Garden State · 2004 — Chapter 2 of 11 · 2'59" · B2

Andrew Questions His Meds, Explained: in no position to comment on

An appointment about headaches and lithium turns into a debate about medication itself. One line says, "I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not," and the doctor's careful boundary leaves the decision with the patient.

What happens

At a doctor's office, Andrew describes brief, electric headaches and says he has stopped taking his medication. The doctor asks about lithium and other drugs, learns his psychiatrist is his father, and declines to judge whether he should stay on meds. He recommends a different psychiatrist and therapy.

At the doctorExplainingSuggestingDoctor & patientB2fastamericanClean
IMDb ↗

Listen for

a surge of electricityas far back as I can rememberwrite you a prescriptionit's amazing you can even hear me now

00:00 / 02:59
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
  1. ❝ MonologueThe Doctor's Two Warnings5 linesPractice page ↗
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

in no position to comment on

not qualified to comment on

The doctor draws a professional line, admitting he lacks the full history to judge the medication choice.

I'm in no position to comment on your family decision.

Also in this scene

  • a surge of electricity

    a sudden electric-like rush

  • as far back as I can remember

    for as long as I can remember

  • write you a prescription

    write a prescription for you

  • it's amazing you can even hear me now

    sarcastic: surprising that you can still hear me

  • know better

    should know not to do it

Everything marked in this scene

31 notes across 42 lines

Slang · A2
Just kidding

only joking — Use it with friends in casual talk, not in formal situations.

Just kidding. How would I know that?
Sound
What can we

Say 'what can we' as one quick unit, with 'can' reduced.

What can we do for you today, Andrew?
Phrase · B1
get really intense headaches

keep getting severe headaches

I've been getting these really intense headaches.
Phrase · B1
a split second

an extremely short moment

Um, they last for, like, a split second.
Sound
for, like, a

Let 'for, like, a' blur; land on 'split second'.

Um, they last for, like, a split second.
Phrase · B2
a surge of + noun

a sudden electric-like rush

The patient searches for words to describe a split-second headache as lightning and an electric rush.

It's like lightening. It's like a surge of electricity, and then it's gone.
Phrase · B1
some form of something

some version of the same drug Here 'it' means lithium or similar meds.

Um, I've been on some form of it since I was ten or so.
Phrase · B2
as far back as I can remember

for as long as I can remember

The patient admits he cannot know his baseline because medication has covered his memory for years.

Only, I'd never know it, because as far back as I can remember, I've been medicated. I left them in L.A., though.
Grammar · B2
as far back as I can remember

time clause: It marks how far back the memory reaches, here to childhood.

Only, I'd never know it, because as far back as I can remember, I've been medicated. I left them in L.A., though.
Phrase · B1
leave someone's body

clear out of your system

Well, that stuff will leave your body pretty fast. I could write you a prescription.
Phrase · B1
write someone a prescription

write a prescription for you

The doctor offers a quick practical fix, writing a prescription if the patient wants it.

Well, that stuff will leave your body pretty fast. I could write you a prescription.
Phrase · A2
take a vacation

a break, here from medication Here it means a break from medication, not a trip.

Actually, I was thinking about taking a vacation.
Phrase · B1
stay on something

keep taking that medication Here 'it' means the lithium or other meds.

Yeah, so I think he'd prefer me to stay on it.
Phrase · B2
be consumed with + emotion

overwhelmed by stress and anxiety Here 'consumed' means overwhelmed, not eaten.

You know, our bodies are capable of doing some very funny things when they're consumed with stress and anxiety.
Slang · B2
ex-best friend

former best friend — Casual and emotionally loaded; formal writing would say 'former best friend'.

I found my ex-best friend's cufflinks in my wife's purse.
Phrase · B2
have someone on + medication

kept you on a medication The medication after 'on' is understood from context.

Well, with all the lithium he's had you on, it's amazing you can even hear me now.
Sound
had you on

Link 'had you on' as one chunk; keep 'you' light.

Well, with all the lithium he's had you on, it's amazing you can even hear me now.
Grammar · B2
a psychiatrist that isn't your father

relative clause: The relative clause limits which psychiatrist he should find.

Look, Andrew, first of all, I think you do need to find a psychiatrist that isn't your father.
Phrase · B2
should have been + past participle

should have been fixed long ago

That's something that should have been remedied years ago. He knows better!
Phrase · B2
know better

should know not to do it

The doctor says the father should have known better, making a professional boundary sound like a blunt accusation.

