open and shut case

formal

A matter, often a legal dispute, whose outcome is already obvious and leaves little room for argument.

4 movies166 YouTube videos · 111 channels

1 / 4

even when it's an open-and-shut case like this one.

12 Angry Men (1957)

In the movies · 4

Meaning

  1. Editorial100% of films

    A matter, often a legal dispute, whose outcome is already obvious and leaves little room for argument.

    • But... I'm sorry, this is an open-and-shut case of suicide
    • even when it's an open-and-shut case like this one.

Phrase guide

A closer look at this phrase

An open-and-shut case refers to a legal dispute or problem where the facts are so clear that the solution is immediately obvious. It carries a confident, formal tone often found in courtroom or investigative settings, though speakers frequently use it right before an unforeseen twist emerges.

What it actually means

  • Obvious and uncontroversial matter

    Describes a legal matter or dispute that requires little deliberation because clear evidence makes the outcome certain.

    With direct video evidence and two reliable witnesses, the theft was an open-and-shut case.

When you'd say it

  • Detective Reporting at a Crime Scene

    An investigator summarizes the initial forensic findings to colleagues to dismiss suspicions of foul play.

    this is an open-and-shut case of suicide

    From Knives Out (2019) →
  • Jury Member Discussing a Verdict

    A juror insists on careful deliberation even when guilt seems entirely clear to everyone in the room.

    even when it's an open-and-shut case like this one.

    From 12 Angry Men (1957) →
  • Frustrated Partner Challenging an Unexpected Delay

    A person confronts an associate when a task originally promised to be straightforward becomes complicated.

    You said this was an open and shut case.

    From Dhar Mann Studios →

More ways to use it

  1. It's an open-and-shut case, but there's just one problem.

    Speakers often follow this expression with 'but' to introduce an overlooked detail.

    From Oldboy (2013)
  2. To the average viewer clicking on this video, this is a pretty open-and-shut case.

    Informal spoken English often adds adverbs like 'pretty' or 'fairly' before the compound phrase.

    From YMS →
  3. Either way, prices are still a problem, more so here than most other countries around the world, and this makes it seem like a pretty open and shut case, right?

    The expression naturally expands from legal trials to straightforward economic and analytical arguments.

    From Economics Explained →
  4. The defense attorney warned his team never to assume a trial is an open-and-shut case.

    Hyphens are standard when the words serve together as a compound modifier directly preceding the noun.

Common mistakes

  • The mystery is very open and shut.The mystery is an open-and-shut case.

    The phrase almost always functions as a compound adjective modifying 'case' rather than standing alone as a predicate adjective.

  • The judge will open and shut the case tomorrow.The judge considered it an open-and-shut case.

    Do not treat the phrase as two separate verbs; it is an established idiomatic unit describing the nature of the situation.

Related phrases & origin

Similar phrases

  • slam dunk
  • clear-cut case

Origin

The phrase arose in 19th-century legal contexts. It compares a simple court trial to opening a case file and immediately shutting it because the verdict is already obvious.

Learn it in full scenes

Questions

What does “open and shut case” mean?
A matter, often a legal dispute, whose outcome is already obvious and leaves little room for argument.
How is “open and shut case” used?
It is frequently used in crime and legal contexts by detectives, lawyers, or judges, as seen in movies like Knives Out and 12 Angry Men. It can also describe any everyday problem that requires no debate.
Which movies use “open and shut case”?
You can hear it in 12 Angry Men (1957), Knives Out (2019), Oldboy (2013) and more (4 movies in total).
Where does “open and shut case” come from?
The phrase arose in 19th-century legal contexts. It compares a simple court trial to opening a case file and immediately shutting it because the verdict is already obvious.
What are other ways to say “open and shut case”?
slam dunk, clear-cut case

With Pro you also get

  • Unlimited any-language search · 200 AI breakdowns a day
  • Bilingual YouTube subtitles, any length (free: 15 min)
  • Download clips to replay offline · Card & Alipay
From $7.99/mo — see Pro →