you should talk

informal

used to tell somebody that they should not criticize others because they have the same fault themselves

30 movies869 YouTube videos · 442 channels

1 / 8

- You should talk! You've a whiny voice! - You sound like the mouse.

Manhattan (1979)

In the movies · 30

Watch it in all 30 movies

Meaning

used to tell somebody that they should not criticize others because they have the same fault themselves

Phrase guide

A closer look at this phrase

"You should talk" is an informal spoken retort used to accuse someone of hypocrisy when they criticize you. It carries a blunt, sarcastic tone and reminds the other person that they share the exact same fault. The expression is delivered as an ironic affirmative statement rather than a literal suggestion.

What it actually means

  • Accusing someone of hypocrisy

    Used to tell a person that they have no right to find fault with you because they are guilty of the same behavior.

    You are calling me disorganized? You should talk!

When you'd say it

  • A peer mocks your habits

    A friend criticizes your annoying manner of speaking, and you instantly retaliate by calling out their own grating voice.

    You should talk! You've a whiny voice!

    From Manhattan (1979) →
  • Someone questions your motives

    A colleague challenges your curiosity or questions, and you push back to show that they pry just as much.

    You should talk. Well, I just asked outta curiosity.

    From Slap Shot (1977)
  • A companion points out odd baggage

    An acquaintance teases you about strange possessions, but you abruptly remind them of their own peculiar shortcomings.

    You should talk, with those two submarines.

    From Monsieur Verdoux (1947)

More ways to use it

  1. You should talk! You've a whiny voice!

    Functions similarly to "Look who's talking," immediately flipping the critique back onto the accuser.

    From Manhattan (1979) →
  2. You should talk. Well, I just asked outta curiosity.

    Spoken casually and bluntly to deflect nosy remarks or mild reprimands.

    From Slap Shot (1977)
  3. You're lecturing me about spending too much money? You should talk!

    Commonly said with emphatic rising intonation to highlight an obvious double standard.

  4. He told everyone I was late to the meeting, but he should talk.

    The pronoun naturally shifts to "he" or "she" when discussing someone else's hypocrisy behind their back.

Common mistakes

  • You shouldn't talk! You did the exact same thing.You should talk! You did the exact same thing.

    Learners often default to negative logic, but native speakers use the affirmative form ironically.

  • You should talk me! You are always late too.You should talk! You are always late too.

    The idiom is a fixed standalone exclamation and does not take a direct object or preposition.

Similar & opposite phrases

Similar phrases

Learn it in full scenes

Questions

What does “you should talk” mean?
used to tell somebody that they should not criticize others because they have the same fault themselves
How is “you should talk” used?
It is an informal comeback spoken with a sarcastic or teasing tone during arguments or banter among friends, coworkers, or family.
Which movies use “you should talk”?
You can hear it in Fantasy Island (2020), Gone Baby Gone (2007), M3GAN (2022) and more (30 movies in total).
What are other ways to say “you should talk”?
look who's talking, you're one to talk

With Pro you also get

  • Unlimited any-language search · 200 AI breakdowns a day
  • Bilingual YouTube subtitles, any length (free: 15 min)
  • Download clips to replay offline · Card & Alipay
From $7.99/mo — see Pro →