00:00 / 02:58
00:00 / 02:58

Tony Meets Alice's Family, Explained

Tony Kirby arrives at the Sycamore house to meet Alice's family and walks straight into chaos: an income-tax collector is threatening Grandpa Vanderhof with jail, and Grandpa insists he does not owe a cent. Later the ballet teacher Kolenkhov drops in and calls the Monte Carlo Ballet garbage — "It stinks."

Family dinnersArgumentsThreateningWarningStrangersB2mediumamericanClean

Key moments

Start here, then watch the full scene
  1. ❝ Monólogo · 6 frases Grandpa vs the Tax Man

    0:14–1:34
    81s
  2. Kolenkhov Drops By

    2:09–2:57
    47s
  1. ❝ MonólogoThe collector's warning6 frasesPracticar ↗

Tony Meets Alice's Family, explained

What happens

Tony Kirby comes to the Sycamore house to meet Alice's eccentric family. He finds Grandpa Vanderhof arguing with an income-tax man who threatens him with jail, and refusing to pay more than $75. Not long after, the ballet teacher Kolenkhov arrives and bluntly tells the family that the show they are off to see is terrible.

What's really going on

The comedy comes from a collision of worlds. Tony, a rich man's son, steps into a house where nobody obeys rules, and the first thing he hears is Grandpa refusing to pay taxes: "I don't owe the government a cent." The tax man threatens, "You'll go to jail if you don't pay," and Grandpa treats the whole thing as a game. Against this, Tony's good manners and Kolenkhov's theatrical rudeness — "The Monte Carlo Ballet? It stinks" — show how casually this family speaks its mind. Tony is not there to judge, though; he is there because he loves Alice, and the scene lets him see, in one evening, exactly what he would be marrying into.

Key lines & what they mean

“If you think you're bigger than the law, you've got another thing coming.”
The tax collector's warning to Grandpa: thinking he is above the law is a mistake he will regret.
“Well, I might pay you about $75, but it isn't worth a cent more.”
Grandpa's offer, delivered like a man haggling over a used car: a token sum and not a penny more.
“I don't owe the government a cent.”
Grandpa's real position: he believes he has no debt to the state at all, so the tax is a game he refuses to play.
“Well, why not? Have they got fences?”
Grandpa's innocent question about interstate commerce, which reduces a legal system to a fence between states.

Theme

  • Class — Tony, a rich man's son, steps into a free-spirited house that treats the law and fine manners as optional.
  • Absurdity — A tax collector threatens jail while Grandpa answers with jokes, and a ballet teacher insults the family's night out.

Qué aprendes en este capítulo

Puntos de enseñanza

Repasa justo después de ver
Mi nivel4/7

A1–C2 es la escala MCER. Las tarjetas por encima del nivel elegido se atenúan y la reproducción no se pausa en ellas.

You Can't Take It with You: tu progreso

Capítulo 9 de 27 · quedan unos 58 min

← Anterior
Siguiente · 10as he pleasesLa escena: Alice Explains Her Family

Ideas clave

Lo que te llevas
  1. Everybody laughs except the man shouting.
  2. Grandpa treats the law as something he can haggle over.
  3. A guest's arrival makes the family chaos feel worse.
  4. The scene is funny because nobody takes the threat seriously.

Preguntas frecuentes

La pregunta, luego la frase
Why is the tax collector arguing with Grandpa?

Grandpa has never paid income tax and refuses to start, offering $75 and saying the government has no claim on him; the collector threatens jail to force payment.

Does Grandpa actually pay the tax?

No. He calls the whole argument a game, says he was only having fun with the collector, and insists he does not owe the government a cent.

Who is Kolenkhov?

Essie's Russian ballet teacher, who arrives for dinner and instantly declares the Monte Carlo Ballet, the show the family is going to, is terrible.

Why does Tony come to the house?

To meet Alice's family. He walks into the tax argument and the household's chaos, and simply takes it in without judging them.

What does "got another thing coming" mean here?

It means the collector is sure Grandpa is mistaken and will find out he cannot beat the law. It is a threat dressed up as advice.