5 to 7 · 2014 — Chapter 10 of 10 · 3'26" · B2

Arielle's Farewell Letter, Explained: the salt of the Earth

Arielle's farewell is a letter, not a conversation. She tells her history - a career that began at eleven and was ending by twenty-five, a marriage built on affection and respect rather than passion - and admits she never believed in love until Brian. But she will not leave her children, so she says goodbye and asks him not to contact her.

What happens

Arielle's goodbye comes as a letter. She confesses that she started working at eleven, felt her career ending by twenty-five, and married Valery for affection and respect rather than passion, never believing in love. Then Brian arrived, bringing a happiness that came out of nowhere. But she cannot abandon her children, so she ends the affair and asks him not to contact her.

BreakupsGoodbyes & funeralsConfessingExplainingCoupleB2slowamericanClean
IMDb ↗

Listen for

the salt of the Earthan error of youtha secret doorcome out of nowhere

00:00 / 03:26
Space play · ← → lines · R repeat
Now
  1. ❝ MonologueArielle's farewell monologue45 linesPractice page ↗
Tap a line to replay it

Phrase of the scene

the salt of the Earth

a thoroughly good person

Arielle calls Valery the salt of the Earth, meaning he is solid and genuinely good.

He is the salt of the Earth.

Also in this scene

  • an error of youth

    a mistake of being young

  • a secret door

    a hidden opening inside

  • come out of nowhere

    appeared suddenly

  • keep a promise

    honor a promise

  • unthinkable

    too awful to consider

Everything marked in this scene

24 notes across 45 lines

Phrase · C1
an error of youth

a mistake of being young

Arielle calls her rushed marriage an error of youth, a way of forgiving her younger self.

And so I made an error of youth.
Phrase · A2
fall in love

become smitten

They had fallen in love, but not me. Not once.
Phrase · A2
all over the world

everywhere on earth

Even though I had been all over the world and I had met everyone.
Grammar · B2
Even though I had been all over the world

concessive clause: Even though concedes a fact, and the past perfect places it before the turning point.

Even though I had been all over the world and I had met everyone.
Phrase · B1
be introduced to someone

be made known to

That spring, I was introduced to Valery.
Phrase · C1
the salt of the Earth

a thoroughly good person

Arielle calls Valery the salt of the Earth, meaning he is solid and genuinely good.

"The salt of the Earth," as Americans like to say.
Sound
salt of the

Link salt of the together, with of reduced to a light uh.

"The salt of the Earth," as Americans like to say.
Phrase · B2
feel affection for someone

a warm fondness for

I felt a great affection for him.
Phrase · A2
a kind of love

one form of love

That is a kind of love.
Phrase · B1
believe in something

trust that love is real

I didn't believe in love.
Phrase · B2
come out of nowhere

appeared suddenly

She says the happiness stunned her because it came out of nowhere.

It has stunned me, this new happiness which came out of nowhere.
Sound
out of nowhere

Run out of together, almost 'oudda-nowhere'.

It has stunned me, this new happiness which came out of nowhere.
Phrase · B2
never felt so alive

more alive than ever

I have never felt so alive...
Phrase · B1
forget about everything

drop all your worries

It is tempting, so tempting to forget about everything and just accept this gift.
Sound
forget about

Link forget and about into 'forge-da-bout'.

It is tempting, so tempting to forget about everything and just accept this gift.
Phrase · B2
write one's own vows

compose personal vows

When Valery and I married, we wrote our own vows.
Phrase · C1
a matter of honor

an issue of principle

She says keeping her vow is more than a matter of honor, raising it above pride.

But it's more than a matter of honor.
Phrase · B2
to do X is to do Y

X equals Y

One day, Brian, when you have children you'll understand that to leave them is to leave yourself.
Grammar · B2
to leave them is to leave yourself

infinitive subject: Two infinitives sit as subject and complement, making an emotional claim look like an equation.

One day, Brian, when you have children you'll understand that to leave them is to leave yourself.
Phrase · B1
try to contact someone

attempt to reach me

Please do not try to contact me.
Phrase · B2
sad to say goodbye

sorry to part

I am so sad to say goodbye.
Phrase · A2
ahead of someone

still to come for us

We had so many adventures still ahead of us.
Grammar · C1
if we had had more time

past unreal conditional: Had had marks a past condition that never happened, so the result takes would have found.

Maybe... if we had had more time I would have found something about you I didn't like, really couldn't stand which would be very useful right now.
Phrase · B2
no X is perfect

all love has flaws

They say that no love is perfect.

Arielle's Farewell Letter, explained

What's really going on

The farewell is written rather than spoken, which lets Arielle explain herself without a fight. She builds the case for her marriage slowly: she was a child worker, a model who aged out early, and she settled for a love of affection and respect - "That is a kind of love" - without ever believing in the romantic kind. Brian, then, is the exception she did not expect, the happiness that "came out of nowhere." The refusal is not a rejection of him but a limit she will not cross: "to leave them is to leave yourself." The letter ends with a compliment and a wound at once - she wishes she could find a fault in him, and says no love is perfect, but they never met him.

Theme

HeartbreakArielle ends the affair with a careful letter, explaining why she must lose Brian rather than lose her children.
MarriageHer marriage is framed as a promise kept out of honor and love of family, not romantic passion.

What you'll learn

  • To leave them is to leave yourself frames love as an equation.
  • The salt of the Earth praises plain goodness, not excitement.
  • She never believed in love until it was too late to act on it.
  • The closing proverb is quietly overturned by the next line.

Listen for

  • salt of the — Link salt of the together, with of reduced to a light uh.
  • out of nowhere — Run out of together, almost 'oudda-nowhere'.
  • forget about — Link forget and about into 'forge-da-bout'.
One day, Brian, when you have children you'll understand that to leave them is to leave yourself.

Arielle's reason for ending the affair: abandoning her children would mean abandoning part of herself, a lesson she knows Brian cannot yet feel.

Maybe... if we had had more time I would have found something about you I didn't like, really couldn't stand which would be very useful right now.

A wry wish for a flaw in Brian that would make leaving easier - and an admission that she cannot find one.

They say that no love is perfect.

The opening of her final line, setting up the compliment that she has never met anyone like him.

That is a kind of love.

Her description of what she feels for Valery - affection and respect rather than passion - which she once mistook for the only love she would know.

Questions about this scene

Why does Arielle end the affair?

She will not leave her children, and leaving them would mean leaving part of herself. The farewell letter explains that the limit is not Brian but her duty to her family.

Did Arielle love Valery?

She says she felt great affection and respect for him and calls that a kind of love, but she admits she never believed in romantic love. Valery was solid and good rather than a passion.

Why does Arielle say she cannot accept the happiness?

She calls it tempting to forget everything and simply take the gift, but she will not abandon her children for it. The love is real, yet it cannot be allowed to displace her family.

Why does she ask Brian not to contact her?

Because she has decided and does not want the decision undone. Contact would only reopen something she has chosen to close for her children's sake.

What does the salt of the Earth mean here?

It means a thoroughly good, dependable person. Arielle uses the American phrase to describe Valery's solid, honest character.

5 to 7 · 10 chapters

All chapters →
That's all 10 chapters of this film