That's something that should have been remedied years ago. He knows better!
Phrase · C1
be in no position to do something

not qualified to comment on

The doctor draws a professional line, admitting he lacks the full history to judge the medication choice.

And secondly... I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not, 'cause I don't know your story.
Phrase · B2
know someone's story

know someone's history Here 'story' means medical history and life experience.

And secondly... I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not, 'cause I don't know your story.
Grammar · C1
whether you should stay on the meds or not

whether clause: The whether-clause is the object of 'comment on' and means 'if or not'.

And secondly... I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not, 'cause I don't know your story.
Slang · B1
meds

medication — Everyday speech; use 'medication' in formal writing.

And secondly... I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not, 'cause I don't know your story.
Phrase · B1
since someone is paying for it

since you are paying for it

But my opinion , since you're paying for it, is that yeah, those drugs may help you as a means to an end.
Phrase · C1
as a means to an end

a way to reach a goal

The doctor frames medication as a practical tool, not a cure, while keeping a dry, professional distance.

But my opinion , since you're paying for it, is that yeah, those drugs may help you as a means to an end.
Phrase · B1
sooner or later

eventually

But sooner or later, if you're not in therapy, whatever's going on in your mind will find a way to peek its head out of the water.
Phrase · B1
find a way to do something

manage to do something eventually

But sooner or later, if you're not in therapy, whatever's going on in your mind will find a way to peek its head out of the water.
Grammar · C1
whatever's going on in your mind

subject clause: The whatever-clause is the subject of 'will find'.

But sooner or later, if you're not in therapy, whatever's going on in your mind will find a way to peek its head out of the water.
Sound
sooner or later

Stress 'soon' and 'late'; let 'or' almost disappear.

But sooner or later, if you're not in therapy, whatever's going on in your mind will find a way to peek its head out of the water.
Phrase · A2
take something off

remove something you are wearing

I'll need you to take your shoes off. I have to scratch your feet.

Andrew Questions His Meds, explained

What's really going on

The scene keeps moving between medical vocabulary and a more personal question: whether years of medication have made it impossible to know what is actually wrong. One description of the headaches — "a surge of electricity, and then it's gone" — sounds like a brief interruption in an otherwise managed life. The admission that "as far back as I can remember, I've been medicated" gives the appointment a different weight. The reply "I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not" is careful rather than cold: it sets a limit on what a doctor who does not know the patient's story can decide. The suggestion that the patient find a psychiatrist who is not his father makes the family arrangement itself part of the problem.

Theme

IdentityThe patient wonders whether he has a problem at all; years of medication make that question impossible to answer.
Family conflictThe revelation that his psychiatrist is his father turns treatment into a family arrangement the doctor questions.

Listen for

  • What can we — Say 'what can we' as one quick unit, with 'can' reduced.
  • for, like, a — Let 'for, like, a' blur; land on 'split second'.
  • had you on — Link 'had you on' as one chunk; keep 'you' light.
  • sooner or later — Stress 'soon' and 'late'; let 'or' almost disappear.
It's recently occurred to me I might not even have a problem.

He has begun to suspect that the condition treated for years may not exist, but he cannot verify it because he has been medicated for so long.

This is the first time I haven't had medicine in my body for a long time.

Stopping the medication has given him an unfamiliar baseline; he is noticing what his body feels like without drugs.

And secondly... I'm in no position to comment on whether you should stay on the meds or not, 'cause I don't know your story.

The doctor refuses to make the medication decision for him, citing the limits of what an outsider knows.

But sooner or later, if you're not in therapy, whatever's going on in your mind will find a way to peek its head out of the water.

Medication may manage symptoms, but without therapy the underlying issues will eventually surface.

Yeah, you're all right. You're alive.

The line turns a routine check-in into blunt reassurance: he is all right and alive, and the exam can proceed.

Questions about this scene

Why doesn't the doctor tell Andrew whether to stay on his meds?

He says he is "in no position to comment" because he doesn't know Andrew's story; the decision is left to the patient.

Why does the doctor object to Andrew's psychiatrist being his father?

He says that arrangement "should have been remedied years ago" and adds that the father "knows better."

What do Andrew's headaches feel like?

He describes them as lasting "a split second" and feeling like "a surge of electricity, and then it's gone."

Why does the doctor bring up therapy if he won't comment on the medication?

He says the drugs may help "as a means to an end," but without therapy whatever is on the patient's mind will eventually "peek its head out of the water."

Garden State · 11 chapters

All chapters →
Chapter 2 of 11 · about 29 min to go