00:00 / 02:06
00:00 / 02:06

Tony Introduces Alice to His Parents, Explained

Tony brings Alice to a grand club to meet his parents and a room full of aristocrats. His father is absorbed in his ancestry, while Tony mocks the whole idea: "all that family tree stuff went out with the buffalo." Alice answers a question about her own pedigree with a pun.

PartiesFirst datesTeasingExplainingStrangersB2mediumamericanClean

Key moments

Start here, then watch the full scene
  1. Kirby Boasts About His Ancestry

    1:20–1:44
    24s
  2. Alice's Family Tree Pun

    1:41–2:04
    23s

Tony Introduces Alice to His Parents, explained

What happens

Tony takes Alice to a fashionable club and introduces her to his mother, his father, Lord and Lady Melville, and the governor. His father is tracing the family tree and mentions the cost, while Tony jokes that ancestry is out of date. Alice deflects the question about her lineage with a joke about her name.

What's really going on

The chapter is the class gap made visible. Tony's family measures people by ancestry, and Kirby is literally paying to prove his bloodline, which is the film's neatest joke about inherited status. Alice is out of her depth and handles it well, refusing to be embarrassed. Her answer, that "a sycamore is a tree," turns the question into a pun and quietly declines to compete on their terms. Tony, meanwhile, sides openly with her, calling the whole ritual out of date. The scene matters because it shows Alice and Tony as a united front before the families ever meet.

Key lines & what they mean

“I thought all that family tree stuff went out with the buffalo.”
Tony's dismissal of ancestry, siding with Alice against his own family's values.
“My dear sir, don't you know that a sycamore is a tree?”
Alice's pun, turning a snobbish question into a joke she can win.
“No. It isn't you they are watching. It's Lord Melville.”
The reminder that attention here belongs to titles, which sets up the whole class theme.
“It cost me $5,000 last year to trace my family tree.”
Kirby's boast, showing that even ancestry is something he treats as a purchase.

Theme

  • Class — The club scene shows status measured by ancestry, and Kirby paying money to prove his bloodline.
  • Identity — Alice refuses to be ranked by pedigree, answering the family-tree question with a pun instead.

Qué aprendes en este capítulo

Puntos de enseñanza

Repasa justo después de ver
Mi nivel2/7

A1–C2 es la escala MCER. Las tarjetas por encima del nivel elegido se atenúan y la reproducción no se pausa en ellas.

You Can't Take It with You: tu progreso

Capítulo 12 de 27 · quedan unos 49 min

← Anterior
Siguiente · 13the wrong impressionLa escena: The Sycamores Prepare for the Kirbys

Ideas clave

Lo que te llevas
  1. A pun can win a room that pedigree cannot.
  2. Mr. Kirby buys status, but Tony refuses to admire it.
  3. Alice answers snobbery without ever raising her voice.
  4. Family trees were fashionable in 1938 high society.

Preguntas frecuentes

La pregunta, luego la frase
Why does Tony bring Alice to the club?

He wants her to meet his parents and the important guests, including a lord and a governor, even though she is nervous about being out of place.

Why is Kirby tracing his family tree?

He says America has become more conscious of background, and he has spent five thousand dollars to trace his ancestry.

What does Alice say about her own family tree?

When asked if she has one, she says that a sycamore is a tree, turning her surname into a joke instead of answering the question directly.

How does Tony feel about ancestry?

He thinks it is ridiculous. He says the whole family tree business went out with the buffalo and mocks his mother for taking it seriously.