00:00 / 02:13
00:00 / 02:13

Alice Explains Her Family, Explained

After grace, Grandpa mentions that Alice is going to be married, and Alice explains her family to Kolenkhov. The story is that everyone simply does what he likes: Grandpa quit business because he was not having fun, and Penny writes plays because a typewriter arrived by mistake.

Family dinnersSmall talkExplainingTeasingFriendsB2mediumamericanClean

Key moments

Start here, then watch the full scene
  1. ❝ Monólogo · 6 frases Grandpa's odd grace

    He reports a family's ordinary life like a progress note to heaven, and the solemn tone is the joke.

    0:28–0:56
    28s
  2. Why Grandpa Quit Business

    1:19–1:43
    24s
  3. Why Penny Writes Plays

    1:49–2:12
    23s
  1. ❝ MonólogoGrandpa's odd grace6 frasesPracticar ↗

Alice Explains Her Family, explained

What happens

Grandpa says grace and mentions Alice's coming marriage. Then Alice explains the household to Kolenkhov: her grandfather walked out of his business one day and took up stamp collecting, her father builds fireworks because he never grew up, and her mother began writing plays because a typewriter was delivered by mistake.

What's really going on

The chapter explains, with affection, why the Sycamores are the way they are. Each story is a small refusal of the ordinary: Grandpa quit a business career because "he wasn't having any fun," and Penny became a playwright because of a delivery error. The film is not mocking them. The point is that none of these lives was planned, and all of them are happy. Kolenkhov's line, that living with them is like a world Walt Disney might have thought of, is both a joke and the highest praise in the film. Against the Kirby household, where everything is arranged, this is the alternative.

Key lines & what they mean

“Living with them must be like living in a world that Walt Disney might have thought of.”
Kolenkhov's description of the household, part joke and part admiration.
“He could have been a rich man, but he said he wasn't having any fun.”
The explanation for Grandpa's choice, which the family treats as obviously correct.
“If it had been a plow, she'd have taken up farming?”
The joke that sums up Penny's approach to life, and the family's answer is yes.
“He started up in the elevator, turned 'round, came right down again and never went back.”
The vivid image of Grandpa quitting, a whole life changed in one ride.

Theme

  • Family love — Each Sycamore's odd pursuit is explained as a choice freely made, and the family is proud of every one.
  • Philosophy — The chapter argues that a life of doing what you enjoy beats a career built for money.

Qué aprendes en este capítulo

Puntos de enseñanza

Repasa justo después de ver
Mi nivel2/6

A1–C2 es la escala MCER. Las tarjetas por encima del nivel elegido se atenúan y la reproducción no se pausa en ellas.

You Can't Take It with You: tu progreso

Capítulo 10 de 27 · quedan unos 56 min

← Anterior
Siguiente · 11castles in the airLa escena: Tony and Alice Talk About Courage

Ideas clave

Lo que te llevas
  1. Alice describes her family without apologizing for it.
  2. A mistaken delivery becomes a life's work.
  3. Grandpa measures success by fun, not money.
  4. The visitor finds the chaos wonderful rather than strange.

Preguntas frecuentes

La pregunta, luego la frase
Why did Grandpa leave his business?

He said he was not having any fun. He walked into the elevator one day, turned around, came back down, and never returned to the office.

Why does Penny write plays?

Because a typewriter was delivered to the house by mistake eight years earlier. Alice jokes that if it had been a plow, her mother would have taken up farming.

Why does Paul make fireworks?

Alice says it is because he never grew up. He builds them for the pleasure of it, not for money.

How does Kolenkhov describe the family?

He says living with them must be like a world Walt Disney might have imagined, because everyone does exactly as he pleases.