
Shit

damn it — Blurt it among friends; avoid it in formal or professional settings.

Shit.
Grammar · B2
If you had only known her

unreal condition: The past unreal condition stands alone, so the missing main clause becomes an unspoken regret.

If you had only known her when I first met her.
Phrase · B2
take someone's breath away

was breathtakingly beautiful

- Her beauty took your breath away. - Yes, I...
Phrase · B2
ready to kill for someone

willing to do anything for her A hyperbolic way to say men were desperate for her.

she was so sensual, and she chose me from a hundred men ready to kill for her.
Phrase · B2
there is something missing

a gap that is hard to name

Someone recalls believing the relationship was perfect while sensing that something was missing.

We were both sure that our relation was perfect, but there was something missing, you know?
Phrase · B2
out of courtesy

as a polite gesture

Yes, exactly, out of courtesy.
Phrase · B2
have paranoid ideas about someone

unfounded suspicious thoughts

Someone pushes back, accusing the other of having paranoid ideas about every woman he has known.

You always had paranoid ideas about every woman I've ever known.

Maria Elena Moves In, explained

What's really going on

The scene keeps circling the same practical question — where she will stay, how long she will stay — because the emotional answer has already been decided. "She has to stay with us" is repeated as a fact, while "a few months at most" tries to put a limit on it. The story about the bus terminal and the overdose makes refusal sound cruel, but the repeated questions keep the arrangement from sounding settled. The image of a perfect relationship missing one ingredient, "like salt," shifts the conversation from hospitality to desire and need: what looks complete may still lack something essential.

Theme

TrustThe talk keeps returning to whether she can be trusted alone and whether the household can take her in.
RomanceA speech about a perfect relationship missing "like salt" reveals longing beneath the practical arrangement.

Listen for

  • get you — In fast speech 'get you' can blur together; keep the ending slightly rising to sound like an offer.
  • you have to — In the rush of the sentence, 'have to' is usually squeezed; let 'to' almost disappear.
  • months at most — Put the beat on 'most' and glide through 'months at' so the limit lands.
Her whole world looked black and all her plans had come to nothing, and she overdosed in the bus terminal.

Everything she had planned had failed, leaving her hopeless, and she took an overdose at the bus station. It explains why she needs a place to stay.

If you had only known her when I first met her.

A way of saying her present condition is far from what she once was; the speaker remembers an earlier, more dazzling version of her.

We were both sure that our relation was perfect, but there was something missing, you know?

Even a relationship both people believed was perfect lacked one crucial element — like a body missing salt.

She's the woman I live with, and you have to speak English around here, please.

A request that English be used in the house out of courtesy to the woman who lives there.

Questions about this scene

Why does Maria Elena need to stay with them?

She has no money, no one capable of caring for her, and she is not trusted to stay alone; the line about her plans coming to nothing and the overdose explain the urgency.

Why does someone keep asking how long she will stay?

The answer only offers "a few months at most," a limit rather than a fixed date, so the question of how long she will stay remains open.

What does the salt comparison mean?

It argues that a relationship can seem perfect and still fail because one small, essential element is absent; salt stands for that tiny missing ingredient.

Why does someone insist on speaking English?

The request is tied to courtesy: "She's the woman I live with, and you have to speak English around here, please," and the next line calls it "out of courtesy."

Vicky Cristina Barcelona · 7 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 5 of 7 · about 5 min to go